Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › argh! so frustrated!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

argh! so frustrated!  

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
i am so frustrated with our ped! i took ds for a WBV yesterday evening and it started out so great. the doctor and nurse were both super easy going about us not vaxing (finally) and i was feeling really at ease. i was planning to say something to her about retracting because i haven't yet but she has never tried or said anything excpet for his first visit she asked if we were going to circ, i said no and she said, good. so i though we had a foreskin wise ped. well last visit she undid his diaper and he peed on her so she forgot to go back to check him. this time she undid his diaper and i said, im sure i dont have to worry about this with you but i want to make sure you know not to retract him. and then she starts pushing on the base of his penis and pulling his skin back! to be honest, i dont think she was "retracting him", i never saw the glans and ds was completely oblivious to the whole thing, but i also dont think what she did was necessary. she said i should push it back without pressure in the bath, and then kept doing it! i said dont push it so hard and she stopped and said, he has until age 2 for that and then if he still isnt retractable by 4 we do something about it. i completely clamed up and said, oh ok. i feel like a terrible mama! i feel like she totally violated him and i just sat and watched! but i said something! i guess i just need to be more firm? dh says we should just never go back to her but i feel lost as to how to find a ped that will be foreskin wise, breastfeeding supportive(she nurse her daughter for 2+years) and ok with us not vaxing. i feel like we have 2 out of 3 and that seems pretty darn good these days and maybe i could try and educate her? but i tend to get the guts to say something and then when they say something back i clam up! i mean i knew what she was saying was total bs and i said nothing! why do doctors have this power? ugh. i feel sick to my stomach.
post #2 of 7
Sounds like she is worth sticking with. Absolutely, educate her. She is mistaken about age 2 or 4 being some kind of cut-off age for "doing something" - this is based on Gairdner's erroneous numbers. Send her this info:
http://www.cirp.org/library/normal/
http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcisi...0-2005-dan.pdf

I'd write her a letter saying how much you appreciate her for all the great things about her, but that you were uncomfortable with the advice she gave you about the foreskin, and did some more research and found the above, which indicates that there is no need to hurry the process. Just because you couldn't find the right words in the moment (boy, doesn't that happen to all of us!!) doesn't mean you can't go back and renegotiate with her about what happened and what she told you.

It is crucial that we all participate in re-educating health professionals, and ideally in a way that helps them be receptive to new information. If they are really jerks, that's the time to consider leaving, but if they are good people, just in need of exposure to information that they never got in their training - we must make the effort to educate them. Each one, teach one...

Gillian
post #3 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by glongley View Post
Sounds like she is worth sticking with. Absolutely, educate her. She is mistaken about age 2 or 4 being some kind of cut-off age for "doing something" - this is based on Gairdner's erroneous numbers. Send her this info:
http://www.cirp.org/library/normal/
http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcisi...0-2005-dan.pdf

I'd write her a letter saying how much you appreciate her for all the great things about her, but that you were uncomfortable with the advice she gave you about the foreskin, and did some more research and found the above, which indicates that there is no need to hurry the process. Just because you couldn't find the right words in the moment (boy, doesn't that happen to all of us!!) doesn't mean you can't go back and renegotiate with her about what happened and what she told you.

It is crucial that we all participate in re-educating health professionals, and ideally in a way that helps them be receptive to new information. If they are really jerks, that's the time to consider leaving, but if they are good people, just in need of exposure to information that they never got in their training - we must make the effort to educate them. Each one, teach one...

Gillian
I 100% agree with everything above. Educate her. Write her a letter about non retracting and also retraction age. Also ask for her email, so you could send her the links about it.
post #4 of 7
She seems like a great doctor. who just has the wrong information. If I were you I would MAIL her lots of information from medical organizations she trusts, and include a letter explaining your shock and concern. Explain how you want to continue having her as your ped, but not if she continues with a policy on retracting babies and young boys because its medical fact that at best that policy is useless and at worst can lead to a number of penis problems.
post #5 of 7
EEK how many little boys has she sent off to be circed

Definatly take the time to educate her not just for your ds but for all the other little boys she sees.
post #6 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by MCatLvrMom2A&X View Post
EEK how many little boys has she sent off to be circed

Definatly take the time to educate her not just for your ds but for all the other little boys she sees.
: (bold mine)
post #7 of 7
she NEEDS to be educated. Please send her intact care pamphlets asap.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › argh! so frustrated!