Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Letter to DD's dentist
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Letter to DD's dentist  

post #1 of 16
Thread Starter 
Please let me know if this letter gets my point across in a polite, yet persuasive, manner. I don't nurse DD anymore but I was concerned because many of the parents in the waiting room appeared to be lower income and non-English speaking. These women need to be encouraged to bf, IMO.

Dear Dr. *****,

I want to thank you and your staff for the kind care you provided for my daughter, Molly, at her first dental visit. I know that good dental care is important for good dental health and I am pleased that she is going to be receiving her care from you.

I reviewed the papers that were sent home with me and found them to be very helpful and informative. However, I was saddened and concerned by one recommendation you made. The sheet detailing “Infant Dental Care” stated that babies should be weaned from the breast by the first birthday. Although I understand you are looking at how the behavior impacts a child’s dental health, I would urge you to adopt a broader perspective. National and international health organizations have made strong statements regarding the recommended time a child should be breastfed.

--The World Health Organization recommends breastfeeding for two years.
--The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends at least one year.
--The American Dietetic Association recommends at least one year.
--The American Academy of Family Physicians position paper on breastfeeding states that a child is at an increased risk for illness if weaned before two years of age.
--The National Association of Pediatric Nurse Practitioners says, in its position statement, that breastfeeding should continue for the first 12 months and beyond.
--A Health Canada report recommends breastfeeding for up to two years and beyond.
--UNICEF’s position is that mothers should continue to breastfeed for two years or more.

As a medical professional I know you are well aware of the benefits of breastfeeding, both for the baby and the mother, so I will not list them here. Unfortunately, many of the young mothers in our country, especially lower income and immigrant mothers, are not aware of the health benefits. And their babies may be the ones who would benefit the most from extended breastfeeding. Consequently, I feel your recommendation of weaning at one year is doing a disservice to your patients. A disservice that could result in health problems in the near future and for a lifetime, not to mention the loss of the intellectual and emotional benefits.

As a doctor your advice carries a lot of weight, especially for young mothers. I would ask that you alter your position on weaning and, instead, provide advice on how to successfully combine extended breastfeeding and good dental health. Suggest that baby’s nighttime routine include brushing after a final breastfeeding. Educate mothers whose children are breastfeeding and eating solid foods on how to avoid introducing sugar from food and beverages into the diet, a course of action recommended by the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry. A mother who is committed to extended breastfeeding has already made her child’s health a priority, and that would include dental health. Suggestions and advice from you on how to successfully combine breastfeeding and good dental health would be well received. I hope you will consider changing your “Infant Dental Care” guidelines to better reflect what I know is your desire for your patient’s medical and dental health. With the proper education the two do not need to be mutually exclusive.

Again, thank you for the time you took with Molly and me today. We look forward to seeing you in six months.

Sincerely,
post #2 of 16
I think that sounds excellent.
post #3 of 16


So well said, it is polite, informative and persuasive!
post #4 of 16
Super letter!
post #5 of 16
Good letter.

Quote:
I would ask that you alter your position on weaning
Instead of 'alter' I would use 'reconsider' because although obviously I would want a dentist to alter their opinion, I think they would take it better if I asked them to reconsider it and come to their own conclusion.

The other thing with you may want to bring up with a dentist is the issue of proper palate formation and the forces at work in the mouth when nursing, and how nursing helps the palate form correctly. There's got to be articles out there on this, but I don't know where. But even if you don't want to add this in, it's a good letter, and it's good of you to call the dentist on their handouts.

ETA: actually, there may be good links to articles and studies on this site:
http://www.brianpalmerdds.com/Default.htm
post #6 of 16
I think it's great. The only thing I would consider is re-wording or re-punctuating the paragraph that starts "As a medical professional..." because there are some incomplete sentences. ("And their babies..." and "A disservice...") I wasn't sure if you were doing that for stylistic reasons or not though.
post #7 of 16
I would include that the AAP says, "..and as long as desired by both mother and baby."

I'd also address the dental health concerns directly, I'm just going to copy and paste a list. I bolded the most important one. PM me if you'd like the full references!

Humans are the only mammals whose young suffer from dental decay, and prehistoric human skulls—before the introduction of a more processed diet—show no
incidence of dental caries (Palmer 2000).
• Studies that demonstrate a link between dental caries and extended breastfeeding often fail to control for confounding factors such as oral hygiene (e.g. Yonezu et al
2006).
• In populations with dental caries, exclusively breastfed children are rare (Hunter et al.,1997).
• The relationship between risk factors and caries development is complex, and multiple population based-studies do not support a relationship between extended
breastfeeding and early childhood caries (Hallonsten et al., 1995; Weeheijm, 1998; Slavkin, 1999: Valaitis et al., 2000; Hallett & O’Rourke, 2002.

