Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › My baby gets upset when I don't understand what she wants.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

My baby gets upset when I don't understand what she wants.  

post #1 of 20
Thread Starter 
My baby is 13 month old and of course she can't talk yet. Sometimes she uses her finger to show something and says something, and of course I can't understand. But she becomes very angry because I don't do what she wants.

Can you tell me how to deal with this? I usually end up giving her something to get her pay attention on it, so she'll forget what she wanted me to do before. Should I do that? Is there any other way?

Thanks.
post #2 of 20
Your method is fine-- whatever gets you through the day, you know. You can also try teaching her some sign language (there are DVDs to help with that), because babies that age can often sign better than they can talk with their mouths. DS's daycare uses baby sign language for that reason, to help keep the babies calm.

Eventually she will (1) learn to talk, and (2) develop a sense of time so that she can be more patient, and this will resolve on its own. Meanwhile, try to do a lot of relaxation exercises to keep this stage from driving you nuts!
post #3 of 20
OH I've so been there. My youngest DSD really had a hard time with this. She knew what she wanted, knew what we were saying, but couldn't communicate back. We didn't know what to do then, but with my nearly 1 yo DD we've been using sign language. We've checked out Singing Time videos from the library, they use American Sign Language. DD has been able to pick up on alot of the signs we've used. She mostly signs for milk and eat, sometimes she signs more. I've also taught her random things like snow (she was fascinated by snow falling) and we're working on please and thank you. Already she's learning the tools to at least tell us a few things, which I think help her a great deal.
post #4 of 20
With dd, signing REALLY helped at that age. We used the Signing Time videos.

-Angela
post #5 of 20
Ditto on the sign language. And you can simply pick up a sign language dictionary at the bookstore or library to pick and choose the words you want to teach her. A few basic words were invaluable for us:
food/eat (to ask if she's hungry)
more (which can be used for more food, more reading, more playing, etc.)
drink (to ask if thirsty)
all done


The other thing I'd suggest doing is ask her to show you what she wants, to take you to it. If she can't reach, pick her up so she can. That helped a lot when I couldn't understand my kids' words. I would usually say, "I'm sorry, I don't understand what you're saying. Can you show me what you want? Can you take me to it?"

HTH
post #6 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by jenmk View Post
Ditto on the sign language. And you can simply pick up a sign language dictionary at the bookstore or library to pick and choose the words you want to teach her. A few basic words were invaluable for us:
food/eat (to ask if she's hungry)
more (which can be used for more food, more reading, more playing, etc.)
drink (to ask if thirsty)
all done


The other thing I'd suggest doing is ask her to show you what she wants, to take you to it. If she can't reach, pick her up so she can. That helped a lot when I couldn't understand my kids' words. I would usually say, "I'm sorry, I don't understand what you're saying. Can you show me what you want? Can you take me to it?"

HTH
I totally agree with this. My son actually started to talk and sign at the same time- around 11 mos, and just used the sign language to basically double his vocabulary for several months. I just checked out a kids ASL book from the library, no classes, DVDs, etc. (I was also lucky to have an ASL translator at my department, from time to time I would ask for her help in modifying a sign to make it appropriate for a baby to do). In addition to body needs such as those listed above, he liked to point things out to us- He did a lot of animal words, vehicles (airplane, bike, truck, car, train). He could ask for a book, say he was tired, ask for a clean diaper, ask to get down, ask to nurse or for a pacifier. He also made up some of his own signs (like he made up a sign for the trash truck, for a hood- as opposed to a hat- stuff like that, it was pretty neat!)

I did the latter with a girl I nannied for (who is now 12!), I would carry her around to try and figure out what she was after. I'd never heard of baby signs at the time, but as soon as I did (I was pregnant at the time) a lightbulb went off in my head, I thought how much she would have LOVED it. She was really struggling to let her needs be known.

Its easy- introduce a couple of signs at first for topics that come up a lot, and just sign and say the word together. (I think the above ideas are good- food/eat, drink, all done/all gone, more. I'd also add sleep, and nurse, pacifier, milk or something for other comfort needs, and maybe a few words for favorite toys or activities?) Add them slowly (for you, not for her, once she "gets it" she can learn them really fast, but you have to remember them!) Babies can point really well, can use a pincer grip, and their hand as a unit. They aren't really good at separating their fingers so some signs that require a lot of dexterity can be frustrating for them and you might want to modify or choose a simpler way to sign those concepts.

Of course, it doesn't end all frustrations. But it makes it much easier in that day to day way, and honestly its really fun- and funny- to get to talk with your baby.
post #7 of 20
We've recently been working on signing. It has helped soooo much. She can now tell me when she wants out of her chair, wants a diaper change, when she wants to find the cat and when she wants to read a book. It has cut the outbursts in half. She is also 13 months old.
post #8 of 20
Signing helped us a lot too.

But here's something else I did. I would touch my son's arm or hand and get down and look at him and say, calmly and cheerfully, "I don't understand! But hold on and we'll figure it out. We'll work it out together! Be patient baby!" or something similar. And then I would work to try to figure it out, again, calmly.

