Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Do you identify to your child things that they're sensitive to?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Do you identify to your child things that they're sensitive to?

post #1 of 26
Thread Starter 
Ok for some this may be a complete no-brainer. If your child is allergic to a certain type of grass, do you identify it for them? If they have a minor medical situation, do you make them aware of it? I'm sure the older generation in our families think DH and I are insane, and I'm not inclined to agree, but hey my perspective may be understandably biased!

A couple years ago when DS was 5, we were visiting the in-laws. DS is allergic to certain types of weeds, and we've identified them to him and advised him to avoid playing around them if possible. He pointed out one at a park and informed his grandma and stepgrandpa that he was allergic to them. They though it was ridiculous that we had taught him that, stating he would use that as an excuse from now on. Would you not teach your child to identify poison ivy and instruct them to avoid it if they were sensitive to it? Were we wrong here?

There are other things that have come up along similar lines. I guess DH and I think the kids have a right to take some control over their health and know what affects them adversly, but on the flip side we're being told we're setting them up to cry babies (they aren't at this point for the most part). Thoughts?

ETA: We don't expect our children to manage their conditions, mild or otherwise. That's our job. We just feel they should be able to have a say in some things and know what to look for as well in certain situations. We are still watching in those situations, but say we're in the park, DS may notice something he's allergic to before we do, etc.
post #2 of 26
I think its perfectly reasonable to help your child be aware of his conditions, and be able to practise "self-defense". My son has some food allergies and sensitivities, and we have carefully explained the food types and combinations he has to avoid, and also to be careful of hidden ingredients and to always ask. Will he use it as an excuse to avoid stuff he doesn't like? Theorically that is possible, but allergies are not fun and honestly I don't see DS taking advantage of it (also he knows its acceptable for him to say "I don't like it", no need for excuses). Anyway even if he did, I'ld rather he knew how to protect himself. True managing his condition is my job, but honestly, he cannot be under my direct supervision 24/7 so better he know what to avoid, and when in doubt, know to say "no thanks". And the people he interacts with in my absence (teachers, grandparents, friends parents etc.) are informed by me what to watch for, but also, explicitly, to respect his responses since he knows what's bad for him.
post #3 of 26
Absolutely. I can't imagine what good it would do to not tell them and have them get into it?

Our boys are allergic to milk. They know this, my oldest at least can read the ingredient list and see if it has milk. My 3 year old regularly tells people who try to feed him if he can't have something because it has milk. I think its incredibly important thing to teach a child who has allergies. Simply because alot of adults don't think allergies are a big deal.
post #4 of 26
it's not just "older" generations... a few years ago i worked in the dining services area at a major local university and at the beginning of each fall we'd get 4 or 5 calls from moms or dads trying to give us lists of things their kids couldn't eat.

the first year i was shocked that the parents let them get to 18 without having to learn about their food allergies, and then even more shocked that they expected us to monitor things for their "kids".

um, sorry, if they are smart enough to get into university, they are smart enough to learn how to read ingredients.

and, i'm all for giving kids information. why not prepare them for situations so that if you aren't there they can still make good choices?
post #5 of 26
Yeah. I think it is a great way for him to learn to take responsibility for his health, figure out what triggers him, and learn to avoid it. I don't think you are setting him up to be a cry-baby but rather the opposite. You certainly don't want him to be the college freshman that the above poster described!
post #6 of 26
to me it just sounds smart and safe!

i have no idea why people would object to something like this--probably like how doctors looked at my parents like they were insane when they deferred questions to me as a child (e.g. "how is she tolerating the macrodantin?" "how often is she doing x or y medical procedure?"). they would act as if i wasn't even there and all seemed incredulous that, at age 7, i knew all my meds, dosages, and the names for everything i had. but why wouldn't i want to know? it's my body!

i think what you're doing is perfectly right.
post #7 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Catubodua View Post
at the beginning of each fall we'd get 4 or 5 calls from moms or dads trying to give us lists of things their kids couldn't eat.
...
and then even more shocked that they expected us to monitor things for their "kids".
?????? No way...
post #8 of 26
i know. seriously. it was so unbelievable to me, but, there it was. that was the job where i truly began to understand what a "helicopter parent" was ....
post #9 of 26
Of course!! Why on earth would you not help your kids learn how to identify plants/foods they're allergic to? Did the grandparents think he should just stumble upon it, suffer through the allergic reaction, have no idea where it came from, and repeat that process over and over until he was old enough to make a correlation between that particular weed and his rash? : I don't get it at all. If parents have information like that and don't share it with their kids, I'd say they're being neglectful.

When I first read your thread title, I thought you were going to ask about parents who reinforce dislikes about more grey-area-type stuff, like if their kid gets scared on a kiddie ride at the fair one year, they might say, "Oh, DS is scared of rides" over and over so that the kid grows up thinking that's true and doesn't try the rides year after year. I can easily see how that type of stuff could be detrimental, but identifying allergens??? That just seems so obvious to me. Your poison oak example was a good one -- we've shown DS poison oak several times on hikes, and now he's able to identify and avoid it himself. Would your ILs somehow think that's bad??? I'm so confused.
post #10 of 26
seems to make sense to me. how are they supposed to learn if we don't help guide them?
post #11 of 26
No, you were not wrong.

