Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Breastfeeding Challenges › Should I take away her pacifier?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Should I take away her pacifier?

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
I posted a thread already about being afraid that she is weaning.

She has nursed a handful of times since I posted that. I timed her once and she nursed for 3 MINUTES! That is it. And that is one of the longer feeds. She is only 9 months old and she nurses maybe 4 times a day. I am really watching the solids I give her, and there is no way she is filling up on them. I feel like I have to give her some so she won't starve! By small amount I mean like 10 little strawberry apple puffs for a snack, and a third of a container of organic banana puree. And she doesn't really want more.

And I was thinking, she had a ped. appt. the other day and wighed almost 18 pounds. I think she has only gained like a pound in the past 2 months.

And I know that the paci has interfered with the breastfeeding since the beginning. I didn't want to give it to her but was desperate and ended up giving it for car rides. She got ADDICTED, seriously.

Is she too old to take it away? I know we would likely go through days of hell. She knows what she wants and she wants it now, lol. It would be like withdrawal, I would have to cut all the pacis up or something to keep from using them when I got desperate!

Would that be evil??? Since she already loves it so much? I would not consider it if I wasn't so worried. She isn't even 1 and I planned on breastfeeding till at LEAST age 2. I just am scared she is on the road to not nursing at all in a few days or couple weeks. Unless something major changes. I'll be heartbroken.

Maybe without her paci she would feel the need to nurse, even though she doesn't use it as comfort ever now.

When she was born she nursed for like 30 minutes straight. I wish I could rewind and change some things I did.....

It seems like the only time she takes it is when she is desperate from thirst! Where is her survival instinct?? She won't even take the bottle or a sippy cup with fluids. She is having wet dipes so she is not dehydrated yet but I am not liking where this is going.... I am even considering crazy stuff like putting sugar on my nipples.....haha. She just needs the fat and calories..... I hope this changes soon.

Thanks for any advice.
post #2 of 6
I dont have any personal experience, but i think i would try to at least severly limit the paci. Just keep offering, babys do get rather distractable at that age, and some babies get super effecent. SO she may only be on for a few mins but she might be getting a full feed.
post #3 of 6
Maybe like the pp said limiting the paci to after BFing, and while sleeping only?

Could you set aside a few breaks in the day that you and you LO could lie down and read to her, or listen to music and cuddle and let her nurse?
post #4 of 6
I would definitely work on taking the pacifier away, it does affect your bf'ing relationship! Just keep offering, and watch the solids like you have been. Let her suck as much as she wants as you reduce the pacifier, because you are the pacifier!
post #5 of 6
I agree, if i was in your shoes I would definatly get rid if the paci and offer to nurse as much as you can. Babies this age are really distractable, try lying down in a quiet, darkened room.

My dd2 doesn't bf as much I would expect her too, and I have worried that she may wean early (her sis bf'd til 2.5y, so thats my goal) I make sure I offer it to her, she usually doesn't ask unless she's sleepy. And I make sure she only has small meals and snack (appropriate for her age/size) I also don't offer her drinks unless i see she really wants some water (eg when she tries to steal her sisters cup) - I never give her any drink apart from plain water or breastmilk. Also I co-sleep as she feeds a lot at night time as she's too busy during the day and I work part-time.


hth

Kirsty x
post #6 of 6
Quote:
Originally Posted by greeneyedmama View Post
I
Is she too old to take it away? I know we would likely go through days of hell. She knows what she wants and she wants it now, lol. It would be like withdrawal, I would have to cut all the pacis up or something to keep from using them when I got desperate!

Would that be evil??? Since she already loves it so much? I would not consider it if I wasn't so worried. She isn't even 1 and I planned on breastfeeding till at LEAST age 2. I just am scared she is on the road to not nursing at all in a few days or couple weeks. Unless something major changes. I'll be heartbroken.

Maybe without her paci she would feel the need to nurse, even though she doesn't use it as comfort ever now.

When she was born she nursed for like 30 minutes straight. I wish I could rewind and change some things I did.....

It seems like the only time she takes it is when she is desperate from thirst! Where is her survival instinct?? She won't even take the bottle or a sippy cup with fluids. She is having wet dipes so she is not dehydrated yet but I am not liking where this is going.... I am even considering crazy stuff like putting sugar on my nipples.....haha. She just needs the fat and calories..... I hope this changes soon.

Thanks for any advice.
This is just my opinion, pls no flames, but if I was in your situation I would take the paci away cold turkey and offer the breast whenever she cried for it. But thats just me - i'm a bit mean like that

You sound really worried and upset - remember your dd has not weaned so things can change. I hope things work out for you both

Kirsty x
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Breastfeeding Challenges
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Breastfeeding Challenges › Should I take away her pacifier?