• The cariogenicity of human milk is somewhat open to debate (Erickson, 1999; Peres et al., 2002; Bowen & Lawrence, 2005), but researchers and clinicians agree
that good oral hygiene is important for all children.

Good for you for sending this letter!
post #8 of 16
1 year is some what arbitrary when considering dental health because not all babies teeth during the same time periods. Some babies remain toothless for much of the 1st year, some are born with teeth. What is magical about 1 year that makes it a good cutoff?
post #9 of 16
great letter
post #10 of 16
I think it's a great letter.

I received a similar recommendation on papers from our pediatric dentist, and I took it up with him directly the next time we were in. He said that he would never, ever discourage breastfeeding, and said that he wouldn't even bring it up as an issue unless there was a serious decay problem - BUT that serious decay can be hastened and worsened with night nursing, and he would certainly address that in that situation.

So I felt a bit better, but I still asked if he could change the wording so it said "night-wean by a year" instead of "wean by a year". Still not perfect, but better... he said he would talk to the person responsible for writing the sheet, and he would look at the website I gave him (Dr. Palmer's).

I dunno - as the daughter of dental professionals (VERY pro-bf'ing dental professionals, I should add) I have some sympathy for dentists - it's so hard to get people to treat their teeth (and their kids' teeth) well that they tend to over-recommend in hopes that people will do just ONE or two of the things they say. And, sadly, a young toddler who does drive-by nursings all day whilst munching on raisins and arrowroot cookies will probably rot his teeth faster with the nursing than without, since the breastmilk will keep things nice and moist and sticky in there.
post #11 of 16
Thread Starter 
Thanks for all the feedback! I am going to make the adjustments/additions you all recommended and mail it off. Thanks again!!!
post #12 of 16
Quote:
And, sadly, a young toddler who does drive-by nursings all day whilst munching on raisins and arrowroot cookies will probably rot his teeth faster with the nursing than without, since the breastmilk will keep things nice and moist and sticky in there.
True, but wouldn't that apply equally to a toddler sucking on a sipply cup of milk or bottle of formula all day in between snacks? Its the snacking and drinking frequently without brushing, not the content (i.e. breastmilk vs. formula vs. cow's milk) that causes caries. So there's no reason to emphasize *weaning* when in fact you'd be better off limiting frequency of "drinks/snacks," and focusing on good dental hygiene.

Love the letter, BTW.
post #13 of 16
I'd remove this:

"Unfortunately, many of the young mothers in our country, especially lower income and immigrant mothers, are not aware of the health benefits. "

Otherwise it may just come across as ageist and elitist.
post #14 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by meganmarie View Post
True, but wouldn't that apply equally to a toddler sucking on a sipply cup of milk or bottle of formula all day in between snacks? Its the snacking and drinking frequently without brushing, not the content (i.e. breastmilk vs. formula vs. cow's milk) that causes caries. So there's no reason to emphasize *weaning* when in fact you'd be better off limiting frequency of "drinks/snacks," and focusing on good dental hygiene.
Yes, and the letter *I* got from our dentist (which I rather suspect is nearly the same as the OP's) says not to do ANY of those things. But, as I mentioned before, the best most dentists can hope for is that people follow one or two of their recommendations, so they plunk everything they can think of in there. Basically the point I was making was that in the presence of continual or very frequent sugar in the diet, breastmilk CAN contribute to tooth decay. If people aren't willing for whatever reason to ditch the sugary/starchy constant snacking, then stopping nursing WOULD actually help as far as cavity prevention goes. BUT BUT BUT please do not quote me as advocating this!!!! I am just saying that I understand where the dentists are coming from.
post #15 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by choli View Post
I'd remove this:

"Unfortunately, many of the young mothers in our country, especially lower income and immigrant mothers, are not aware of the health benefits. "

Otherwise it may just come across as ageist and elitist.
Yeah that!, I think that you have very good intentions to protect a one group of the most "vulnerable " mothers.
I love you letter, if the dentist is going to makes the review of the information the bring to the parents that going to be a impact in many lives.
post #16 of 16
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by isabchi View Post
Yeah that!, I think that you have very good intentions to protect a one group of the most "vulnerable " mothers.
I love you letter, if the dentist is going to makes the review of the information the bring to the parents that going to be a impact in many lives.
I changed it to
Unfortunately, many of the mothers in our country are not aware of the health benefits.

And took out the line about their babies benefiting the most.

It was just so obvious in the waiting room that most of the patients didn't speak English (using a staff member to translate forms), that is why I had included it. but don't want to offend since it could be touchy anyway, thanks for the advice.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lactivism
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Letter to DD's dentist