Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › New Member
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

New Member  

post #1 of 11
Thread Starter 
Hi everyone!

My name's Val, and I'm new to the group (I've actually been somewhat of a lurker for about 2 months). My husband found this site for me because our pediatrician recently retracted our son's foreskin as far as he could force it to go-my son said it brought tears to his eyes, and there was a tiny amount of blood in his underwear later ! My son is seven, and not retractile- the opening of the inner foreskin is very small, but he has no trouble urinating, so I'm hoping that's not an indication that something is wrong. He has never had a problem with his foreskin until recently, when he suddenly had burning while urinating. I took him to the pediatrician to make sure he didn't have a UTI. At least the doctor did recognize that it was just an irritation, which cleared up right away by following his advice to soak in plain water and eliminate any sitting in sudsy water at bath time. But I couldn't believe he thought he needed to push my son's foreskin back so hard! Now I'm vacillating between anger at the doctor's ignorance, and worry that he caused damage, or that there really is something abnormal about this non-retractile state at age 7. Does anyone else have older sons with non-retractile foreskins? When he pushed the foreskin back, the doctor exclaimed in a shocked tone that my son has "phimosis" and "adhesions", and that it will have to be addressed if he "wants to lead a normal life", all right in front of my son, of course: I have talked to Marilyn Milos (sp?), and the attorney for DOC, and feel a little better, but now have the seemingly impossible task of finding a good doctor who knows normal anatomy and physiology! Does anyone know of a good pediatrician in SE Wisconsin?
post #2 of 11
Welcome to MDC!

It's totally NORMAL for a boy to not retract till much later.

These two links will help you to see that what your doctor did to your son was very wrong and possibly harmful:

A Warning For Parents of Intact Sons http://www.mothering.com/discussions...d.php?t=129378

The Definition of "Retraction" & Why it is BAD http://www.mothering.com/discussions...d.php?t=575627
post #3 of 11
Wow, thats horrible. I know you have been told the right information, but just to make you feel more secure, as a guy who has intact friends, i can say there is ABSOLUTELY nothing wrong with your son's penis. There are guys who go into their teen years who cant retract yet, its NORMAL!


Even if your son could NEVER retract his whole life, he would still be able to pee properly, and he could still masturbate and have sex. Your right, this doctor is horrible and I hope he is given all the correct information and that DOC deals with him properly!
post #4 of 11
There is or was a list here with Dr who are foreskin friendly.

If you cant find a Dr who is then you can simply refuse any genital exam by a Dr. or have your ds show the Dr his penis without the Dr ever touching it.

I am sorry your ds was hurt. Odds are that nothing bad will happen if it hasnt already.

A thread you should read http://www.mothering.com/discussions...d.php?t=764732 It talks about things that happen that are normal and not normal and how to deal with them.

If you know what is going on then you can avoid going to the Dr. most of the time. And it will help ease your mind to know things are normal.
post #5 of 11
There's nothing abnormal about a 7yr old not retracting yet. My 7.5 yr. old doesn't yet either. If he has anymore irritation ect adding baking soda to his bath water can really help.

I'm so sorry the doctor's ignorance hurt your son, he should have not retracted him.
I really wish doctors would get educated about normal penis care and stop hurting little boys.
post #6 of 11
Retracting may not be present until your son has reached the end of puberty, which in some people may be 20+ years. Retracting is not necessary at 7 years old, and it is not a sign of any pathology.
I hope this helps.
P.S. welcome to the boards!
post #7 of 11
Great correct advice above.
Educate the ill-informed incompetent doctor who injured your son. I would suggest a follow-up letter written and signed by you and your husband addressed to him and the admin. or the clinic or hospital for which he is affiliated. Explain what occurred and why it is damaging. Also ask Atty. John Geisheker from DOC org. to send a letter of complaint and education on the development of the prepuce in children and the harm of forced retractions. He does it for free, however, I sent him a small donation to DOC as sincere graditude after he sent a letter at my request to a pediatrician who forcibly retracted a 4 yr. old boy causing crying pain and swelling of the boy's penis.

How many young, undeveloped, intact little boys need to suffer like your son or worse yet, end up getting circumcised due to "phimosis" and "adhesions"! It makes me sick! This is 2009 and this abuse happens all the time in America, hundreds a time a day I bet by ignorant, "licensed" physicians. It is scary that it continues at such an alarming high rate. However, fight back and protect all boys by letting this doctor (and ALL others who harm) know what he did is grounds for malpractice and he needs to STOP!

Good Luck in finding an intact educated doc. In the meantime, while searching, be upfront and quiz docs. by asking them relavant questions. Let them know where you stand on circ. and what you know about prepuce develop. and no retraction. Before every exam remind the doc. and be on alert that no retraction occurs. Only your boy should retract to the point that does not cause pain.

Best Regards and kudos to you and your husband for leaving your precious, perfectly made son intact.
post #8 of 11
To me, that sounds like sexual assault!

I mean, if the doc had "opened up" a girl's vagina, causing tears and bleeding... that would clearly be a violation.

This is no different, to my way of thinking.

I'd be thinking about filing suit. What the doc did just isn't right.
post #9 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by momval View Post
When he pushed the foreskin back, the doctor exclaimed in a shocked tone that my son has "phimosis" and "adhesions", and that it will have to be addressed if he "wants to lead a normal life", all right in front of my son, of course:
This person believes circumcised is normal and normal is abnormal, he is clearly insane.

Retracting foreskins plays a major role in perpetuating circ in the USA.
post #10 of 11
Have you visited the Finding Your Tribe forums yet? Here is the one for Wisconsin. Hopefully if you post a thread in there looking for a good doctor, you'll get a good lead.
post #11 of 11
I have an intact friendly family practitioner in SE Wisconsin..I'll PM you his name.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › New Member