Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Anti-circ ped but he "gently" retracted!?!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Anti-circ ped but he "gently" retracted!?!  

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
Ok, first off - this ped is very AP friendly. He told us to carry baby all the time, is very BF friendly despite my son having severe allergies to some foods I was eating he never suggested weaning or formula. He was thrilled when we said we weren't going to circ. He is supportive of our decision to delay vaxes as well. He is truly a rare find in my community. And he comes highly recommended by nurses I know and even my tribe here on MDC.

However, at the two month check-up I was looking at the baby's face while he looked him over and when I looked back he had the foreskin pulled exposing the very tip of the urethra. I cried out, "Don't!" and he said, "Its ok, you need to pull back very gently and clean this area. Don't force it, but pull back gently until you meet resistance and clean." I have never pulled back the skin and had only "washed it like a finger". (BTW - despite the siggy this is my first intact boy. Ex-H insisted on circ, but my wonderful current DH was happy to leave baby intact)

He did not expose the glans at all, and baby did not cry. But my mama gut felt sick about it. I did notice a slight bit of redness at the tip later but it faded by the evening. What do you think? I'm not sure how to handle this.

Thanks!
post #2 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by earthmama4 View Post
Ok, first off - this ped is very AP friendly. He told us to carry baby all the time, is very BF friendly despite my son having severe allergies to some foods I was eating he never suggested weaning or formula. He was thrilled when we said we weren't going to circ. He is supportive of our decision to delay vaxes as well. He is truly a rare find in my community. And he comes highly recommended by nurses I know and even my tribe here on MDC.

However, at the two month check-up I was looking at the baby's face while he looked him over and when I looked back he had the foreskin pulled exposing the very tip of the urethra. I cried out, "Don't!" and he said, "Its ok, you need to pull back very gently and clean this area. Don't force it, but pull back gently until you meet resistance and clean." I have never pulled back the skin and had only "washed it like a finger". (BTW - despite the siggy this is my first intact boy. Ex-H insisted on circ, but my wonderful current DH was happy to leave baby intact)

He did not expose the glans at all, and baby did not cry. But my mama gut felt sick about it. I did notice a slight bit of redness at the tip later but it faded by the evening. What do you think? I'm not sure how to handle this.

Thanks!
He is wrong on this one. I think over all you have a great ped. And I would just gather the docs and go over it with him at your next visit. Just say you looked into it and this is what you found. The AAP care instructions should be enough. If you can't find them someone here will post it.
post #3 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by earthmama4 View Post
He did not expose the glans at all, and baby did not cry. But my mama gut felt sick about it. I did notice a slight bit of redness at the tip later but it faded by the evening. What do you think? I'm not sure how to handle this.
Well if he exposed the tip of the urethra, then he did expose a part of the glans.

Its true that this situation did not do much damage to your son, because he was a little "looser" down there. And while for some boys retraction may cause little damage, for some it could cause heavy injury to his genitals. But that is why the rule is to NOT expose at all is because you never really can never know how "loose" any boy is because there really is no average.

Only the boy will know when to stop, stopping when you feel "resistance" is stopping too late, because your already pulling on sensitive tissue by that point.

Besides this one thing, you have a great doctor here. This is just something your doctor may not understand, and you should correct him. Call him up, send him an email (if it is more comfortable for you) and let him know you dont want him doing ANY future retraction. Explain the state of your son's penis that night, and also explain why you do not want him retracting and back it up with some links if wish.

But with any ped (especially good ones) communication is key, and solve most of your concerns.
post #4 of 9
I think your Dr. is a good one but he couldnt be more wrong on retracting any to clean. I would in the future just request he not touch the penis at all that way nothing can happen. He can look all he wants but hands off.
post #5 of 9
Please print out a Intact Care pamphlet for your Dr!

http://www.nocirc.org/publish/index.php
post #6 of 9
He does sound like a very good doctor. Don't give up on him, print him info, including contact info of DOC and ask him to contact them as they are always happy to anwer these kind of questions. They are also MDs, so he won't feel offended.
post #7 of 9
I wish I understood why so many doctors feel the need to "retract just a little until you feel resistance". Do they open little girls vaginas until they feel resistance in order to see how open it is? I really don't get it.
post #8 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by knucklehead View Post
I wish I understood why so many doctors feel the need to "retract just a little until you feel resistance". Do they open little girls vaginas until they feel resistance in order to see how open it is? I really don't get it.
actually some do : My (ex) ped used to do that to my daughters, in fact one of them used to have their parts very tight and would adhere but not much, he used to recommend me to open it up when cleaning and for some reason I never really did anything - I thought it was just wrong to do that, and if she was born that way why would I wanna mess it up? I am so glad I know what I know now... NO dr will retract my son in anyway!
post #9 of 9
yeah i told the ped to not retract..he said okay, thats great i didnt circ... then told me to pull it a little to help it loosen. i was like UMM..NO.

and i know someone whos girl had adhesions and she was told to rip it apart every time she was changed, too.


im surprised more people dont have sexual problems from all the craziness of ripping skin apart so often1 yikes!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Anti-circ ped but he "gently" retracted!?!