Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › I smacked my ds :(
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

I smacked my ds :(

post #1 of 22
Thread Starter 
This has been bothering me for days. He was struggling during a diaper change, which has been a major power struggle recently. He's 18 months old. I tried all my "regular" approaches, distrations, songs, etc...and he would NOT stop struggling, and he was getting shit all over my father's couch, and I just LOST IT and smacked his leg.

What made it worse was the look of utter shock on his face that not only was I not comforting him, but he suddenly realized that I was the one who inflicted the pain. And he stopped struggling, just layed there and cried while I finished (quickly and efficiently). I felt absolutely awful. I still feel sick to my stomach when I think about it.

When he was in a clean diaper, I spent about 5 minutes hugging him and comforting him, and apologized to him for using my hand to hit. He seemd fine, in terms of moving past the incident, and he only cried for a minute or so, but I still am carrying a load of guilt.

He has had a huge amount of change, transition, and disruption in his life recently (which is where the power struggle comes in, which I recognize), and now he has one more thing in his little world to wonder about - whether Mama is going to hurt him if he doesnt listen.

I cant even express how crappy I feel. I hope I never am in this place again. I have NEVER intentionally hurt him, not even in my most extreme moments of frustration. Once, when he was about 12 months old, he kept messing with the cords plugged into the wall at someone else's house, and I kind of poked him with the plug, which startled him more than anything else. And once when he was about 6 weeks old, my then-husband (we're divorcing now) walked into the room at about 4 am when I'd been up all night with ds, and asked me if I couldnt keep the damn door shut because the baby crying woke him up. I was so furious with him that I snatched ds up off the changing table abruptly and scared the bejesum out of ds. I told myself then that NEVER again would I handle my baby in anger, no matter what the reason. Until this incident the other day, I have kept true to my conviction.

And now my conviction is renewed. I remember how guilty I felt when ds was 6 wks old and I scared him by handling him roughly, and I feel the same way now. Just needed to unload. Thanks.
post #2 of 22
Hugs to you. I can really relate. DD has been pinching me like crazy...drawing blood. One day I lost it and pinched her back (many people told me to do this and I said no way will I do THAT). I couldn't believe that I intentionally hurt her. She cried and backed away from me and ran to Da Da. My heart still hurts. I vowed never to hurt her again in any way. All we can do is apologize, and move on. I think/hope children know when we are sorry.
post #3 of 22
I believe most of us have been there. We are human and we make mistakes. We just need to learn from them and move on. Parenting is hard work, reading between the lines its sounds like youve had some hard times in the past year. Maybe you need to take a break and do something nice for yourself. Its hard to be at our best when theres no break in sight.
post #4 of 22
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the reply... Its been a rough few weeks (for both of us), and I have tried my hardest to be ds's consistent parent that he can ALWAYS feel comforted and nurtured by, and I feel like I really compromised that trust. He is very attached to me, and has always been very in tune with my moods, or when I am very serious about something that can hurt him (hot stove, climbing stairs, etc). He actually requires very little "discipine" per se, so I'm sure my behavior was not only shocking, but makes him wonder what else Mama is capable of.

And to make matters worse, the only thing we've really had to work on in terms of "no-no" is him hitting me - when he's excited, he likes to hit my face. Sometimes in play, sometimes in frustration/anger, but it seems to be his one display of "violent" behavior - and I've worked very hard at correcting it. And here I come with my load of nonsense about "Oh, no, we dont hit with our hands..." and what do I show him? Bah, this parenting thing is a hard gig.
post #5 of 22
HUGS!!

