Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Spirituality › If your first religion was Christianity and you eventually "quit" but later heard it calling...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

If your first religion was Christianity and you eventually "quit" but later heard it calling...

post #1 of 20
Thread Starter 
So I'm not entirely sure what I'm asking with this thread, but you ladies who hang out here are awesome so I thought I'd put this out there. Thank you for reading! Sorry it's so long.
At the moment I have no religion. I have some beliefs but they are eclectic and some of them are conflicting
When I was little (until I was about 8) I went to church with my mom. My most vivid memories of church are from a pentecostal church we went to for a while. It was very joyful, there was a lot of singing and even dancing and also speaking in tongues. I liked the actual worship service because it felt good! Sunday school not so much, I remember it being somewhat patronizing and certainly not as "juicy" as the praise part.
When I was 9, my parents "converted" to Tibetan Buddhism. Long story short, my mom had some major mental health issues and she found great healing from Buddhism and her teacher. For both her and my dad Buddhism just "fell into place" and it is definitely the right thing for them.
Tibetan Buddhism is heavy on the ceremony - we would go to these ceremonies when I was a kid and, though I do remember a feeling of calm and peace after them, they were not nearly as participatory for kids and I was mostly just bored. This, combined with the starting of my adolescent irritation with my parents, resulted in me resenting them and their religion, though I did read some Buddhist philosophy later and it made sense to me in many ways. Until I was 14 or so I still believed in God (though I didn't expressly identify as Christian anymore) and I would still pray, and my parents never discouraged me from pursuing my own religious path, though they did introduce me to Buddhism and encourage my participation.
Anyway, as a teenager I realized that I had stopped believing in God, though after a year of full atheism I realized that even if I didn't believe in God per se, I still believed in "the universe" for lack of a better term, that things worked themselves out in a balance, were all connected, and that we couldn't know whether those things were good or bad for us so had to accept them as they came and learn from them. I didn't pray anymore. Christianity bothered me because the Christians I encountered were often close-minded, fearful and/or patronizing and I found many of the main beliefs to be impossible for me intellectually. More on that later.
I also had a few experiences with Hinduism in my teenage years and liked the theistic nature of it without having to rely on the Bible for example, though it certainly isn't for me.
I was also seriously attracted to Islam for a while, precisely because it is theistic but doesn't require belief in, i.e., Jesus as a savior, which was (is) hard for me to get my head around. Though again, I found out it wasn't for me.
My DP recently started seriously practicing Zen Buddhism (meditating for an hour each day, reading, etc.). It has been wonderful for him, giving him the kind of mental peace and stability that comes from a spiritual practice minus the kind of religious beliefs that put him off of every other religion (Zen is pretty much the driest, least religious religion there is and encourages "seeing for yourself" instead of straight out belief). In fact, I have found Zen attractive in some ways as well. I like how it doesn't rely on beliefs, that it works with exactly what is in front of you, the straightforwardness of it.
But, exactly for that reason, it's so gosh darn dry! And I really can't get into it.
So in the past year or so I have started to identify my feeling of "the universe" as God again. I do believe in God now, very much. I read several Christian blogs regularly, and I like a lot about it: the service of others, the surrender to God in your everyday life, the "attitude of gratitude", the emphasis on love and forgiveness, the mindfulness. Not that Buddhism doesn't have these too, but they are just so much less focused on in my experience. Or somehow harder for me to access. In many ways I identify very much with Christian beliefs. But I have a few issues, particularly intellectual issues that I didn't have much of an problem with as a child. But I can't seem to quash my fascination with Christianity no matter how much I keep getting hung up on these issues, which is why I decided to write this monster post. Maybe those of you who converted to Christianity can help me with these.
For one, the Bible. I have trouble taking the whole thing as God's word. While I do believe that parts of it could certainly have been divinely inspired, I mostly see it as the product of the historical forces that made it. I also believe that the holy texts of other religions have much "divine" in them and I can't believe that Christianity is the only way to God. This might not actually be that big of an issue; at the Catholic school I went to for example they were very ecumenical and the interpretation of the Bible was very symbolic.
For another, the dualism. I have a huge amount of trouble believing that the soul is separate from the body. I think that belief has been the root of a lot of bad things in our culture and it just bothers me. I feel that God is in everything, that essentially there is nothing but God and that the biological processes of physical life are also part of that. I don't believe things are separate, I believe we just see them that way (there's the Buddhist influence) and we need to get past that flawed perception in order to be really happy. I also have issues with the idea of heaven and hell, though I realize there are a ton of different understandings of those within Christianity.
Also the explicit patriarchalism and the misogyny of a lot of Christianity's big names (Augustine for example; this is actually also an issue for me with most major religions). I see this as a relic of the historical context in which the Bible/other religious writings were written but it still bothers me. And does God have to be male in Christianity for example? Or is God beyond gender?
