Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Keep your fingers crossed
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Keep your fingers crossed

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
I posted on here about a month ago that I knew a casual work acquaintance that was expecting a boy. I wanted advice on how to approach her regarding circumcision. Well, I did it. I was so nervous and scared that she would react badly but held on to hope that she was crunchy enough to hear me out.

I waited until we had a moment alone and just asked if she was planning on circumcising. She looked at me with a sad expression and said "yes". Then she said " I don't really want to". So I asked her why she was doing it and she told me about hygiene etc. etc. It is so sad that people are so misled and misinformed. So I asked her why she thought it would be hard to clean and she was under the impression (as so many are) that you have to retract and clean under the foreskin. I took a deep breath (because I was shaking on the inside and wanted to appear calm and knowledgable) and told her how most people don't realize that the foreskin is attached and isn't retractable at birth yada yada yada. She was very receptive and was surprised at what I told her. I told her that my DS was always easier to clean than my DD and that when he is older and retractable he can clean himself.

I also handed her a folder of printouts from Nocirc on normal anatomy and function, care of the intact penis, protecting boys from premature retraction and photos from a circ with a plastibell. Not horrifyingly shocking like a video with sound but horrible enough that she knows what actually happens.

She seemed really happy and even thanked me for the info. I told her that I always hated unsolicited advice when I was pregnant but felt the need to share what I know and leave it at that. She said she wasn't offended at all and was glad I told her. I let her know she could ask me anything anytime and I would be more than willing to help. I also gave her nocircs web address.

Now I wait and see if her husband will be on board. He is circd and I think leaning more heavily towards it. She is a pretty strong mama though and I'm hopeful this will have a good outcome. Send lots of prayers everyone!!!:
post #2 of 4
PLease do find a way to follow up on supporting her in re: getting her husband on board. You never know whether they will have the strength to stand up to them if they are very resistant, and she needs to know that she can get support from you for getting through this with an intact son. I had a good friend recently who knew enough to know she really didn't want to circ, but her husband was very strong that the boy would be circed. She was hoping he would "come around" by the time the boy was born, but then she went into labor 3 weeks early, and she lost a lot of blood and was very out of it after the delivery, and just didn't have the strength to keep up the fight, and just gave in and agreed to it. It is now 6 months later, and she still regrets it.

If your friend knows she has someone to talk to and support her (you), she may be able to stand her ground and protect her baby. But I learned the hard way, that there are no guarantees, so don't hesitate to follow up and take her the next step of the way.

Gillian
post #3 of 4
Quote:
Originally Posted by glongley View Post
PLease do find a way to follow up on supporting her in re: getting her husband on board. You never know whether they will have the strength to stand up to them if they are very resistant, and she needs to know that she can get support from you for getting through this with an intact son. I had a good friend recently who knew enough to know she really didn't want to circ, but her husband was very strong that the boy would be circed. She was hoping he would "come around" by the time the boy was born, but then she went into labor 3 weeks early, and she lost a lot of blood and was very out of it after the delivery, and just didn't have the strength to keep up the fight, and just gave in and agreed to it. It is now 6 months later, and she still regrets it.

If your friend knows she has someone to talk to and support her (you), she may be able to stand her ground and protect her baby. But I learned the hard way, that there are no guarantees, so don't hesitate to follow up and take her the next step of the way.

Gillian

:

She still can have the "he has the penis = his right to decide attitude". It's up to you to explain her that she has a foreskin just as well, unlike her husband whose was cut off and he has no was of appreciating this body part. Also, explain her that this is a human right issue, that only their son can decide about cosmetic sergeries on his body. Tell her how many men spend YEARS to restore a pale immitation of what took 15 min to cut. And if the husband is still unsure, I would definitely recommend showing him the video if RIC.

Good luck! Thanks so much for speaking up for those who can't speak for themselves!
post #4 of 4
Thread Starter 
I agree about following up with her. I will "feel her out" next Saturday when I see her again. I have to be careful because she is just a work aquaintance and I can't risk offending her because I could get in trouble with my work. I feel like I've done my best considering the situation.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Keep your fingers crossed