my downfall is yelling, it happens, we are not perfect and it is perfhaps good for our children to see us has shortcomings, and how we handle those shortcomings. You apologized which models how you can repair bad behavior.
post #6 of 22
I'm with you SuperGlueMommy...yelling is my downfall. It's getting better but I still blow it sometimes. I will apologize and hug my son when I do though. It really bothers me that I've blown it so many times and I don't want him (or my other son) to remember Mommy as the person who yelled all of the time. I'm reading a book by Naomi Aldort right now that is sooooo good. It's helping me to understand that my boys don't act up to irritate me, they do it because they have unmet needs or are overtired, bored, etc. I find that if my boys are tired or hungry they are much more difficult. I guess I am too LOL!
post #7 of 22
i think it makes a difference to admit you were wrong and apologize. my mom STILL doesnt think she is wrong for hitting me growing up. I think our relationship would still have a standing chance if she saw how she treated me as wrong, but she saw that it was okay to hurt me, and thats not the kind of people I allow in my life anymore.
post #8 of 22
It happens to the best of us.....
post #9 of 22
My heart still hurts from the time when DS was just 4 or 5 months old and bit me when nursing. I was so hurt/surprised that I just reacted and smacked his little face. To this day I can't believe I did that. I'm not saying it's good that that happened, but the remorse I feel from that incident has kept me from doing things since that would cause me to feel that way again. Be gentle with yourself, mama. You're right. This parenting gig is hard.
post #10 of 22
I'm so sorry. I've done this. As has my extremely gentle discipline friend. When I did it, I think my daughter was just under 3 and she was having a horrible time. We took her to a store and she was constantly screaming, smacking my backside, running away, even squirming away from and not listening to grandma and grandpa who were with us. We finally just left the store and drove home, but since we were with the in-laws, I sat in the back seat next to dd. Well, she was rear-facing in her carseat and she just kept kicking and hitting me the whole way back. I tried everything, but her one goal was to hurt me. I finally lost it and grabbed her arm as it was swinging out towards me for the hundredth time and smacked her leg. Not very hard at all, but I felt bad. I don't think it phased her much. She was in the zone. I try very hard to be as gentle as possible and that includes yelling, but we are human and these kids know how to get us to our breaking point. I think yelling is more of my downfall. I was never hit as a kid, but my parents did yell. Last week I ended up screaming at dd after she threw a total screaming fit while we were out trying to have a good time. She then screamed as we took her to the car (it wouldn't stop, we needed to leave) and the entire car ride home, which is maybe 15 minutes. I tried playing music to drown out the noise, but the high intensity just got to me.

I'm working on it Take care mama, it happens to everyone. One of my friends had good insight on this. If we do this at our WORST, what happens with parents who START with hitting or screaming? It's scary to think about.
post #11 of 22


I've done that to each of my children. While it's not ideal, I apologized and we've moved on. They learn a lot from how you handle your mistakes as well.

One of the things that this might tell you is that you might need to tend to your own needs. When/how can you get a break? I'm much more likely to yell/lash out at my kids when my own stress level is sky high. The analogy people use is that of the airline oxygen mask. You really do need to put on your own mask first before you can help your son. Otherwise, you just might pass out before you get him helped.
post #12 of 22
BTDT. I spanked my DS a couple of times when he was younger. I do still feel bad about it, but I apologized to him each time and he seems to have forgiven me. Kids are resilient. If your child is as tuned into you as you say, he will know that you are truly sorry and he will forgive you.

Oh yeah, and next time, don't change him on the sofa! Then you won't be as likely to have the issue.
post #13 of 22
This has happened to us, a few times more than I am comfortable with. DD at almost 3, and bit me 4 times within a 24 hour period. The last time she left a bruise, so I bent down and bit her arm. Not hard enough to even leave an imprint, but it hurt her feelings so much, and I knew that was worse than the actual physical pain I could have left.

Then the next day, she was leaning in to bite a friend, and as I swooped her up away from the other, I swatted her leg. Once again, not hard at all, but it was the fact that I struck her, that I broke the level of trust she has in me.

And then this afternoon. She ran into the parking lot, something she hasn't done since she was a little toddler. Usually I just say "stop!" in a paniced voice and she stops. Well, not today. She kept running and my heart was about to pound right out of my chest. Thank God there were no cars coming. It could have been bad. I don't even know what possessed me to hit her. I didn't even think about it. I just reacted. And that kind of scares me.

She was just so very heartbroken. She was crying and said "you don't hit my butt, mom! you don't do that!" And yea, I left like such a loser.

I apologized, of course, and promised to never hit her again. Then we talked about not running away in parking lots or out in roads, and stopping when mama says "stop."

She seems to be recovered really well, and I think that has a lot to do with me showing remorse and telling her that it was wrong of me to do that. I just need to remember that hitting her isn't going to solve anything. It may release tension for me for a second, but the guilt I feel, and the hurt it causes her, will far outlast that.
post #14 of 22
Thread Starter 
Thanks for all the kind words. I hadnt wanted to post about it because I was afraid of being totally ostracized...and my loss of control really embarasses me :.

Ds is having to do overnights with his (previously) uninvolved father, and when he comes back to me, he has had some new behavioral issues - tantrums, the struggle w/diapers, etc. Its been very hard for me to watch him be subject to so much confusion and upheaval. It COMPLETELY stresses me out - I am so worried about his feelings of security and attachment with me. I rarely sleep on the nights he's away from me (and I think the same applies to him), and the following day (after spending the night at dads) is ALWAYS a nightmare of melt-downs over minor injuries, hitting me/uncontrollable tantrums when I say "no", etc. Neither of us is well rested, and it makes for cranky behavior from both of us.

I try SO hard to keep it in check, so that he isnt seeing/feeling my stress, but he and I are very tight - there is just no way he isnt reading my tension. Which just makes it all the more guilt-producing on my end because I want for every moment in my care to be as full of comfort, consistency, and security as possible. He has so little of that right now. But, as you all have pointed out, I need to grab my own oxygen mask first. . I like that analogy.

