Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Just a happy story!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Just a happy story!

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
For background, I'm the middle of 3 children. I'm 20, my sister M is 15 and my brother C is 28, and married with two daughters. I posted before about how my brother and his wife are devoutly pro-circ

Well, today my sister and I were talking about how awful it is when little baby girls have their ears pierced. It's painful, piercing with a gun is a big no-no, and they very well might not want their ears pierced but will never have a choice. M is one of those girls who doesn't have pierced ears and never will, she hates them.

Anyhow, she was saying how she wouldn't get her future daughter's ears pierced because she couldn't stomach the thought of causing her baby pain. I asked if she would circ any sons she had. She gave me this slightly horrified face and said "NO!" I asked if she knew what it was, and she said "kind of, but I know it hurts them." I quickly told her exactly what it was, and she was absolutely disgusted and said she'd NEVER do it to her sons

To make things better, I asked what she'd do if her husband was convinced that they needed to circ. She said "I'll tell him that I was the one who carried the baby and delivered it naturally and no WAY is he doing that to my son." I grinned and told her I'd help sway her husband if he was pro-circ.

I just can't say how happy this makes me. Mainly because my sister has probably heard about circumcision maybe twice in her life. She's never talked to me about it, and seeing as the only living intact man in our family is our grandpa (and she doesn't even know that), intactness is not the "norm" in our family. It's so great...here's a girl who barely knew what it involved, and still knew it was bad! There's hope! It makes me so happy to know that my future boys will have some intact cousins to run around with, and that 2 of 3 kids will raise intact children. I'm just so excited, and knew you ladies and gents would understand
post #2 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by KaylaBeanie View Post
For background, I'm the middle of 3 children. I'm 20, my sister M is 15 and my brother C is 28, and married with two daughters. I posted before about how my brother and his wife are devoutly pro-circ

Well, today my sister and I were talking about how awful it is when little baby girls have their ears pierced. It's painful, piercing with a gun is a big no-no, and they very well might not want their ears pierced but will never have a choice. M is one of those girls who doesn't have pierced ears and never will, she hates them.

Anyhow, she was saying how she wouldn't get her future daughter's ears pierced because she couldn't stomach the thought of causing her baby pain. I asked if she would circ any sons she had. She gave me this slightly horrified face and said "NO!" I asked if she knew what it was, and she said "kind of, but I know it hurts them." I quickly told her exactly what it was, and she was absolutely disgusted and said she'd NEVER do it to her sons

To make things better, I asked what she'd do if her husband was convinced that they needed to circ. She said "I'll tell him that I was the one who carried the baby and delivered it naturally and no WAY is he doing that to my son." I grinned and told her I'd help sway her husband if he was pro-circ.

I just can't say how happy this makes me. Mainly because my sister has probably heard about circumcision maybe twice in her life. She's never talked to me about it, and seeing as the only living intact man in our family is our grandpa (and she doesn't even know that), intactness is not the "norm" in our family. It's so great...here's a girl who barely knew what it involved, and still knew it was bad! There's hope! It makes me so happy to know that my future boys will have some intact cousins to run around with, and that 2 of 3 kids will raise intact children. I'm just so excited, and knew you ladies and gents would understand
All right! That's great especially considering the fact that she is 15.
post #3 of 9
The youth really do seem to get it. I think that this is the PERFECT age to have that discussion and plant those seeds. Younger people seem to be more receptive b/c they don't have any stocks in circumcision yet and they are always willing to question things. Maybe we should take this idea and run with it. NOCIRC/Intact America ads in young people magazines????
post #4 of 9
Thread Starter 
^Wouldn't that be great?!

To be honest, I figured when the time came she'd never circ, because she's painfully sensitive and can't stomach the thought of any violence. It's great to have that validation though, and since she IS so young and far from having children, intactness will just seem like the right and obvious choice when she does have kids. It was just the immediate "No" and look of horror that warmed my heart. She gets it. I'm not alone in this family :
post #5 of 9
That is a great story :
I agree 15/16 is a really great age for this discussion.
post #6 of 9
What a great conversation. Glad you shared it with us.:
post #7 of 9
Awesome! Its great to see you and your sister will have each others back on this. Also its great that your proc-circ brother only had girls. Its looking like the next generation of your family will all be intact!:

Hopefully thats a tradition you can carry in your family for as long as it exists. But I guess that means you need to have the "circ talk" with his two daughters at some point in the future.
post #8 of 9
OP, that is a wonderful story, and thank you so much for sharing it!!! :

Quote:
Originally Posted by tutucrazy View Post
The youth really do seem to get it. I think that this is the PERFECT age to have that discussion and plant those seeds. Younger people seem to be more receptive b/c they don't have any stocks in circumcision yet and they are always willing to question things. Maybe we should take this idea and run with it. NOCIRC/Intact America ads in young people magazines????
I absolutely agree with this 100%. I think that the youth are the ones we NEED to be talking to about this.. before their heads get filled with lies and misconceptions. They're way more receptive and for some reason, a great many can see the truth where many adults cannot.

My 15 yr old son was circumcised at birth - this was waaaay before I knew anything about what it entailed - and it wasn't something we ever talked about until just recently. He'd found some papers that I had printed out about circumcision and asked me what it was.. so, I explained it to him. He was absolutely horrified, but VERY understanding that I simply didn't know right from wrong back then. He swears up and down that he will never ever allow it to happen to any sons he may have. My heart just beams knowing that

I haven't gotten into the conversation with my 12 yr old DD at this point, but she has seen me read about it quite often, so I know that it's coming. The only reason that I haven't delved into it with her is because I have no clue what was done to her younger half-brothers. DD is highly argumentative and I don't want her starting a big fight with her dad if they had her brothers circ'd. So, I just haven't quite figured out how to attack this one with her yet. Very soon, though..
post #9 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by Frootloop View Post
OP, that is a wonderful story, and thank you so much for sharing it!!! :


I absolutely agree with this 100%. I think that the youth are the ones we NEED to be talking to about this.. before their heads get filled with lies and misconceptions. They're way more receptive and for some reason, a great many can see the truth where many adults cannot.
true, if you don't tell them the right facts they will get their information from less reliable sources. and about your daughters, do explain to them about how being intact is ok...almost every girl i've dated has brought it up because they had never seen it before and thought it was different/weird because i was usually the only intact guy they had ever been with. it was a lot of wasted time, they should just be ok with it.

and that is a good story, op.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Just a happy story!