Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Well guess I'll skip the conversation altogether...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Well guess I'll skip the conversation altogether...  

post #1 of 26
Thread Starter 
My SIL is pregnant. About 3 months I think. This is her second, her first is a girl.

Well her and my husbands cousin parked in our driveway for a festival up town where we live (we only live a couple blocks from the square, believe me it's the closest place to park during Festival, people park MILES away and walk). Anyway, they popped in the house for a while to see the kids and chit chat.

I asked SIL if she's using the M/W in town, she is (used her with her DD, in that town there are 2 m/w and 1 OB, my SIL doesn't care for the OB because he's foreign and has a very thick accent...and DH's family is slightly racist). Anyway so I asked when her u/s would be, if they were finding out the gender.

She said yeah, it'll be next month Then she says "I kinda hope it's a girl, if it's a boy I'm sending him to nursery for the whole time we're in the hospital until they 'make him look normal'. : I was sort of confused so I said "Huh?" and she says "Ya know, until they circumcise him. I helped L (the cousin) change K's (cousin's baby) diaper before they circumcised him and it was GROSS. I don't wanna go near it until it's normal."

I honestly had to get up and leave the room...

I was going to spam her with information, but obviously she'll just shut me down...
post #2 of 26
Wow. What a terrible, terrible thing to say about your own newborn infant. I just can't understand some people.
post #3 of 26
It makes me so sad (and well pretty freakin angry too) that anyone could look at a precious baby and see a part of them as ugly or nasty. I just don't get it and I also hope she has another girl. Many girl vibes to her. And I also hope she'll spare her daughter/s her ignorance about normal/natural male anatomy.
post #4 of 26
I would still send her info and make sure to include a video and pics of an actual circumcision (now that's gross).
post #5 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by LavenderMae View Post
I would still send her info and make sure to include a video and pics of an actual circumcision (now that's gross).
Yeah that. Definitely include a video. I couldn't have walked away. That would have sent me off on a major soapbox speech. I really hope she had a girl too.
post #6 of 26
oh wow what a
post #7 of 26
Wow. I hope it's a girl too.
post #8 of 26
what a superficialist person
post #9 of 26
Wow, how sad! I hope she has a girl!
post #10 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by LDSmomma View Post
Wow, how sad! I hope she has a girl!
Me too, but it seems like everytime there's a person in a story on here who's pro-circ, they always have a boy .
post #11 of 26
Thread Starter 
I'm really crossing my fingers it's a girl. I just can't fathom...

I also hope if we have a 3rd that it'll be a boy...he'll be left intact. I guess if it's so 'gross' I don't have to worry about the IL's pressuring me to allow them to babysit
post #12 of 26
What's the midwife's stand on circ? Maybe the midwife can set her straight and get her thinking!
post #13 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by PuppyFluffer View Post
What's the midwife's stand on circ? Maybe the midwife can set her straight and get her thinking!
Thats a good idea. Or at least give her information so shes not so nieve and close minded, and can make an educated decision to do or dont.



I HATE ppl with attitudes like that. I was once talking about circumcision with a friend and she said she was so grossed out over the whole thing... I took it personally, my husband and son are intact.
post #14 of 26
: that it's a girl.

How awful. I think that a raw bloody wound that turns into a nasty scar is far more disgusting than healthy tissue with a purpose will ever be.
post #15 of 26
:Puke

I am so sorry you had to hear that . That is very ignorant IMO. I had to be separated from my DS when he was born (due to an unneceasearean and glucose issues), and I can guarantee you that I would have done anything to have not been without him in the first crucial minutes, hours, etc. I am glad, though, only because that time saved my son's foreskin (I was going to circ originally and through grace, I was presented with the information I needed to realize that leaving your child intact is the only option).
post #16 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by JamesMama View Post
She said yeah, it'll be next month Then she says "I kinda hope it's a girl, if it's a boy I'm sending him to nursery for the whole time we're in the hospital until they 'make him look normal'. : I was sort of confused so I said "Huh?" and she says "Ya know, until they circumcise him. I helped L (the cousin) change K's (cousin's baby) diaper before they circumcised him and it was GROSS. I don't wanna go near it until it's normal."
:Puke Wow, This comment actually made me feel nauseous. How vile that she would think this way about her own child.
post #17 of 26
That's really mindblowing. "Normal"? Normal is a healthy newborn with all the standard issue parts. Normal isn't skinned, wounded, raw. WTH is wrong with people?
post #18 of 26
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by PuppyFluffer View Post
What's the midwife's stand on circ? Maybe the midwife can set her straight and get her thinking!
The M/W is personally against it. She was my m/w with my DD, we had the discussion prior to finding out the gender...she brought it up and I told her I wouldn't be circ'ing if it were a girl or a boy She just said "Oh good!" and did a 'preach at the choir' thing. I don't know if she'll bring it up with SIL or not.

We're in Iowa...so I don't know how much she digs into it, I've known several people that have used her and still circ'ed.
post #19 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by JamesMama View Post
"I kinda hope it's a girl, if it's a boy I'm sending him to nursery for the whole time we're in the hospital until they 'make him look normal'. : I was sort of confused so I said "Huh?" and she says "Ya know, until they circumcise him. I helped L (the cousin) change K's (cousin's baby) diaper before they circumcised him and it was GROSS. I don't wanna go near it until it's normal."

Interesting this is the same kind of thinking parents who cut their girls use. That they are dirty, gross, and no man would want them until they are circumcised.
post #20 of 26
Wow, that is just so sick and sad. Not wanting to see her baby until he was mutilated? Just makes me want to run and hug my sweet intact little boy tighter!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Well guess I'll skip the conversation altogether...