We have a Bitty Baby and an American Girl Doll. My youngest, although it belongs to her older sister, loves Bitty Baby. My oldest loves her American Girl doll. My youngest, who is 4, also likes the Cabbage Patches, she has a set of twins. I do not think she has a favorite. She wants her own Bitty Baby. My MIL bought her sisters and said she didn't think our little one needed her own. I will have to try to take care of that for her.