Yes - and I did it anyway :)
I NEVER thought I would be comfortable with a homebirth even though I loved the idea in theory. I'm not totally mainstream, but I'm not that crunchy either. But I ended up with an unexpected c-section with my first and when I found myself pregnant again, I started considering it. I ended up choosing a homebirth because it seemed like my best chance not to end up with a second c-section. But I was so unsure I was well into my third trimester before I switched providers and I was still wavered every now and then. And in the end it came down to one thing for me - I REALLY trusted my midwife.
She was VERY experienced and calm and well known in our area so I got a lot of recommendations and I knew that she would know what to do in any situation that came up, would make great decisions and I totally trusted her.
And once I went into labor, I never had any doubts or worries at all. My labor was a long, back labor and I would do it all again in a second. I am SO glad I had a homebirth. And the bond with my second child was much more immediate which is very special to me.
I'm sure you will have a wonderful HBAC story to tell soon