And of course I'm coming to the big one... Jesus as a personal savior. Though I am starting to think that this is a Mystery that just can't be comprehended intellectually and goes to a far deeper, symbolic and less verbal level than literally believing the death and resurrection story and that's that, so oddly I might have less trouble with this one than the previous ones.
Part of me feels that these issues are essentially not all that important, and that I should just put less emphasis on them and instead focus on the lifestyle and the actual practice of Christianity rather than the "theory" part. Though since the "theory" is what makes a religion unique from other religions it would seem dishonest to just ignore it and still identify as a Christian.
So... getting close to the end of my life story here I am so grateful if you are still reading I guess I'm particularly interested in the thoughts of those of you who have struggled or are struggling with these issues. Also if someone knows of a particular belief system or interpretation of Christianity (and I know there are many) that deals with the issues I have I would love to hear. Though before suggesting that I just not bother with Christianity please remember that the whole reason I wrote this is because I can't seem to shake Christianity in my spiritual search, despite my intellectual knowledge that my beliefs do not seem to match up 100%.
I think that's it... whew!
post #2 of 20
Hey there ursusarctos, I read your story, and am sort of in a similar boat. I was raised as a born again Christian. My mother started going to church when I was around 7 I think, my dad never went to church was never interested, my mom made him go once a year on Christmas Eve so the "whole family" would be together at church (my mom was in her glory always praying for my dad to become "born again") but my dad usually slept thru the service. Anyhow, being a born again Christian was my life, I was sheltered pretty much from the "real world" I was always taught that anything outside Christian music was evil, I found myself throwing away many of great c.d's when I was a teen (I'm 30 now) thinking that it was the right thing to do. I never knew anything about anything other than born again christianity and all the speaking in tongues, etc. I was taught that if you weren't born again you were going to hell, even Catholic I was taught were "bad people". It was awful. Then I went away to college when I turned 18, learned about the "real world" and college parties, drinking beer smoking pot, etc. After a year and a half I was suspended from College (long story). I thought it was God's way of telling me to be a "good Christian girl" so I dropped out and entered a local massage school and lived at home with my parents. I LOVED the yoga, tai chi, meditation, herbs, all that stuff, it was more of the 'hippie vibe' which I got into in college. But in the back of my head I was always second guessing myself thinking its bad to like meditation because its not "christian like". It was such a struggle for years and years. My first summer home after College I went to a church picnic (I had a butterfly tatoo I got in college across my shoulder blades by then). The next day in church on Sunday the pastor made a HUGE lecture about tatoo's and how its not proper to mark the body like it says in the bible, and looked straight at me the entire service. I was mortified. It changed me that day I will never forget it. I couldnt imagine how hypocritical born again christians were, so judgemental and close minded. My mother is still unfortunately like this, she always responded answers growing up and STILL DOES with 'Let's pray about it' and tries to hold my hands and pray. Shortly after that I met my boyfriend (now husband) and learned to be more open minded, I felt more confident in being who I wanted to be. I read about buddhism, hinduism, and so many other religions I found facinating. I still find them facinating. But lately as I get older I find myself more interested in having a relationship with God. On my terms though, not with the born again christianity aspect, or the bible, heaven and hell and so many contradictions that go along with it.
Anyhow, I am interested in chatting too, I hope my story makes sense somewhat! lol!
post #3 of 20
I could write a big long novel too, but basically was brought up Catholic then sent to a Fundamental Baptist boarding school for high school. After I finally left that hellhole, I did an extensive study or religion, I guess trying to find where I fit into this world. I ended up deciding there was no God, and pretty much being an atheist for about 10 years. In the past couple of years, I have sort of reconnected with the idea of spirituality, but I had a lot of the same struggles that you bring up. I have found a good home in the Unity church. It is Christ-based, but uses ideas from all over. We don't believe in hell or sin, just consciousness and separation from consciousness. The Bible is not taken as an absolute literal truth. We find a lot of symbolism and inspiration from it though. I really just feel good every time I go to church now. The messages are positive and nourishing. It's nice to go to church because it makes me feel good and not because I'd feel guilty if I didn't.
post #4 of 20
I want to sub because I can't write now (I'm at my mom's) but I have a story too and would love to participate. Many things you write in your OP resonate with me as I have been on a journey from a non-Christian religion to Christianity, out for a while, back in Christiainity again, and then back out. I have wandered the desert for a few years now and though I do not see myself ever returning to the Christian church for pretty much the same reasons you write, I do feel drawn to something. I will return when I have more time to reply.
post #5 of 20
subbing as my computer is far into the red but I am here as well and would like to input and learn...
post #6 of 20
You've put a lot of stuff out there and I would like to reply to some of it. So you know where I'm coming from, I have never left Christianity, but I have had to struggle with a lot of things from my fundamentalist upbringing that were damaging and not life giving.

