Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › Poll: Do you do WBV
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Poll: Do you do WBV - Page 2  

Poll Results: Do you do Well baby/child Visits?

 
  • 2% (5)
    Yes, we do WBV on schedule and vax on schedule.
  • 13% (23)
    Yes, we do WBV on schedule and selectively/delay vax.
  • 23% (41)
    Yes, we do WBV and do not vax.
  • 0% (0)
    We go twice a year and vax on schedule.
  • 1% (2)
    We go twice a year and selectively vax.
  • 2% (5)
    We go twice a year and do not vax.
  • 0% (0)
    We go once a year and vax on schedule.
  • 0% (1)
    We go once a year and selectivly vax.
  • 6% (12)
    We go once a year and do not vax.
  • 0% (0)
    We only go as needed to the doctor and vax.
  • 2% (4)
    We only go as needed to the doctor and selectively vax.
  • 42% (73)
    We only go as needed and do not vax.
  • 3% (6)
    Obligatory Other.
172 Total Votes  
post #21 of 40
We only go when needed. Which turns out to be not very often even with 7 kids. I think I was at the drs twice this year with 2 kids. And I am only guessing on the 2nd one. lol That could have been last year.
post #22 of 40
We don't vax, we do periodic WBV's, but not as often as we would if we were vaxing.
post #23 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanidFL View Post
We do WBV and do not vax. I will do the same for the next one too.
I do too, but just to have him weighed/measured. I really like my family doctor, and she doesn't give out parenting advice, she's located nearby, and I'm in Canada so there's no charge. : I can't think of any reason not to go.

Oh, and for me, the information on file came in handy when DS had weight loss issues in the Fall. We know how much he weighed then and now. I could have done it all on a bathroom scale, but my doctor was very willing to refer us to an allergist too.

ETA: I don't think DS is asked to come in as often as vax'd kids. She always has to think really hard when telling me when the next appt will be.
post #24 of 40
Don't Vax, don't go, but...

I did go with DS 1 as I felt we needed a relationship with the Dr. That was not going well, so we stopped going and then moved. Now I'll see the midwife/naturopath who delivered DS 2 if they get seriously ill.

We all went in to see a nearby allopathic Dr. last year and that was just to say hi and get on her patient load. Have not seen her since. Hope to not need to.

Julia
post #25 of 40
I voted that we go to all Well Child checkups but we delay and very selectively vaccinate. I just grew up with the notion that well child checks are part of the routine. And it helps that we have a vax-friendly doctor that has never harrassed us in any way at the appts.
post #26 of 40
Apparently I am in the minority here, because I do think that WBV are important (and not just for my special needs son, but for my "typical" son, too). I am not a dr, there are things that I'm not trained to look for. I know the basics of child development, I know the basics of the common illnesses, I have common sense. But that isn't always enough.

For example, a coworker's baby was just at her 6 month WBV and the dr noted that her feet can bend up to touch her shins, which will likely delay her walking and she may need some braces. I would not have known to look for that, and if this mom had not done WBV, she would not have known until her daughter was actually delayed in walking, and would have missed key months for physical therapy and potential bracing.

A Pediatrician noticed my son's eye turning out, and I even specifically knew to be on the lookout for that because of a strong family history of lazy eye. But I hadn't noticed it. We were able to get him to an ophthalmologist quickly.

I can't see inside my childrens' ears, and there aren't always outward signs of issues.

A routine iron check at the 12 month WBV showed my oldest to be slightly anemic, so I knew to make an effort to give him more iron-rich foods. I would not have known that if we hadn't had it checked.

A pattern of growth and development is very helpful to have in the off chance that something does come up (an illness, an injury, loss of developmental milestones, etc) Establishing a base line for temperature and blood pressure could be helpful as well.

Both of my sons have sacral dimples, which could be signs of tethered cords. Since I also have a sacral dimple and it's never been an issue, I thought nothing of it. A Pediatrician noticed my son's and immediately sent us for an xray and ultrasound. It turns out my mom also had those tests done on me to rule out spinal issues, but I didn't know it. I just thought it was a dimple!

I don't see going to WBV a problem at all. If you choose not to vax (we don't) then a short simple "we're not choosing to vax at this appt, thank you" is often all that's needed (I heavily edited the vax refusal form and feel confident and comfortable just saying "no thank you" at each appt). I let the parenting advice roll right off me, unless I have a specific question or issue. I carefully guard my sons' foreskins. So aside from a co-pay, it's no skin off my back, and potentially very helpful for my children.

A small price to pay, in my opinion.
post #27 of 40
We do all WBV's. We do delayed, selective vaxing. I like seeing how big my kids are getting, and our ped is very AP friendly. THe doctor knows that I keep myself well-educated, and we keep each other up on things we learn. For instance, the doctor had never heard of people giving avocado as a first food. When I told her that DD was eating just avocado, no cereal (at 8 months) she was a little startled but then told me that was great, why didn't she think of it. Now she tells all her families to start with avocado. She also brags about me to the doctors and nurses at the hospital. When iw as in the hospital having DS, I overheard her talking about me, telling the nurse I had nursed until DD2 was 3 and how fantastic that was, and she wishes I could start a class or something. That felt good.

So for me, WBV's are as much an opportunity to learn about my children's growth as it is to talk to a doctor who has become an old friend.
post #28 of 40
We do not vax and only do well baby visits for the first 6 to 12 months. I am about to have my third though and those wbv may be even less. I hate taking a small baby in an office full of germs.

It's funny when someone asks you how much your baby weighs or what percentile they are in. I think we just say normal.
post #29 of 40
I just "Asked the Expert" Bob Sears this same question.

