I think her writing is good, but I don't like what she has to say. I think her edginess is forced and I'm not a prude but her open, blunt talk about certain subjects seems put on rather than revealing. It's like she's saying, "See how cool I am when I speak openly about certain things? See how gritty I am?"
No, that's not what I see, but I guess others do.
I've not read her for a long time, but I gather that she had severe PPD after the birth of her daughter and wrote extensively about that in very raw, unfiltered terms. I think that got a lot of people's attention.
I think she's sarcastic and crude. If she were sarcastic and political, or sarcastic and AP, or sarcastic and unschooly, I'd be all for it!

: