Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Being an only child
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Being an only child

post #1 of 60
Thread Starter 
Hello. My dh and I are probably not going to have any more children (dd is only four months now, but I think for our marriage's sake and our sanity one child is enough for us) and I feel a little guilty about this. I grew up with a sister I was very close to, and it's hard for me to imagine life without a sibling. But it's also hard for me to imagine going through the horrendous pregnancy I had again, especially with a very sensitive and high-maintenance young one to care for.

So, my question to those who were only children is: did you enjoy being an only child or did you feel that you were missing out on something?
post #2 of 60
I'm an only child and always wished for siblings. When I grew up no one else was an only child (or had divorced parents) and I felt like I didn't fit in. However, I think it's more common now to be an only child.

Your baby is very young and you may feel differently about more children in the future. I found the first few months hard to get used to. I'm sorry you had a difficult pregnancy.

I did like getting all the attention and not having to share, but I ended up spending so much time with adults that I still don't feel as comfortable with people my own age as I do with older people. I think not having other kids around also made it hard for the adults in my life to realize how kids really act. I always was expected to behave like an adult which was difficult. I didn't get a lot of encouragement to play or be silly. I missed playing with other kids and even longed for siblings to fight with! I hope that we'll be lucky enough to have more than one child, for that reason as well as many others.

Ultimately, you have to do what feels right for your family. But since you asked, that's my experience.
post #3 of 60
I am an only child and loved it growing up. My best friend was the youngest of 7, so whenever I felt like having some sibling fun, I'd head on over to her house. Then when her brother starting bugging me I'd just say "oops, gotta go" As well, I really enjoyed the one on one time I had with my parents. I feel I had a closer relationship to them than my other friends, because they weren't distracted by other children.

As I get older though, I do think about when I'm 'old and grey'. Like who will be around me during this time in case DH is not? Will I be one of those lonely old people in the nursing homes who nobody visits? A little depressing, I know. But those thoughts didn't come to me until I got into my 30's.
post #4 of 60
I really think a lot of this depends on the personality of the child, the environment, etc. and I'm sure you'll get answers from both sides of the fence on this.

I was an only child. To make it even worse, I was raised by my grandparents in a semi-retirement area. I loathed it to the point where I swore I would do whatever it took to make sure any child of mine wasn't an only. It was very lonely, and while I can certainly say that's part of the reason I was such an avid reader and developed such a good imagination, I'm realizing again as my children get older that I don't play partly because as a child I never really played any 2+ person games or had the whole running the yard screaming your head off like a fool tag games, etc. I feel pretty guilty when my kids ask me to play and I haven't got the faintest idea how they want me to interact with them. Don't get me wrong, I did great in school and had plenty of friends I hung out with, I just was really never exposed to a lot of the aspects I would have if I'd had a sibling. (I technically do have a half brother; he's 8 yrs younger and lived 4-5 hrs away while I was growing up. I was allowed to see him about every 2-4 years and barely know him, so I don't really consider that as representational of a sibling relationship.)
post #5 of 60
:

It's likely dd will be an only child also, due to pregnancy problems, fertility issues and a high needs baby. So, I'm curious about the responses.
post #6 of 60
my DH was an only child, and i have one brother.

i think that there's no real way to know if your child would do better as an only child or as a sibling till you're looking at the situation in hindsight!
i think it's a crapshoot either way, to be totally honest!

i do think that your DC will be better off with two "sane" parents than with two nutso parents, and one sibling

as a PP mentioned, it is much more common now to be an only child than it was 20 years ago, which will make it easier for your DS
post #7 of 60
I was an only child (though my dad ended up having another daughter when I was 30). I had one of the most idyllic childhoods of anyone I know. I lived in a neat little neighborhood with a lot of hippie families. There was a neighbor girl who was three weeks younger than me and also an only child and we played often and I was close and comfortable with her family. Even though my parents divorced and I moved around a few times and was an awkward pre-teen I think back very fondly on my childhood and never felt like I was missing anything by not having a sibling.

I sometimes wish I had a sibling now, in the even that my mom ages and ails and needs help I will be the sole child to care for her, you know?

