Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at School › National Young Scholars Program
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

National Young Scholars Program

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
My 10 year old got a packet at his mothers house about this. DH went and picked it up and it's gold embossed and very fancy.

His mother is over the moon. She's calling all of their family and friends and telling him how special it is. I looked at the information and it seemed...off.

First of all, he's a good kid and a good student, but he's not exactly gifted or academically special that I can see right now. The work that he's taught in his fourth grade class is a little slow moving IMO, so he's doing it well and he's happy.

Second, this program is 2 grand for 4 days, not including airfare.

Third, they go a little far to convey what a miraculous event it is. They included a marketing letter especially for him, and a link for a press release that he can send to his local newspaper.

Fourth, it didn't come from the school, or through the school. The school didn't even mention anything like this to us, or even that he was in the running for some kind of award, even though his teachers name is mentioned many times in the packet. There's nothing else to the program that I see. Just camp.

It seems a little like those Who's Who books to me and DH is skeptical, too. But, again, his mother is thrilled and so is my kid, so I'm kind of hoping that we're wrong.

Has anyone ever heard of the NYSP or participated?
post #2 of 6
DD got the same thing in the mail this year (also 10) and we thought it was actually just mass mailed.

Here is the 4th link I found when I searched:
http://search.live.com/results.aspx?...c=IE-SearchBox

Apparently there is a lot more info out there if you add "scam" into the search.

I read some reviews where the people were happy, but mostly acknowledged that it wasn't an "award" and was more of an expensive, more academic summer camp. If you have plenty of money it's not a waste, but not exactly what they want you to believe either.
post #3 of 6
They mass mail to schools and try to get teachers to send in names of kids. I've always just tossed the packet that comes. The gold-embossed logo screams Junk Mail to me. There is no consistent criteria; any teacher who gets this in her box could glance at it, think "so-and-so has been doing great this year!", send in info, and forget all about it. No one else in the school would have any idea, so it's not like the school has anything to do with it.
post #4 of 6
no advice. just commiseration.

wonder if the teacher gets a kickback for sending a name.

i feel so sorry for her when she realises she's been scammed.

wonder if dss is excited coz his mom is excited and maybe travelling and going someplace rather than about the award itself.

hope you and your dh are able to send her some scam links.

anytime there is are $$$s attached i always get suspicious.
post #5 of 6
Quote:
Originally Posted by ecoteat View Post
They mass mail to schools and try to get teachers to send in names of kids.

Wow. Aren't teacher's bound contractually NOT to release without consent the names/addresses of the children in their schools? I would not be pleased (and the teacher and the school would know well about that fact) if our family's information was given out by a teacher to anyone without my consent. That's highly unethical IMO. And then to have to deal with a disappointed kiddo and parent(s) that got their hopes up as though this was something legit. Despicable!
post #6 of 6
For anyone who is interested, you may want to check out the FERPA law. Any school that receives DOE funds is bound by it, and is required to inform you about it annually and give you the chance to NOT give your consent regarding information release.

http://www.ed.gov/policy/gen/guid/fpco/ferpa/index.html
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at School
Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at School › National Young Scholars Program