To address your points:

The Bible: There are several more liberal churches that hold similar views to yours on biblical inspiration. I don't think that your views here disqualify you from considering Christianity.

Dualism: The body/soul disconnect that you point out is NOT Christian. I'm not saying that some (even many) Christians do not teach this. A lot of people have bad theology. But it is not Christian; it is gnostic. I agree that this disconnect leads to problems in our culture.

God and gender: God is not male. God is beyond gender. There are of course Christians who are confused about this, but it is not Christian to claim that God is male.

Jesus as personal savior: The real hang up for me here is the "personal" part. Christ is savior of all including the entire created order, not just human beings. It is Jesus' mission to bring healing and reconciliation to his entire creation. This relates back to the dualism issue. I think it is a mistake for those Christians who think that only their souls will be resurrected while they go off to some perfect place in the sky. Christianity actually teaches a bodily resurrection. The soul and body are not separated. The work of ushering in Christ's kingdom means that Jesus is working to, as theologian N.T. Wright says, "set the world to rights." I think that the overemphasis on Jesus as "personal" savior springs from the highly individualistic nature of our culture.
post #7 of 20
Subbing so I can come back and add to this thread later (crying child at the moment)
post #8 of 20
As I wrote above, I have been in Christianity, lapsed (but didn't leave), recommit, and then leave for good. I was raised with metaphysical beliefs by my mom; my dad was agnostic at best. I converted in college and for the better part of twelve years, was very involved in Christianity (evangelical, and at times, fundamentalist, always with a non-denominational church). Dh ended up converting when I recommitted myself to the church and we were baptized together. Our older two boys were dedicated in our church where we were members and we were quite involved. One thing lead to the next, and I found myself one summer night up until dawn comparing the beliefs of Christianity with the Jewish Tanach; I could no longer align the two nor had faith enough to ignore the inconsistencies. I officially had lost my religion.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ursusarctos View Post
So in the past year or so I have started to identify my feeling of "the universe" as God again. I do believe in God now, very much. I read several Christian blogs regularly, and I like a lot about it: the service of others, the surrender to God in your everyday life, the "attitude of gratitude", the emphasis on love and forgiveness, the mindfulness. Not that Buddhism doesn't have these too, but they are just so much less focused on in my experience. Or somehow harder for me to access. In many ways I identify very much with Christian beliefs. But I have a few issues, particularly intellectual issues that I didn't have much of an problem with as a child. But I can't seem to quash my fascination with Christianity no matter how much I keep getting hung up on these issues, which is why I decided to write this monster post. Maybe those of you who converted to Christianity can help me with these.
For one, the Bible. I have trouble taking the whole thing as God's word. While I do believe that parts of it could certainly have been divinely inspired, I mostly see it as the product of the historical forces that made it. I also believe that the holy texts of other religions have much "divine" in them and I can't believe that Christianity is the only way to God. This might not actually be that big of an issue; at the Catholic school I went to for example they were very ecumenical and the interpretation of the Bible was very symbolic.
After I left Christianity, I had huge issues with the Bible, and by extension any holy book. I have a hard time believing that the Universe/God/the Divine can be put into a box, let alone a single bound book. As I said above, I could not align Christian dogma with what I read in the Jewish scriptures. As well, the only real "education" on the Bible was from fairly literal points of view (the Creation story was not taken literally, at least by the leaders of our church, but much else was taken very literally). Since I left, I have come to see all holy books as containing truth - kind of in the way that you can read something and find truth for your life within the words. I think many people across time and space have been inspired to write words of wisdom for us, but I also feel that those words have been editted and miscontrued and misused through out history.
Quote:
For another, the dualism. I have a huge amount of trouble believing that the soul is separate from the body. I think that belief has been the root of a lot of bad things in our culture and it just bothers me. I feel that God is in everything, that essentially there is nothing but God and that the biological processes of physical life are also part of that. I don't believe things are separate, I believe we just see them that way (there's the Buddhist influence) and we need to get past that flawed perception in order to be really happy. I also have issues with the idea of heaven and hell, though I realize there are a ton of different understandings of those within Christianity.
I don't think I have had much experience with the idea of dualism, but maybe because I have never held that belief, so even if it was talked about at our church, it just didn't make an impact on me. And yea, the literalness of heaven and hell in the afterlife does not sit well with me either. I do take Jesus at his words when he said that the Kingdom of God is at hand; I believe that we make our own personal hell and heaven now. I just read a Buddhist tale to my boys the other day where a samarai interupted a monk's meditation to have him teach about heaven and hell. The monk proceeded to insult the samarai until the samarai was red with anger and threatened to kill the monk. "That," he said, "is hell." When the monk realized how he felt and then felt his anger disappate, the monk said, "That is heaven." (Sorry for butchering that - it's a quick paraphrase . ) That, to me, sums up heaven and hell. Unfortunately, that was not how our church taught it.
Quote:
Also the explicit patriarchalism and the misogyny of a lot of Christianity's big names (Augustine for example; this is actually also an issue for me with most major religions). I see this as a relic of the historical context in which the Bible/other religious writings were written but it still bothers me. And does God have to be male in Christianity for example? Or is God beyond gender?
I take huge issue with the patriarchalism in religion in general. Though our church allowed women to preside over men (it was progressive in many ways), it was still a man-lead church based on a man-lead religion. I think I'm too be of a conspiracist to believe that Jesus taught only to men (or that he was not married), and I shudder to think of the treatment of women over the course of human history at the hands of men that used religion as their weapon of choice. I do not buy into the argument of not letting the actions of men cloud the religion/belief. Those actions are part and parcel of the religion/belief in my opinion and I just cannot in good faith participate. Oh, and I believe that God defies gender - and even if there is anything considered gender involved, it is both man and woman - kind of the "two became one" type thing. How else could any of us, if one believes in a creator, believe that we as women were created in the likeness of our creator if our creator is only male. Doesn't make sense.
Quote:
And of course I'm coming to the big one... Jesus as a personal savior. Though I am starting to think that this is a Mystery that just can't be comprehended intellectually and goes to a far deeper, symbolic and less verbal level than literally believing the death and resurrection story and that's that, so oddly I might have less trouble with this one than the previous ones.
I think my beliefs since leaving the church have been clouded (or maybe enlightened ) by gnostic readings. But, I do not believe that Jesus (and honestly, I still wrestle with the idea of whether his was historically a person or not) meant to be a personal savior. I see it much differently - that the focus should be on his life and not his death. That we should focus on his message, which is a universal message - love God (the Divine, the source from which we all are connected, ultimately meaning to love oneself as a human expression of that Divine), and love each other as ourselves (recognize the Divine in every one). Isn't that basically the same idea of the greeting of "namaste"? We are to realize that we are all children of the Divine and I think the teachings of Jesus point us to that. He is the Way because his is a path of Love; there is no other way to the Divine except the path of Love. For when we are not existing within the context of Love, we are no longer connected to our Source.
Quote:
Part of me feels that these issues are essentially not all that important, and that I should just put less emphasis on them and instead focus on the lifestyle and the actual practice of Christianity rather than the "theory" part. Though since the "theory" is what makes a religion unique from other religions it would seem dishonest to just ignore it and still identify as a Christian.
So... getting close to the end of my life story here I am so grateful if you are still reading I guess I'm particularly interested in the thoughts of those of you who have struggled or are struggling with these issues. Also if someone knows of a particular belief system or interpretation of Christianity (and I know there are many) that deals with the issues I have I would love to hear. Though before suggesting that I just not bother with Christianity please remember that the whole reason I wrote this is because I can't seem to shake Christianity in my spiritual search, despite my intellectual knowledge that my beliefs do not seem to match up 100%.
I think that's it... whew!
I have a pull back to church. I miss so much about it. I crave the music as the act of raising our voices together as one in such a pure way is an incredibly moving experience for me. But, I cannot align my beliefs with the dogma taught by the church. I am slowly recreating my own beliefs. They are largely metaphysical. They are also somewhat gnostic. I am incredibly redrawn to the message of Jesus, but from what I think many in a church would consider an heretical point of view. Right now I am fascinated with the idea of Mary Magdalene as Jesus' wife and a co-prophet with him. I have some Buddhist leanings. But mostly, I am working on rediscovering and recultivating my faith. I'm not 100% sure in what I have faith. But, I know I choose faith. And I'm working on it. I do not know if we'll ever return to any structure of a church; if we do, it would either be a Religious Science/Science of Mind church or a Unity church. But, for now, I am beginning again the act of praying. And, I am opening myself up to the teachings found in a variety of holy books, including Gnostic writings.
post #9 of 20
Well, you have certianly hit the big questions!!! I'll give you my thoughts - I come from a pretty catholic Anglican tradition myself. I became a Christian after I went to university and started to study philosophy.

