Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Child-Led Weaning › How old was your dc when they stopped nursing to sleep...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

How old was your dc when they stopped nursing to sleep... - Page 2

post #21 of 30
Ds is 4.5 and still nurses to sleep most nights (although he is at least capable of falling asleep without nursing now...if he's sick and can't breath or if I'm really sore, etc, he will just roll over and go to sleep)...he stopped night nursing (on his own) at around 3.5ish. It was very gradual...
post #22 of 30
My oldest nursed to sleep until she was about 3.5 when I decided (because tandem-nursing went badly for me) to set limits. She most wanted to nurse to wake up, not go to sleep, which surprised me. She was my biggest "comfort nurser" and gave it up so gradually, I wasn't even sure when our last nursing session was, other than sometime after her 4th birthday.

My second nursed to sleep until she weaned at almost 2.5 with my encouragement when I got pregnant with number 3. She weaned easily I think because she was not much of a comfort nurser and even as a newborn she could go to sleep without nursing. To this day she goes to sleep this easiest once she decides to go (she is the night-owliest nightowl though).

My third is a little bit of a comfort nurser, but not as much as his oldest sister. However, the only time he ever falls asleep is while nursing, except for car naps (thank goodness he sleeps well in the car). I've been thinking about this lately myself because 1) I'm tired of it, but most of all because 2) I think it would help fight his cavities if we stopped nursing through the night. Last night he let me just rock him a little bit, but ultimately he wanted to nurse. I think I'm going to keep trying to just rock him every night, but not push it too fast.

I was remembering how often my girls would fall asleep in front of videos. My son has never done that! I wonder why.

I think it is totally a personality thing. I am amazed by stories like the first reply in this thread. My children have all experienced child-led breastfeeding--I nursed my oldest almost constantly through her youngest days--but only one gave it up easily.
post #23 of 30
My dd is 27 months and she still nurses to sleep and for naps and a lot through the night. I am wondering too how this gracefully ends on its own. It seems impossible right now that she will just one day decide to fall asleep without nursing. I just can't picture it. But it will be sooooo nice if/when it does.
post #24 of 30
I when my LOs stopped nursing to sleep, it was SO easy! They always nursed BEFORE sleep, but then it got harder to get the to finally, finally drift off
post #25 of 30
Don't worry, you are not alone! My almost-3-year old still nurses to sleep. She was starting to fall asleep on her own at night, and I also felt hugely victorious, like someone else posted. But then she got sick and we're back to nursing on demand throughout the day and to sleep for naps and bed.

It WILL happen - I caught a glimpse of it, and it felt SO good to have her falling asleep without nursing -- and without any trauma!! It can be done. Hang in there. Some nights it's tough though.. I will admit. I have my moments where I just wish that she would fall asleep without me nursing her for 30-45 minutes to get her there.

Oh well - we will miss these times when they wean!
post #26 of 30
My DS nursed to sleep until he was 2 years and 3 months old when we nightweaned. He weaned completely a couple of months after that. DD never nursed to sleep. She's 3.5 years old and still nursing.
post #27 of 30
I cut and pasted this from my response to a similar question awhile back:

Sometime around eighteen months, he began to drift off less. I noticed he was in a lighter state of dozing when I put him down. This happened gradually and not at a steady rate. Some weeks it occured more often, some less.

At some point, he began to unlatch and sit up during our bedtime nursing session. I was confused and would encourage him to finish, not wanting him to wake hungry again in an hour. After a few days of this I thought, wait, he's telling me something - he's done and he's ready to lie down! Duh! From that point on I knew nursing to sleep was a phase he was going to grow out of at his own pace. He had shown me that he could let me know when he wanted to stop, and that he could now lie down without being totally asleep.

Before this point I wasn't sure he'd grow out of it without me encouraging it. It was not that big a deal to me, since nursing to sleep was such an effective tool, but seeing him begin to respond to his own needs and beginning to mature in his sleep patterns was a big milestone and taught me that it really was going to happen with or without me!

At about the age of two, I could stop the nursing session myself without protest from him, and lie him down drowsy but awake. He would then drift off after cuddling close to his lovey and blankey.

Now that he is two and a half, I can put him down basically awake, but relaxed, after a few minutes of nursing. Occasionally he will let go and say, "I'm done" and I will lay him down. I anticipate the day that he lays in my arms and is content to merely cuddle, refusing my suggestion to nurse. I know it is going to happen sooner or later.

...
thought it would be good to update since it's been a year since I wrote that!

Ds was a couple of months past three years old and still faithfully looking for a little nursing before bedtime.He was still sleeping in his crib next to my bed. During a spring cleaning session I decided to set up the toddler bed in his room. I thought it would be a good place to cuddle and read. He asked about it and I just said to him that one day he would sleep in it and it would be his very own cozy bed.

Within three days he insisted on sleeping in his bed. We never asked him to do it. When he wanted to we were really low key and just said "Oh, ok." A couple of times he awoke and spent the remainder of the night in his crib but by the second week he had decided to stay put all night. This was a shocking enough development, lol, but even more surprising was the effect this had on our nursing to sleep routine... he began to forget to ask to nurse at bedtime and would ask instead for cuddles.



post #28 of 30
Ds will be 16 months tomorrow, and tonight is his third night in a row falling asleep on his own. I don't know if it's the new environment we're in, our the 8PM snack/sippy cup that's doing it, but for three nights in a row he has drank about half a sippy cup of whole milk with his snack, i read him 1 story and ay him in his bed and pat his back. Within 10 minutes he is asleep. It's amazing.
post #29 of 30
Quote:
Originally Posted by BetsyPage View Post
All of the sudden I feel like I'm the only one with a 2-3 yo who still nurses to sleep... goodness, this is MDC, please tell me that's not true! lol
DD is 4.25 and still nurses to sleep.
post #30 of 30
My ds had self weaned for day nursing by the time he was two, but still woke up 3-4 times a night to nurse (for literally a minute, I timed him once). I was ready for sleep, so for about 4 nights I slept in another room, and dh comforted him to sleep. First night wasn't happy, second night not bad, and only a little difficult the first night I came back to the fb. It worked out oddly good for me, I spent the second night at the hospital with a friend who had an emergency c-section and needed help with new baby.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Child-Led Weaning
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Child-Led Weaning › How old was your dc when they stopped nursing to sleep...