Thanks again. At least my guilt has renewed my convictions. I suppose I'll be doing a lot of that over the next 18 (+) years.

eta: renewing my convictions, I meant, over the next 18 yrs, not smacking ds . Just thought I'd clarify. Sounded a bit weird when I read it.
post #15 of 22
There is a difference in purposely hurting your child for retaliation or punishment, and a reflex like you had today. You didn't chose to do what you did, it just happened and you immediately felt remorse.

I'm sorry your little guy was frightened and I'm glad he didn't cry too long. I am curious to see how he is at future diaper changes?
post #16 of 22
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by SmoothieMom View Post
There is a difference in purposely hurting your child for retaliation or punishment, and a reflex like you had today. You didn't chose to do what you did, it just happened and you immediately felt remorse.

I'm sorry your little guy was frightened and I'm glad he didn't cry too long. I am curious to see how he is at future diaper changes?
He's still miserable about it. I've been having to bribe him with a "goody" - those soft dinner mint things . It sucks, but otherwise, the boy would be buns-to-the-wind 90% of the time. Right now we are staying with family (and we arent exactly welcome, either), so I cant run the risk of nice little puddles on the floor. And the couch is the only place to change. The floors are unfinished, and consist of splintery plywood. He does the "alligator-death-roll" wherever though, it doesnt matter where we do the change. The smack on the leg happened last Sunday, and nothing has changed appreciably since then. Except my own patience level has notched up a bit .
post #17 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by Socks for Supper View Post
Ds is having to do overnights with his (previously) uninvolved father, and when he comes back to me, he has had some new behavioral issues - tantrums, the struggle w/diapers, etc. Its been very hard for me to watch him be subject to so much confusion and upheaval. It COMPLETELY stresses me out - I am so worried about his feelings of security and attachment with me. I rarely sleep on the nights he's away from me (and I think the same applies to him), and the following day (after spending the night at dads) is ALWAYS a nightmare of melt-downs over minor injuries, hitting me/uncontrollable tantrums when I say "no", etc. Neither of us is well rested, and it makes for cranky behavior from both of us.
he's hitting you and acting out because he knows you are a safe person for him to release his feelings upon. no doubt being with his dad brings up all these bad feelings, which he knows he has to repress while he is there. as soon as he gets home and feels "safe" again, the feelings come out.

maybe just knowing that can help you accept it and take it less personally. it's actually a compliment to you, as backward as that sounds, because it means that he knows he can trust you to love him and accept him.
post #18 of 22
Have you tried diapering him while standing? I tried it and she seemed to like it. When she is fighting it, I say, Oh you'd rather do it standing? She goes for it. Although when it was a poopy dipe, it was hard to clean her. However, I think if I keep trying I'll get use to that too.
post #19 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by Socks for Supper View Post
He's still miserable about it. I've been having to bribe him with a "goody" - those soft dinner mint things . It sucks, but otherwise, the boy would be buns-to-the-wind 90% of the time. Right now we are staying with family (and we arent exactly welcome, either), so I cant run the risk of nice little puddles on the floor. And the couch is the only place to change. The floors are unfinished, and consist of splintery plywood. He does the "alligator-death-roll" wherever though, it doesnt matter where we do the change. The smack on the leg happened last Sunday, and nothing has changed appreciably since then. Except my own patience level has notched up a bit .

Oh dear, that doesn't sound like a very good situation at all. How about on your bed with a large change pad underneath? I'm so sorry you are in a difficult living situation, I hope things get better for you soon.
post #20 of 22
Heya, I hope things are getting a bit easier for you, it sounds like you've been through a lot lately! I know this isn't what you're looking for right now, but if your little one is fighting diapers so much, you might talk to him about learning to use the potty (not that you wouldn't still diaper him, just that you might give him chances to use the potty).

I know, I know, I'm coming from EC-world, so it seems like 18 months is so early. But really, there's this awesome window at 18 months where they're old enough to "get it" and not so old that they fight you so much about it. My friend started giving her son chances to use the potty when he was 18 months, and although he's still in diapers a lot of the time, he uses the potty for poop nearly always now (at just past 2). You might even just take him when YOU are using the potty, and see what happens (leave him in diapers the rest of the time so it doesn't stress you out!).

That way you can talk to him about how once he's learned to use the potty, he won't need to wear diapers anymore. It's the ultimate incentive for a kid who hates diapers....

Anyway, I know that's not what you're looking for (and it sounds like things are already quite busy enough for you right now!), I just wanted to throw it out there in case it sounds like something that might help reduce the power struggle--i.e. you're giving him an "out" by showing him how to get to the place where he DOESN'T have to wear diapers anymore!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › I smacked my ds :(