Audrey Niffenegger - The Time Traveler's Wife is what I was going to recommend. I think it fits your description - creepy, supernatural, romance really well.
If you like the Twilight books you might like Sunshine by Robin McKinley. Different vampires, parallel world and some romance in a gothic sort of way. (Gothic in the 19th century romance version of the word not visigoths, flying buttresses or black clothing.)
I utterly agree about Neil Gaiman. I'm currently reading Ananzi Boys and DH just finished The Graveyard Book. You might try American Gods. Coraline is awesome. I can't wait for the movie.
If you like the Twilight books you might like Sunshine by Robin McKinley. Different vampires, parallel world and some romance in a gothic sort of way. (Gothic in the 19th century romance version of the word not visigoths, flying buttresses or black clothing.)
I utterly agree about Neil Gaiman. I'm currently reading Ananzi Boys and DH just finished The Graveyard Book. You might try American Gods. Coraline is awesome. I can't wait for the movie.