Quote:
Originally Posted by ursusarctos View Post
For one, the Bible. I have trouble taking the whole thing as God's word. While I do believe that parts of it could certainly have been divinely inspired, I mostly see it as the product of the historical forces that made it. I also believe that the holy texts of other religions have much "divine" in them and I can't believe that Christianity is the only way to God. This might not actually be that big of an issue; at the Catholic school I went to for example they were very ecumenical and the interpretation of the Bible was very symbolic.
There is quite a bit of variation in how different Christians interpret the Bible. There are those who think it was inspired by God, just as all realigious texts are, and that tends to put them in a position of believing Christianity is one path to God among many.
A more traditional way of looking at it is that it is a special revelation made by God. That does not mean that there were no historical forces at work however, and that has never been the position of the Christian church. Rather, they believe it was through those historical processes that God worked. God gives us humans a certian amount of freedom, but he is still able to arrange things, all those interconnections in the universe, to ensure that certian important events , like the creation of the Bible, take place in a way that is acceptable.
Now, historically the Bible has not all been understood "literally." Some of it is symbolic, or allegorical, or poetic. It is a fairly big topic to see what is appropriate for different parts of the Bible.
Now, even with that understanding of the Bible, it is still possible to think other religious works are "divinely inspired" but obviously not in the same way. Typically, they are considered examples of natural religion.