Nonetheless, I did choose to have more than one child and now I feel very ill equipped to deal with siblings. I love both boys wildly, but I don't love the idea of trying to raise them as brothers and dealing with their relationship/rivalry/etc. It's almost like I wish I could do like my dad and raise two separate "only" children. Is that weird? Ah well.

Looks like the answer is: it depends. I don't think you should worry about it at all though. Better to do what's right for your family than what's deemed "right" by some people.
post #8 of 60
Quote:
Originally Posted by mamarootoo View Post
i think it's a crapshoot either way, to be totally honest!
:

I'm an only child. Ages 5-10 we lived in a subdivision with LOTS of other kids to play with, so I didn't ever really feel left out or that I was missing something. When we moved to a new neighborhood for the remainder of my childhood (and new town) it was different. I was lonely. But 10 is a weird transitional age, too - from playing outside all the time to pretending to be teenagers, etc. At least in my experience.

On the one hand, I love the simplicity of the fact that I know I will be the one caring for my parents when they need it. I've seen this sort of "who gets stuck holding the bag" game go down with other families with siblings, and it seems like a horrible game of resentment, etc.

On the other hand, I'll never know what I missed. I like to think that had I had a sibling, it would have been nice to commiserate with him/her when it seems like your parents have lost their minds. But who knows if they would have shared my perspective, right?

I have the one DS now, and I'm really on the fence about having another kid. I didn't have to worry about sharing my parents financially growing up, nor did I have to share their time. But I was lonely and bored a lot growing up. There is no one right answer, but it is hard to sort out all the what ifs.
post #9 of 60
I am an only child, and I always wanted a sibling. It was extremely difficult having ALL of my parents' attention on me-way too intense!
post #10 of 60
I had a horribly mean brother, so not an only child..

that being said, there were many times that I wished I was

I really do think that I would have been a very happy only-child, and I would have loved all of the attention. My partner feels the same way about his childhood too. Many kids adjust fine -and are content- without siblings..

Now, however, I am glad to have my brother around because it seems like we have this special bond that can't be shared with anyone else.. and I like the idea of having someone to call when I'm all old and grey

I also want to second the pp who said that the first months are hard.. I was done too, three times

soooo...

I wish you well in finding your *path*
post #11 of 60
My husband and I are both only children with very different experiences.

Me: parents only wanted one. I had 100% of my parents time and energy, money to do great activities, lots of friends and the ability to spend time with adults in a purely normal fashion. I wanted to have a sibling so much - asked Santa every.damn.year - but I think it was just a passing "want" and nothing more. Being an only rocked!

DH: father died when he was an infant so mother was forced to only have one. No money, no activities, a lot of sadness surrounding his mother's desire for more kids, etc. Has *very* skewed ideas about onlies and did *not* want an only. He has since changed his mind and only wants the one kid we have.
post #12 of 60
I am an only child and have mixed feelings about it. My parents were pretty inept when it comes to love and affection and really did a pretty crappy job raising me. I think it was the universe working in its beautiful, mysterious way when they could not conceive again. (I am not being cheeky - I am very serious about that). Either of my parents have ever said "I love you" or expressed pride in me or my life. Even as a small child, I knew there was something wrong with my family, though I did not understand what it was until adulthood.

That being said, I think that if the circumstances were better I would have loved a sibling. It really can be lonely as an only child - especially when you get a little bit older and could really come into a wonderful friendship with your sibling(s). My husband had 3 sisters (1 older, 2 younger) and they are by far his (and my) best friends ever. The love between all of them is 100% unconditional and always a priority.

I think about my parents growing older and being their only caretaker. I think about my own old age and not having any family of my own to share those years with, as my cousins are all much older than me as well. I guess as I "grow up" I am seeing a whole new side to this only-child thing. It would have been fun to have a playmate as a child, but it would be even better to have a a true confidant as an adult - someone who REALLY understands where you come from and why you are who you are - with absolutely no explanation needed.

