Favorite Knitted Soaker Pattern?

[motherbirth]

So far I have tried making the Curly Purly Soaker and the Little Turtle Knits soaker pattern (I can't find the link to the pattern I bought, I bought it to make a soaker for a friend and then made one for myself too).

I just saw this Little Turtle Knits wrap pattern, and I was thinking of trying the Punk Knits soaker pattern.

I haven't used either cover I made yet... I think I like the Curly Purly one better because it has ribbed cuffs around the legs (the Punk Knits one has the same option). The LTK one just has leg openings and they don't seem stretchy enough.

Has anyone used any of these knitted covers and found one is easier/better than another? I didn't want to make a bunch in one style and then find out that I didn't like them.

[Michigan Mama]

I just made a curlypurly and I like it, but I don't think I picked up enough stitches around the legs, they are just a smidge tight. I did another one that was knitted flat, not in the round, and I don't like that one so well. Can't remember the name.