Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Hopefully I got through...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Hopefully I got through...  

post #1 of 13
Thread Starter 
My 17 year old niece is due any day. They were here on Sunday for James'
3rd birthday.

Anyway they were discussing gift from her shower and she mentioned getting vaseline. I took the opportunity to bring up circ. Evidently she hadn't decided yet.

So I started giving her the information, her Mom breaks in with about it being so hard to clean. I told her that it wasn't true and that you just wipe it off like a finger. She told me the only reason she had it done to her son years ago was because they told her it had to be retracted at every diaper change and cleaned with a Qtip. I told her that's what they used to think, but now they know better. Her Mom seemed upset that she was misled.

She then mentioned how horrible it was to watch. DN says she wouldn't watch. I told her if she didn't have the guts to watch then she shouldn't put her son through it. And her Mom agreed with me!

So I print off the Nocirc pamplets and give them to DN, and then my DSIS decdes to join the conversation. She starts in about the old men in the nursing home. I tell her that's a stupid reason to do it, since DS may never even end up in a nursing home. Then I ask DSIS what parts does she recommend cutting off the women to keep them clean. She then states it's not a problem with women, and I said, "How can that be? Women have far more nooks and crannys then men." She didn't have an answer for that.

Then she tried to pull the religion card, so I reached over to the computer and printed off the article about Christian and circs. So DSIS reads the article and has to admit her reasons are all garbage. I even think she may have changed her mind a little.

So then I find out she's having the baby in the same hospital as I had James. I tell her they won't even do it there and she'll have to take the baby later for it to be done. She didn't seem to like that idea.

So all in all, I think I may have influenced her not to do it. But I'm not real sure. So say a prayer for little Riley.

Terri
post #2 of 13
Wow Terri! I'm impressed! I think you did a great job educating quite a few people there.
post #3 of 13
Sounds like you got though is the babies father involved? Could he be a problem.
post #4 of 13
Congrats! And way to be calm, cool and collected, I'm sure that helped your position so much!

I have to ask if you don't mind, maybe it's just pregnancy brain but I can't figure out DSIS. I've run through every family member designation I can think of. Please tell me which one I'm missing. Thanks!
post #5 of 13
Sounds like a win! ::::


Give her the Dr. Fleiss article about protecting her intact son too. That is a very important one!
post #6 of 13
Nice job! Sounds like you were able to articulate all of the correct information in a way that reached her. Proud of you!
post #7 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by IlluminatedAttic View Post
I have to ask if you don't mind, maybe it's just pregnancy brain but I can't figure out DSIS.
I didn't figure it out either and I haven't had pregnancy brain for years. I just thought maybe it was dear sister in law???? Not sure though.
post #8 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by Night_Nurse View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by IlluminatedAttic View Post
I have to ask if you don't mind, maybe it's just pregnancy brain but I can't figure out DSIS. I've run through every family member designation I can think of. Please tell me which one I'm missing. Thanks!
I didn't figure it out either and I haven't had pregnancy brain for years. I just thought maybe it was dear sister in law???? Not sure though.
I'm guessing "dear sister" not to be confused with "dear son" (DS).
post #9 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by notjustmamie View Post
I'm guessing "dear sister" not to be confused with "dear son" (DS).
Ahh! That makes perfect sense. Thanks!
post #10 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by greenrosemom4 View Post
My 17 year old niece is due any day. They were here on Sunday for James'
3rd birthday.

Anyway they were discussing gift from her shower and she mentioned getting vaseline. I took the opportunity to bring up circ. Evidently she hadn't decided yet.

So I started giving her the information, her Mom breaks in with about it being so hard to clean. I told her that it wasn't true and that you just wipe it off like a finger. She told me the only reason she had it done to her son years ago was because they told her it had to be retracted at every diaper change and cleaned with a Qtip. I told her that's what they used to think, but now they know better. Her Mom seemed upset that she was misled.

She then mentioned how horrible it was to watch. DN says she wouldn't watch. I told her if she didn't have the guts to watch then she shouldn't put her son through it. And her Mom agreed with me!

So I print off the Nocirc pamplets and give them to DN, and then my DSIS decdes to join the conversation. She starts in about the old men in the nursing home. I tell her that's a stupid reason to do it, since DS may never even end up in a nursing home. Then I ask DSIS what parts does she recommend cutting off the women to keep them clean. She then states it's not a problem with women, and I said, "How can that be? Women have far more nooks and crannys then men." She didn't have an answer for that.

Then she tried to pull the religion card, so I reached over to the computer and printed off the article about Christian and circs. So DSIS reads the article and has to admit her reasons are all garbage. I even think she may have changed her mind a little.

So then I find out she's having the baby in the same hospital as I had James. I tell her they won't even do it there and she'll have to take the baby later for it to be done. She didn't seem to like that idea.

So all in all, I think I may have influenced her not to do it. But I'm not real sure. So say a prayer for little Riley.

Terri

Wow, your amazing. Great job!
post #11 of 13
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by notjustmamie View Post
I'm guessing "dear sister" not to be confused with "dear son" (DS).
Yep, she's my dear sister, unless she's spouting her old men in the nursing home reason, then she's not so dear.

Terri
post #12 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by notjustmamie View Post
I'm guessing "dear sister" not to be confused with "dear son" (DS).
Quote:
Originally Posted by greenrosemom4 View Post
Yep, she's my dear sister, unless she's spouting her old men in the nursing home reason, then she's not so dear.

Terri
Thank you! I would have laid awake in bed tonight trying to solve this puzzle.
post #13 of 13
: good going mama
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Hopefully I got through...