Quote:
For another, the dualism. I have a huge amount of trouble believing that the soul is separate from the body. I think that belief has been the root of a lot of bad things in our culture and it just bothers me. I feel that God is in everything, that essentially there is nothing but God and that the biological processes of physical life are also part of that. I don't believe things are separate, I believe we just see them that way (there's the Buddhist influence) and we need to get past that flawed perception in order to be really happy. I also have issues with the idea of heaven and hell, though I realize there are a ton of different understandings of those within Christianity.
OK, this is a major misunderstanding of Christianity, which is very much against duealism. So for Christians, we think the body and soul are radically one, and cannot exist along, in any permanent way (this is why many Christians say the soul enters the body at conception, and are agaist abortion; there can be no matter without a form, or soul.) Also, Christianity says that the divine Logos, or Word, which could also be translated as the Tao, is what runs through all things and makes them what they are. So the source of our being is found in God. However, we also say that we are separate things from God, not a part of him in a pantheist sense. Which is to say, that he made each of us our own creatures.
Now, Christians do say that a kind of separation between us and God occurred, which is why we feel separated from him, and why we can't always see what we should do, or even do it when we see clearly. THat happened through the human act of choosing untruth over truth - it put us in the position of not being "in tune" with God completely. But of course the main point of the Christian message is that God took action to fix that, and bring us back to unity with him.

Quote:
Also the explicit patriarchalism and the misogyny of a lot of Christianity's big names (Augustine for example; this is actually also an issue for me with most major religions). I see this as a relic of the historical context in which the Bible/other religious writings were written but it still bothers me. And does God have to be male in Christianity for example? Or is God beyond gender?
In Christianity, God does not have a gender; gender belongs to creatures that have a body. We tend to address God as male, most (not all) of the Biblical images of him are male, and particularly, Jesus addressed him as male. So why? Well, it would be weird to call him an "it" since in Christianity he is very much presented as a person. (Maybe if the Bible were written for amoebas?) That is different from in the classical pagan religions, where he is definatly an it - but has no interest or even knowledge of his creation. And so we are kind of stuck with the image of a father or mother - and the Bible seems to take the position that God is, in human terms, more like a father than a mother. But he isn't actually either - his relationship with creation is unique.
On the misogyny - yes there is some, in the tradition, that comes from a historical setting. I'm fond of Augustine, personally, and have never found him all that offensive on that issue. As far as examples such as Paul saying that wives would submit to their husbands, there is a lot of disagreement about whether this was meant to be understood within the particular cultural context he was writing in, or in a more universal way. My suggestion would be not to worry too much about it, and keep an open mind both ways - it's not impossible that it might be meant either way, but I think it is best understood from a pretty sure Christian base either way. It's hard to wrestle with from the point of an outsider.


Quote:
And of course I'm coming to the big one... Jesus as a personal savior. Though I am starting to think that this is a Mystery that just can't be comprehended intellectually and goes to a far deeper, symbolic and less verbal level than literally believing the death and resurrection story and that's that, so oddly I might have less trouble with this one than the previous ones.
Yes, there is a lot to the story of the ressurecton, though most see it as being a historical event, and not a symbolic story. Remember I said that Chrsitianity was not duealistic, but that we were sperated through our own actions from God, and so had to be brount back to unity with him? Well, that includes the body; that unity isn't just intellectual, but includes the body, the world, all of creation. If the story is symbolic, than only the immaterial part, the idea, is really reconciled. It is in the person of Jesus, who is a real union of God and human, spirit and flesh, that that happens. (Why did God do it that way - that is a big mystery.)
Quote:
Part of me feels that these issues are essentially not all that important, and that I should just put less emphasis on them and instead focus on the lifestyle and the actual practice of Christianity rather than the "theory" part. Though since the "theory" is what makes a religion unique from other religions it would seem dishonest to just ignore it and still identify as a Christian.
I think that the practice of any religion I can think of depends heavily on the theory. Certainly, it seems odd to subscribe to a worldview that you think is actually untrue, though of course noone knows for sure. I would say that sometimes if there is a particular issue that doesn't seem clear to you, practice can begin to make it more clear. I have never really be drawn to the whole "Jesus Christ is your personal Savior" thing, though I understand what it is supposed to mean. But maybe one day it will become clearer to me.

