Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › 5 year old son - too young?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

5 year old son - too young? - Page 2

post #21 of 24
I did not read all of the posts; but both W and O have had pretty bad infections in their penises. Both were cured within 24 hours after doing soaks twice a day with herbs recommended by our naturopath. Even with the first infection--which we let get way too bad, we ended up at the conventional doctor and he never mentioned circumcision; but did give us antibiotics--which we never used.

In the past month I noticed an infection coming and we followed the advice of the naturopath to sprinkle acidophilous (powder) on the penis. Cured.

Sorry if I am repeating.
post #22 of 24
Keep in mind infection is often dxd when it is actualy just natural seperation issues. If if is seperation issues then it will clear on its own within 24-48 hours with doing nothing an infection gets worse over time not better without treatment. A helpful link http://www.mothering.com/discussions...d.php?t=764732
post #23 of 24
One thing I always consider is "How would the doctor treat a girl with a similar infection?" (Kinda corny, but it gives me space to think.) Then that is how I would want to proceed with my boys.
I have yet to hear a dr. suggest circumcision for a girl with a health issue in her genitalia.
post #24 of 24
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgracer View Post
Okay I've read a few posts about members against circumcision.

Our son got sick 2 weeks ago and his doctor said the tip of his penis got infected some what. She said my son is a candidate for "early" circumcision. Is 5 year old too young to be circumcised? My heart is melting by just thinking the pain he have to endure and I wanted circumcision to be done when he's like can decide a little for himself.
These infections are not serious. They usually clear up by themselves and never re-occur. Girls are ten times more likely to get infections yet we never consider chopping bits off them.

Make sure you are caring for the intact penis right (no care is required , do nothing). Considering your doctor recommended circumcision - he probably also told you to pull the foreskin back. This is probably what caused the infection.

The foreskin is attached to the glans from birth. It should be left to separate naturally. Any attempt to pull the foreskin back or clean under it is damaging. First off it hurts. Secondly it creates micro-tears in the skin. These not only increase the chance of an infection; they form scar tissue. Scar tissue is inelastic and so may cause retractability problems later on.

After the foreskin has separated from the glans, soon it will be able to retract over the glans, once the hole gets big enough. Again, you must not force this, this happens all on it's own. The time it occurs varies for each boy. Most are retractable by age 10, though it can occur up until the age of 18.

So just to re-iterate - do not pull the foreskin back. Do not clean under it. Don't use soap as that can irritate. Do not allow this clueless doctor to take away an important body part without the boy's consent.

Care guidelines: http://www.cirp.org/pages/parents/care/
Normal development of foreskin: http://www.cirp.org/library/normal/
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › 5 year old son - too young?