I think the room looks much neater when the shower curtain is closed, so that's how I voted. ITA with whoever above mentioned the collection of soaps, shampoo, etc looking much more cluttered than the "smaller space" of the closed shower curtain.
But, in reality, the shower curtain often stays open. If we need to hang any laundry, the curtain NEEDS to stay open so there's room to hang the stuff, and with the washing machine in the bathroom, my bathroom doubles as a laundry room.
Follow Mothering