These aren't the same size. I finished the first one while at home and then started the second one. We got packed up and headed to Utah the next day. I packed some knitting and after getting on the road realied I was going to be cutting it short. Very short. I had to nix out a couple of garter rows and had to bind off with a size 6 needle (instead of my g hook I used for the ties...I think it was a g hook 
). I much prefer the first one. It fits the cup better.
The first one
The second
All I had left
I have to make one more for my mom's cup and then I'm good to go. My dad and his girlfriend really liked them. These are super easy and super fun and nice. The pattern is written a bit large. I cut out a few rows on the final little batch of 4x1 ribbing (I just wanted to be done...I only did 5 rows) and it ended up being perfect. Had I done more it would have been too tall. I saw on Ravelry someone else had that issue so I kept that in mind while I was knitting.
). I much prefer the first one. It fits the cup better.The first one
The second
All I had left
I have to make one more for my mom's cup and then I'm good to go. My dad and his girlfriend really liked them. These are super easy and super fun and nice. The pattern is written a bit large. I cut out a few rows on the final little batch of 4x1 ribbing (I just wanted to be done
...I only did 5 rows) and it ended up being perfect. Had I done more it would have been too tall. I saw on Ravelry someone else had that issue so I kept that in mind while I was knitting.