I think, though, that every family is unique. You will make the right decision for you and yours because that is how the world works. Just keep in mind that you are only 4 months post partum and your feelings may change or evolve as time goes on. No need to make any decisions today!
post #13 of 60
I was an only child until age 14 when I gained a half sister. I enjoyed it and I can say that I am completely normal (ish) and well adjusted. I wouldnt have changed my childhood for the world. There were times when I wished I had a sibling, but more times when I was glad that I didnt
post #14 of 60
I loathed being an only child.

As a kid, we lived away from people and I had no friends, cousins, or after school activities. I played board games by myself and had imaginary friends I talked out loud to until my teens - I was that lonely.

As a teen, my parents had no comparison to other kids my age and would give me ridiculous curfews (9 pm at age 18) and ground me for something like shaving my legs at age 14. Everything I did was the end of the world, even though compared to my peers I was an angel. (No drinking, no smoking, no sneaking out, no cheating on tests... nothing like that.)

As a young adult, I had to take on way too much emotional responsibility because my father was terminally ill for about a decade before he finally died. I had no one to share that with. My mother was his caretaker and I was always the black sheep for not wanting to be at his bedside constantly praying for his soul. (I'm so not exaggerating; I had to do that many night vigils in my adolescence and finally stopped doing it after a few years.) I was also locked in my room by myself for weeks on end except to go to school, because he was ill and didn't want me around to hear him vomit because it embarrassed him. He viewed it as a shameful thing, so he didn't want anyone witnessing it. And I wasn't allowed a phone or Internet or anything because they didn't want anyone to know that he was that sick (for business reasons on his part). So basically I was left to my own devices. Having a sibling to at least share time with or the emotional stress of that, well, it would have been helpful I think. Except I don't really wish that experience on other people, either.... So I dunno.

Now, as an adult, my mother is widowed and has no family or friends except us. And I get ALL the emotional unloading, no siblings to share the burden with. I'm still in my mid-20's and she's only in her 50's so this might go on a while. She wants to chat several times a day, be privy to everything that's going on in my marriage, she even wanted to move into the house next door to us so she could be with us every day. If I ever tell her that I just don't have the resources to be all this for her, she tells me while breaking down crying that I hate her and I'm the only family she has. Which, well, is true. (Not the hating her part, obviously, the only family part.)

DH was an only child also, but he grew up with a lot of other friends and family, and he liked being the only child. But his mother too is disabled and he gets the same kinds of guilt trips as an adult now, that he's the only family she has and yada yada.
post #15 of 60
My partner and I are both only children and have very different ideas about it.

I was always lonely as an only child and always wanted brothers and sisters. My mother is disabled and my father is about to pass away from brain cancer, and I can't tell you what the strain is like having to take care of them myself when they live 150 miles away and I am about to give birth. It 100% falls on my shoulders and it is an enormous amount of pain and guilt. When my father passes away my mother will not have enough money to survive and I don't know how I will be able to help her.

My partner enjoyed being an only child, he liked being able to go to private school and have his parents dote on him. His parents are wealthy and he's not worried about end of life issues because of that. My parents were solidly middle class, and health issues can absolutely make middle class stability come crashing down. His parents only wanted one child, my parents wanted many but lost all of the other ones to miscarriage.

I want more than one child, because I could never willingly put another child into this position. My partner only wants 1.

ETA: after reading the last post, I agree about the parents being too invested in your life for the rest of your life. I have a great relationship with my parents, but yea, when my mother become a widow she wants to follow me where ever I move. I'm her only family. My partner's parents are highly highly involved and critical and micromanaging of his life and I think they think the baby being born is theirs. I'd LOVE to have more family to share all this with! As it is our child will have only 3 family members besides my partner and I, grandma, grandma, and grandpa. That feels very lonely to me.
post #16 of 60
I've enjoyed being an only. As a child I often asked for a sibling, but it was never my choice (obviously) and my parents made sure to include a friend whenever possible.

I did have close neighborhood friends who remain, today, like sisters to me. I also have cousins nearby.

I'm very conflicted about having a second child. DH is one of 6 and would like 2 or 3, but I'm nervous about sibling relationships.