Mostly we did and sometimes we didn't. But it started to work where he would understand that we were going to work on it together and he would calm down when I would say that... and still does, at 3.5. It's only true after all.
post #9 of 20
I agree with teaching sign language. We bought a book and started using signs around 6 months. DS started signing back around 8 months.

At his 18 month check up we tried a new pediatrician and the guy asked how many words DS used. At the time DS didn't have many verbal words but he knew so many signs (I'd have to get his baby book to remember). We told the doc and he said "oh, sign language" with an eye roll and then said "it's not a recognized language, how many words can he say."

We were so surprised - what does he think American Sign Language is? Duh.

Needless to say we didn't go back to him. Now DS has a huge vocabulary and is super verbal. I think part of that is because of the early sign language. His brain was able to start working on communication before his body was ready to "speak" words. Kind of a jump start thing.

Best part was it did cut down on the frustration for him. He soaked up the signs we taught him and if he didn't have one he'd invent one. It's worth a try.
post #10 of 20
I agree with trying signing. We got the Baby Signing Time DVDs and love them. I think they're great for me because I can see kids making the sign so it's easier to tell what ds is trying to sign. He adores the videos and is using so many signs now. We started around 12-13 months. You can find them at www.babysigningtime.com
Good luck!
post #11 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cheshire View Post

At his 18 month check up we tried a new pediatrician and the guy asked how many words DS used. At the time DS didn't have many verbal words but he knew so many signs (I'd have to get his baby book to remember). We told the doc and he said "oh, sign language" with an eye roll and then said "it's not a recognized language, how many words can he say."

We were so surprised - what does he think American Sign Language is? Duh.
Um. What would he ask the parents of a deaf baby to assess development? Or for that matter the baby of deaf parents? Good lord.
post #12 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by lolar2 View Post
Um. What would he ask the parents of a deaf baby to assess development? Or for that matter the baby of deaf parents? Good lord.
Ironic b/c the whole "baby signs" thing took off when research consistently found that children of Deaf parents developed language *earlier* than those of hearing parents (contrary to what many had expected to find).

I also agree with a PP that a gentle physical touch along with eye contact can help reassure your preverbal child that you *are* trying to understand her!
post #13 of 20
Exactly!
post #14 of 20
Thread Starter 
Thanks all. I'll certainly get one of those DVDs to get to understand DD.
Btw, usually when did you start teaching LO sign language and how long did it take LO to learn the first few sign language?
post #15 of 20
With dd we signed from around 4 or 5 months? And she was signing back around 9 or 10 months as I recall.

Ds we've signed since birth, and I think we're seeing some signs now- he's 8 months.

-Angela
post #16 of 20
I signed for a good couple of months before my son did any signs back or showed understanding of them. Once he started he added them at a fast clip. He gained verbal and gestural language around the same time (starting around 10/11 months). This was not what the babysigns books I'd read described (they talked about 4mo babies signing, anyway- not mine).

At your daughter's age she may pick it up really quickly- if she's already using other gestures to communicate (waving, pointing, reaching up to be picked up, etc) she's already got the idea...
post #17 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by emmaegbert View Post
I signed for a good couple of months before my son did any signs back or showed understanding of them. Once he started he added them at a fast clip. He gained verbal and gestural language around the same time (starting around 10/11 months). This was not what the babysigns books I'd read described (they talked about 4mo babies signing, anyway- not mine).

At your daughter's age she may pick it up really quickly- if she's already using other gestures to communicate (waving, pointing, reaching up to be picked up, etc) she's already got the idea...
We were pretty lackadaisical from about 5 months - 10 months. And then my son signed back and we got all into it. It was around 1 year though that we gave in and put on the signing time DVDs and he just exploded with them. I think it was watching the other kids.

He gained some verbal too, but the signs outstripped the verbal for quite a while, especially when he was upset... I remember at 18 months we were still really glad for them.

Just as a side note, he's 3.5, and we still use some of the signs, especially I love you.
post #18 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by alegna View Post
With dd we signed from around 4 or 5 months? And she was signing back around 9 or 10 months as I recall.
This was our experience too. ds just turned 14 months and he has around 40 or 50 signs. His signs just exploded last month!! It's absolutely wonderful, I wouldn't do it any other way.
However, just because you didn't start when your baby was 4 or 5 months is not a bad thing - your little one should pick up a couple of signs fairly quickly if you do them consistently, it's a great age for you to start!
post #19 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cheshire View Post
At his 18 month check up we tried a new pediatrician and the guy asked how many words DS used. At the time DS didn't have many verbal words but he knew so many signs (I'd have to get his baby book to remember). We told the doc and he said "oh, sign language" with an eye roll and then said "it's not a recognized language, how many words can he say."

We were so surprised - what does he think American Sign Language is? Duh.
what an idiot. He's a doctor? a pediatrician? from where? a correspondance course?
post #20 of 20
I just wanted to add that picking up DD also helped to figure out what she was pointing at. When you are 2 feet tall and pointing to a cabinet in the kitchen it could practically be anything that they are thinking about. i would pysically pick her up and move her closer so she could show me what she was trying to say.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › My baby gets upset when I don't understand what she wants.