Quote:
So... getting close to the end of my life story here I am so grateful if you are still reading I guess I'm particularly interested in the thoughts of those of you who have struggled or are struggling with these issues. Also if someone knows of a particular belief system or interpretation of Christianity (and I know there are many) that deals with the issues I have I would love to hear. Though before suggesting that I just not bother with Christianity please remember that the whole reason I wrote this is because I can't seem to shake Christianity in my spiritual search, despite my intellectual knowledge that my beliefs do not seem to match up 100%.
I think that's it... whew!
A lot of the things you are asking about are pretty basic questions, logically, but also historically, and they are intellectually oriented. I've found the Roman Catholics and the Orthodox are the most likely to have good teaching programs that address the history and the basic issues, though I'm not sure I see you in those churches... Other churches do have that stuff, but I find less reliably, there seems to be more variation between congregations. But in all denominations, some congregations aren't blessed with good teachers, so try not to hold that against them if you run into one.
post #10 of 20
Wow, this is a fascinating thread. I find it fascinating that others are 'being called back' as you put it. Ive never left Christ. I have left church tho and a lot of the teachings of the church behind. When I say left the church, I mean Big Church Christianity. When I say that, I mean all the stuff you have to wade thru to get to the heart of these kinds of questions. I have no advice to offer. I have come to the conclusion, no matter how it sounds to someone else, that the bible is the Word of God, that he's revealed himself thru the bible. Im one of those who beleives it is inspired by God and I came to that conclusion on my own, doing my own studying, meditating and praying. That doesnt mean to say that I believe that every single word was inspired or that it doesnt contain some errors (grammatical, some misunderstandings, etc which I havent figured out yet). The biggest thing for me... if you read my siggie... thats it. I know Jesus Christ and God the Father thru Him. Its been a very special adventure to Know Christ. Very very special. I did the whole sinners prayer when I was 21. It was all SO interesting as I look back on it and Im coming up to my 11th anniversary of that moment. I can relate to a lot of the old hymns, psalms, been thru a lot, seen a lot, and Know Christ has carried me thru SO much. There is definately a special relationship there, and Im still learning. I did go thru a crisis of my faith, where I didnt know if I could believe it all anymore, was very confused, but when I came thru that, a certain set of very, extremely difficult circumstances which God carried me thru, my faith in Him was stronger, I couldnt deny His existance any longer, the confusion was gone and Im actually greatful I went thru that hardship just to come out of it all knowing God that bit better. I just wish you all all the best as you search 'for your way in this word' or where you fit in... which ever it was said, lol. I just say keep seeking absolute truth. Its out there. And to those who seek, it shall be found. If you want anymore direct answers Id be happy to give them but Im not sure anyone wants to hear those so Ill leave it at that. God bless in your 'travels'!!

hugs!!
post #11 of 20
Can I just say that perhaps you dont need any particular sect or denomination or order of Christianity to find the answers to the questions you have. We have direct access to God thru Christ (sorry if you dont like the sound of that... to anyone of another faith, sorry if that sounds offensive). And can I say that the answers dont necessarily need to come right away. Sin (just as an example) was something I couldnt get my head around when I was first 'saved'. The fact that I needed a Saviour was very foreign to me, its only been in the last few years that I realised why Christ had to do that.

Quote:
And of course I'm coming to the big one... Jesus as a personal savior. Though I am starting to think that this is a Mystery that just can't be comprehended intellectually and goes to a far deeper, symbolic and less verbal level than literally believing the death and resurrection story and that's that, so oddly I might have less trouble with this one than the previous ones.
I think it is a mystery. OOoooOOh these things are SO exciting to discover, Im telling you. Well maybe its just me and my personality, I dont know. I do believe it was a historical event and I do so bc of the impact Christianity has had in the world and how it was a persecuted sect to begin with that seemed to have NO chance. Anyway, I only want to encourage you really and not give you 'answers' or speculations or what I beleive, bc its only going to mean anything to you when you discover it yourself. No church can give all the answers. Its a deep personal thing.
post #12 of 20
Ok, I'm back now. I didn't read any of the responses yet, so sorry if I repeat anything that's been said already.

I was raised baptist. Started studying religion when I was 12 and finally settled on paganism as a general term that allowed me to take a bit of truth from every faith I'd studied and create my own belief system. That worked for a long time. But there tends to be an over-focus on the Goddess in paganism and less of a focus on the God. When DS1 was about 9 months old, I started feeling really out of balance. I felt like I needed to start placing more emphasis on God. I decided I would try out some different churches and see how I felt.

Someone on diaperswappers suggested that I try out an LDS church (mormon). I went once, hated the insanely pushy missionaries, and decided it wasn't for me. Spent the next 6 months or so at a methodist church before I decided that I would give the LDS church just one more try. And I am SOOO glad that I did.

It's strange - I spent years putting together my our faith from pieces of this and pieces of that. And yet I stepped into a church with beliefs nearly identical to mine! (Including the belief in God's wife - a presence that had originally led me to paganism and one I could never deny, no matter what church I went to).

Now, it's hard to explain a lot of my beliefs that aren't quite that of the church, but would answer some of your questions. I am a universalist by nature. I do not believe there is only one way to God. My husband, in fact, is still pagan. And I am glad that he has found what connects him with God, in the same way he is glad that I have found my path. LDS believe that EVERYONE will be resurrected (with their bodies) and go to heaven. What level of heaven depends on the choices you make here in this life. "Hell" is for Satan and those who sided with him in the great conflict in heaven. Just the fact that we are here on this earth means that we sided with Heavenly Father, and because we already made that decision, Jesus died for all of us - whether we choose to believe or not.