I had a great childhood and have an excellent and close relationship with my parents.
post #17 of 60
Quote:
Originally Posted by makuahine View Post
Hello. My dh and I are probably not going to have any more children (dd is only four months now, but I think for our marriage's sake and our sanity one child is enough for us) and I feel a little guilty about this. I grew up with a sister I was very close to, and it's hard for me to imagine life without a sibling. But it's also hard for me to imagine going through the horrendous pregnancy I had again, especially with a very sensitive and high-maintenance young one to care for.

So, my question to those who were only children is: did you enjoy being an only child or did you feel that you were missing out on something?


I hear you. I'm in the same situation, same reason. DD is now 1 and life is easier (I now cope with life in general, though I'm still not cooking... or sewing... or exercising... ), but DH is still absolutely certain, no more. I have come to thinking that I MIGHT cope in 5- 10 years time. DD is still likely to be an only child.
post #18 of 60
Your DD is 4 months. You may feel exactly this same way in 3 years. Or you may be a totally different person. No matter how certain you are of your viewpoint right now.

I suffered with severe trauma, PTSD with all the lovely things that entails like flashbacks, hallucinations, prolonged sleep deprivation... So DS was the first, the last, the only. Never again. I had always wanted 2, but now that was over.

Over the next 18 months I did a lot of healing - therapy, writing a memoir, researching PTSD, even coming here was helpful! DH and I (mostly me) thought about having another child, and put a tiny toe in the water. I was pregnant in about 5 seconds, maybe less. It wasn't all roses, my home birth turned emergency cesarean again, but the way I handled myself, and the way I handled others (yes, handled, I was not a passive non-person to be "treated"), was extremely different. Growing from my trauma made me a very confident, secure person. DS and DD gained by that. DS and DD are now 4.5 y and 2 y, and they love each other, rarely fight and I am grateful. Having DD was the best decision I made, not just for her, but for DS and for myself.

Added: I am a very different person today than I was before DS was born. Of course I would have been different anyway, but his birth has colored my life, and I do not think that will ever "just fade away." But it doesn't consume me, it doesn't negate the rest of my being, like it did 4 months, 8 months or even 18 months after DSs birth.
post #19 of 60
I was an only child and didn't mind it at the time. But it is definitely the reason I so badly wanted a sibling for my daughter. Now, I also worry about who will take care of my aging mom when she is going to need help. I also miss the close bond that some people have with their siblings. But then, some of the sibling in my family HATE their siblings, and these life long differences cause them a lot of hurt. You know, I can understand your feelings, but if you really don't want more children, of course you shouldn't . Like a pp said though, it may change later on since the memory of your birth and pregnancy is still fresh.
post #20 of 60
I don't know much about only children personally. I come from a large family and I loved it. And I have two kids. But, my husband and I decided to stop at one child when I accidentally got pregnant. It was not my choice to have more than one.

I love both my children and I wouldn't want to choose between them but in some ways I do wish that I had had only one. :

I am overwhelmed and since I have a history of mental illness I have to work very hard at staying healthy. I feel like we are just keeping it together. Caring for our kids, our home and getting to work on time and being productive-they are all receiving the minimum effort needed. I feel guilty all the time. At times, I feel like life is passing me by while I tread water to keep from drowning. And I miss my husband. We spend our time being partners. I feel comfortable and safe with him but we don't seem to have fun together anymore-just the two of us.

This sounds more negative than my life is. I am optimistic and my kids bring me joy. I am not depressed and I have things that make me happy every day. But I am not as happy as I was when I had one child or no children...

I am just waiting this out. Maybe in one to two years, I won't feel this ambivalence anymore...

As for having an only child...I had a friend who was an only child and I said to her I felt sorry she didn't have siblings. She said she loved it. I guess, for her, she didn't miss what she didn't have. When I though my son would be an only child, we decided to move near extended family and friends. Both our best friends have 1 or 2 kids. One of my cousins has an only child. And I have two nieces and nephews that are near the same age as my son. I decided that I would put effort into keeping his relationship with them strong.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Being an only child