I am not going to be vaccinating my newborn (baby #3 BTW) at all. Are there any other health reasons, besides vaccinations, to attend the so-called well baby visits—especially if my baby seems healthy, happy, and growing fine, according to the charts?

Answer:Yes, there are. A good physical exam every few months is important—there are a variety of health and physical problems that can come up that a parent wouldn't always notice. Since these problems aren't common, you could argue that checkups are a waste of time and money for everyone who has a normal checkup. But for those who end up having a problem that can be treated or addressed with a better outcome because it was found early, they're well worth it. So, in my mind, it's worth doing. In my practice, I do every other checkup with babies who aren't vaccinated.
post #30 of 40
We don't vax, and our doc never harassed me about it. He gave me his "professional opinion" about it, and then left it at that. That is why I felt comfortable coming back to him for her regular WBV the first year. And I just wanted to get her weighed and measured frequently for her baby book.

After the first year, he moved, and I had a bad feeling about the person who took over, so we dropped that practice and it took me a year to find another one I really liked and felt comfortable with. Well, 6 months to find them, and another 6 months on the waiting list.
post #31 of 40
I didn't take DD3 to the doctor for almost two years. Finally, took her just so that I would have relationship with a doc for if/when she got sick. She's never been sick to the point of needing to go. She only had her 4mo vax.

DD6months has only been for the two week checkup and one WBV that was really late. Again, just so that I'd have a working relationship with a pediatrician. We haven't been back. They haven;t noticed
post #32 of 40
We have done WBV on time but from now on it will be once a year unless something concerns me. I dont think I will do WBV as often with the next baby.
post #33 of 40
I do WBV on schedule. We do not vaccinate at all.

I like having the paper trail should I ever have to deal with DHS (god forbid)
post #34 of 40
We don't vax and do all WBV. I LOVE our ped so I'm sure we might do otherwise if I couldn't find a ped we loved who supported our decision etc.
post #35 of 40
We selectively vaccinate and we do all WBVs. I like to have a good relationship with a doctor who knows my children when they are well. The last thing I want is to be calling a pediatrician who has little to no relationship with me or my child at 3 AM when there's a serious concern. I also think it shows respect for the doctor to bring my children in for visits when he thinks it's appropriate. If I want him to have respect for me and my kids, I don't think being a "rebel" and acting like I know better than him is going to facilitate that.

I also think my doctor, through getting to know me at WBVs, has come to realize that I have a very good medical knowledge base and and pretty good sense when it comes to my kids, so he trusts me to make the best decisions for them, rather than thinking I'm just some radical "mama" who got nutty ideas off the internet and is jumping on the "OMG VACCINES ARE THE DEVIL!" bandwagon because it happens to be en vogue at the moment. He hears me out, trusts that I've done research and made a truly informed and well-reasoned choice.
post #36 of 40
:
post #37 of 40
We've never actually *needed* to take our son to the doctor, we did regular visits until 6 months and haven't bothered to go back since (DS is almost 3 years). I think we'll go in for a visit with this next babe around 1 month to get him or her registered as a patient of his and stuff. DS has only had a handful of colds and flus and bumps and bruises, nothing serious in his life. DH and myself haven't needed doctors but about 3 times in our lives each.
post #38 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by 2boyzmama View Post
Apparently I am in the minority here, because I do think that WBV are important (and not just for my special needs son, but for my "typical" son, too). ...

A Pediatrician noticed my son's eye turning out, and I even specifically knew to be on the lookout for that because of a strong family history of lazy eye. But I hadn't noticed it. We were able to get him to an ophthalmologist quickly.
.....
A routine iron check at the 12 month WBV showed my oldest to be slightly anemic, so I knew to make an effort to give him more iron-rich foods. I would not have known that if we hadn't had it checked.

A small price to pay, in my opinion.

Same here. DD strabismus and iron deficiency was picked up in a WBV. Also her weight issue (low) has been tracked.

I think it is negligent of any one here to recommend to someone else to skip a WBV in order to skip vaccines. That is a responsibility I would not want to shoulder. Everyone here seems to want to direly protect the vulnerable babies but they don't think twice against discrediting any need for a WBV when there are things that could be picked up early and dealt with before becoming a problem for a small infant. But then again, the backbone of MDC is about bucking the system so it sort of falls in line with the ideals. But it makes me sad, particularly when people recommend this for new moms who don't have alot of baby experience and might not be able to recognize symptoms based on comparative experience.

So yes, we have kept up on WBV and don't vax.

I would much rather people encourage parents to take their kids to a doctor and continue to give them tools and tips on how to deal with not vaxing than to just skip the visits altogether. I would rather see all the great tips on being assertive, how to respond, how to stand up for one's rights, etc.
post #39 of 40
Interesting thread! I've been curious how many do WBV's and pay for the visit out of pocket. (Different poll, I guess!) No health insurance here, by choice.
post #40 of 40
I voted we go once a year and do not vax. That is not toltally right though. We went pretty much on schudule until one. Then every 6 months until 2. Now once a year. With ds1 we are there much more often because he has serious allergy issues and is always ill. With ds2 we are there about once a year plus when needed which has only been once since he was a baby.

As for importance, the ped flagged ds2's autism before I really thought something was that "off". He had no super noticable delays so that has helped us a lot. There was a very big chance that nobody else would have noticed until he was in school and having problems. She has also been a big advocate for getting help and services for ds1. I think it's mportant to have a good relationship with your child's health care provider. I don't think she tries to push meds on us. She wanted a few more people to evaluate ds1 before we could put him on any meds for the psych stuff going on with him last year. Those evals took us through the worst of his behavior and we were able to decide for him not to get meds before we even started. She is also against the overuse of antibiotics.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Vaccinations
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › Poll: Do you do WBV