At first glance, our faith seems VERY patriarichal. We have many people who speak against us because women are not given the priesthood, for example. And yet the position of Mother is SO highly valued. We have enough responsibility nuturing our families - why would we want to add the huge responsibility of carrying the priesthood on top of that? There have also been comments made by general authorities that say that the characteristics that the priesthood gives to men are things that we naturally have as women. Sometimes I think women are respected more than the men are, so it makes me laugh when people think it's the other way around. lol As I've already stated, yes we belief that God is male, but he has an equal, a wife, who is so holy that She is rarely ever mentioned. Heavenly Father doesn't want her name to be taken in vain and disrespected the way that He is. Now personally whether I believe these things litterally or whether it's just a way for our brains to interpret things in a way that we encounter them here on earth, I'm not sure. It is completely possible that GOD exists beyond gender, and because of that, it is easier to think of GOD as both - male and female, balanced.

We also believe that the Bible is the word of God, but only when it is translated correctly. There are many things that don't make sense in the Bible as it is currently translated. There's a section in the OT (I don't remember exactly where) where it talks about how God *tried* to kill someone. Um...sorry. If God tried to kill someone, they'd be dead. There's also quite a bit missing from the Bible. Google the Council of Nicea. It was essentially a group of men that got together and decided what belongs in the Bible and what doesn't. Many precious things were lost from that. (And only some of them restored in the Book of Mormon).
post #13 of 20
I am definitely enjoying this thread. I posted already but agree with someof the other posts that my relationship with God is in my heart. I stopped going to church shortly after experiencing one too many hypocrites in the church. I know that should not of stopped me but becuase of that I was opened to many other beliefs. I haven't ever been to a universal church but am interested.
post #14 of 20
Thread Starter 
Oh my goodness everybody, thank you for the AWESOME posts!!! It has been amazing to read everyone's story and explanations and everything else! I am a bit overwhelmed, in fact! I will try to respond more fully soon but just wanted to express how cool and interesting and informative it has been reading the responses here and that I didn't abandon the thread
post #15 of 20
This thread rocks! Absolutely rocks.

OP, I am in a "spiritual crisis" as well, and could have written your post word for word. I feel like I have no idea where I belong lately and it sucks.

And Moonprysm, you have me kind of curious about LDS now! Who would have thought!
post #16 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by ~Boudicca~ View Post
And Moonprysm, you have me kind of curious about LDS now! Who would have thought!
I LOVE my church. We respect all faiths and acknowledge that all faiths have some truth in them. Which makes sense that a lot of my beliefs were ones that I had originally drawn from other religions and just happened to be part of the accepted beliefs of the LDS church as well.
post #17 of 20
*subbing*
I'm in the same boat. Hearing the proverbial call back.
post #18 of 20
subbing

this is very interesting.
post #19 of 20
Thanks for asking this...I could have written much of what you did as well! I have loved reading everyone's replies. DH and I are struggling to come up a more solid idea of what we believe (after being raised Catholic) and don't feel like we will ever fit into a particular church. I really miss the feeling of community, though, and so we might try out the Unitarian church in the town where we are moving to.

It's hard, because I do believe in God and the entire philosophy of "namaste" as a PP said...but I'm not sure I'm into religion. Seems to me that often, as soon as you assign a system to something as immense and amazing as God, things have the potential to go bad pretty quickly.

I see the Bible as a story; every other civilization has a creation story, and rules, and a history, and some type of savior figure, and an explanation for death and life, etc.
post #20 of 20
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by papayapetunia View Post
I have found a good home in the Unity church. It is Christ-based, but uses ideas from all over. We don't believe in hell or sin, just consciousness and separation from consciousness. The Bible is not taken as an absolute literal truth. We find a lot of symbolism and inspiration from it though. I really just feel good every time I go to church now. The messages are positive and nourishing. It's nice to go to church because it makes me feel good and not because I'd feel guilty if I didn't.
Do you mean Unitarian Universalist? It sounds good in terms of non-dogmatism. I don't think they have an active congregation in Finland though, I'll have to check.

Quote:
Originally Posted by indie View Post
Dualism: The body/soul disconnect that you point out is NOT Christian. I'm not saying that some (even many) Christians do not teach this. A lot of people have bad theology. But it is not Christian; it is gnostic. I agree that this disconnect leads to problems in our culture.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bluegoat View Post
OK, this is a major misunderstanding of Christianity, which is very much against duealism. So for Christians, we think the body and soul are radically one, and cannot exist along, in any permanent way (this is why many Christians say the soul enters the body at conception, and are agaist abortion; there can be no matter without a form, or soul.) Also, Christianity says that the divine Logos, or Word, which could also be translated as the Tao, is what runs through all things and makes them what they are. So the source of our being is found in God. However, we also say that we are separate things from God, not a part of him in a pantheist sense. Which is to say, that he made each of us our own creatures.
Now, Christians do say that a kind of separation between us and God occurred, which is why we feel separated from him, and why we can't always see what we should do, or even do it when we see clearly. THat happened through the human act of choosing untruth over truth - it put us in the position of not being "in tune" with God completely. But of course the main point of the Christian message is that God took action to fix that, and bring us back to unity with him.

...

Yes, there is a lot to the story of the ressurecton, though most see it as being a historical event, and not a symbolic story. Remember I said that Chrsitianity was not duealistic, but that we were sperated through our own actions from God, and so had to be brount back to unity with him? Well, that includes the body; that unity isn't just intellectual, but includes the body, the world, all of creation. If the story is symbolic, than only the immaterial part, the idea, is really reconciled. It is in the person of Jesus, who is a real union of God and human, spirit and flesh, that that happens. (Why did God do it that way - that is a big mystery.)
: OH! Wow. Bluegoat, your explanation of Logos was a revelation to me. Thank you. Wow.
I am surprised to hear it expressed that Christianity is actually not dualistic, though of course when I think about the points you and indie bring up it makes a lot of sense. I have just been exposed to an attitude of "our present physical life doesn't really matter because ultimately we're going to our real (spiritual) home in heaven anyway".

Quote:
Originally Posted by genifer View Post
Can I just say that perhaps you dont need any particular sect or denomination or order of Christianity to find the answers to the questions you have. We have direct access to God thru Christ (sorry if you dont like the sound of that... to anyone of another faith, sorry if that sounds offensive). And can I say that the answers dont necessarily need to come right away. Sin (just as an example) was something I couldnt get my head around when I was first 'saved'. The fact that I needed a Saviour was very foreign to me, its only been in the last few years that I realised why Christ had to do that.

I think it is a mystery. OOoooOOh these things are SO exciting to discover, Im telling you. Well maybe its just me and my personality, I dont know. I do believe it was a historical event and I do so bc of the impact Christianity has had in the world and how it was a persecuted sect to begin with that seemed to have NO chance. Anyway, I only want to encourage you really and not give you 'answers' or speculations or what I beleive, bc its only going to mean anything to you when you discover it yourself. No church can give all the answers. Its a deep personal thing.
Thank you for your encouragement, gennifer. I also have a friend who does have a deep personal relationship with Jesus and from this I know that it can be an amazing thing for people. And in fact it is people like you who seem to gain a deep sense of personal joy and peace from their relationship to Jesus that makes me interested too

Though it has been interesting to hear from other people that you can still be a Christian without having to approach Jesus on such a personal level.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Moonprysm View Post
Now, it's hard to explain a lot of my beliefs that aren't quite that of the church, but would answer some of your questions. I am a universalist by nature. I do not believe there is only one way to God. My husband, in fact, is still pagan. And I am glad that he has found what connects him with God, in the same way he is glad that I have found my path. LDS believe that EVERYONE will be resurrected (with their bodies) and go to heaven. What level of heaven depends on the choices you make here in this life. "Hell" is for Satan and those who sided with him in the great conflict in heaven. Just the fact that we are here on this earth means that we sided with Heavenly Father, and because we already made that decision, Jesus died for all of us - whether we choose to believe or not.

At first glance, our faith seems VERY patriarichal. We have many people who speak against us because women are not given the priesthood, for example. And yet the position of Mother is SO highly valued. We have enough responsibility nuturing our families - why would we want to add the huge responsibility of carrying the priesthood on top of that? There have also been comments made by general authorities that say that the characteristics that the priesthood gives to men are things that we naturally have as women. Sometimes I think women are respected more than the men are, so it makes me laugh when people think it's the other way around. lol As I've already stated, yes we belief that God is male, but he has an equal, a wife, who is so holy that She is rarely ever mentioned. Heavenly Father doesn't want her name to be taken in vain and disrespected the way that He is. Now personally whether I believe these things litterally or whether it's just a way for our brains to interpret things in a way that we encounter them here on earth, I'm not sure. It is completely possible that GOD exists beyond gender, and because of that, it is easier to think of GOD as both - male and female, balanced.

We also believe that the Bible is the word of God, but only when it is translated correctly. There are many things that don't make sense in the Bible as it is currently translated. There's a section in the OT (I don't remember exactly where) where it talks about how God *tried* to kill someone. Um...sorry. If God tried to kill someone, they'd be dead. There's also quite a bit missing from the Bible. Google the Council of Nicea. It was essentially a group of men that got together and decided what belongs in the Bible and what doesn't. Many precious things were lost from that. (And only some of them restored in the Book of Mormon).
Wow Moonprysm, that is fascinating. I had no idea LDS was so complex and... happy! Thank you for sharing!

I guess this is not that thorough of a response after all There is just so much food for thought here. Thank you all so much for your input and for making this such a cool thread. I think I have to investigate Christianity more deeply. Since I have been ignoring the small voice telling me to go read the gospels for ages now, perhaps it's time to stop making excuses and pay attention...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Spirituality
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Spirituality › If your first religion was Christianity and you eventually "quit" but later heard it calling...