Allergies have been on the rise, and parents today are far more aware of them and the dangers then past generations. My inlaws didn't take my allergy concerns seriously when DD was younger so it was even more important to educate DD about them.

All the kids we know can tell you what their allergies are, and are good about avoiding them.

It's not you, it's them!
post #12 of 26
The outdoor allergen thing is so tricky... I guess some people know very specifically which plants they are allergic to but it seems like most people with seasonal allergies have a hodge podge of allergies to various things to varying degrees. I had horrible seasonal allergies as a kid. I was getting shots for a while, but they made me sick, so I stopped after a year or so. I had testing done so I guess I knew what I was allergic to but it was still more like I'd be outside and I could say "My allergies are bad today" or "My eyes are itchy, I have to go outside" or "Wow, I feel OK today!" - it wasn't like I would go to the park and be like, whoops, that's XXX, I have to stay over here! Because everything together would or wouldn't bother me... I know people will say "ragweed bothers me" or whatever but I always thought it wasn't so much that plant was near as that plant was in season so just being outdoor anywhere within a few miles would be bad....

The only thing I will try to actively avoid is poison oak/ivy as my last reaction to that was SEVERE and I have a feeling I am going to be in a heap of trouble if I get it again.

My son has outdoor allergies - we haven't had him tested, we just give him medicine if he is having a bad allergy day.

Anyway outdoor stuff I find complex. I don't know if I would bother being specific with a child. I don't know if you always CAN...

Foods, I would definately be specific.
post #13 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Catubodua View Post
i know. seriously. it was so unbelievable to me, but, there it was. that was the job where i truly began to understand what a "helicopter parent" was ....
Unfortunately it's in the classroom as well. I've had parents want to call or email to tell me about their children's issues with test-taking or to discuss why their child got a certain grade. I would have been humiliated if my mom had done that when I was in college. My mentor actually has started saying clearly at the beginning of classes that she will not talk to parents about classes. If you can't talk to her, then you don't need to be in college.
post #14 of 26
I agree with the other posters. It is ridiculous (imo) not to at least make your child aware so they can be empowered to learn about what makes their bodies tick and how to be the healthiest they can be (with your help and guidance of course!)

That having been said though, I do know some people who have struck the fear of God into their children about every.single.situation.or.ingredient, and around every turn, something is out to kill them... which of course, is not very empowering to me.

However, that is rare, and that doesn't sound AT ALL like what you are doing.
post #15 of 26
It's only logical to me to inform your own child about their health issues. Allergies for instance, I can't think of any reason to not tell a child about them. One day they are going to have to be on their own and have to identify what will make them sick.
post #16 of 26
Um, yeah. My child has extensive food allergies, many of them potentially life-threatening. What's the alternative? Risk her life by not CLEARLY explaining that some foods could make her very ill? Make her think mom and dad are horrible ogres who just don't let her have Oreos and bagels out of spite? I generally agree with the whole "blessing of a skinned knee" idea (allow your kids to make mistakes, fail, even get hurt, as learning and growth experiences), but I can't quite get on board with the blessing of the defibrillator in the ambulance to the ER.

Catubodoa...wtf? What if the kids went out to eat? It sounds like these aren't serious food allergies. (The kid would know if he carried an Epi-Pen, right? My 3 yo knows about her Epi-Pen, for Pete's sake.) I'm wondering if it's more "Oh, poor Precious can't sleep well if she has too much chocolate."
post #17 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by BrandiRhoades View Post
Unfortunately it's in the classroom as well. I've had parents want to call or email to tell me about their children's issues with test-taking or to discuss why their child got a certain grade. I would have been humiliated if my mom had done that when I was in college. My mentor actually has started saying clearly at the beginning of classes that she will not talk to parents about classes. If you can't talk to her, then you don't need to be in college.
Sorry to contribute to the side conversation, but I just have to share this: My aunt has, multiple times, called her adult son's BOSSES to chew them out for something work-related that happened with her son!! : Can you imagine?? And the worst part is that this doesn't embarrass her son; in fact, he'll run home to tell her about a work problem so that she can handle it. I can't even imagine what his teachers had to deal with from her when he was in school.
post #18 of 26
OP: I think it's great that at 5 you were informing him and he was able to identify it for himself without any hinting or questioning. However, I can say my mother taught me (maybe a tad older than 5) what poison ivy looked like and to avoid it or else what happens to me would happen. In all honesty, yeah I did do a lot of , "nope can't do that!" But I am thankful, because less problems for me! And now, I am teaching my 5 year old, though her not having had a reaction (since she's not ever touched poison ivy) she doesn't get why or how it would hurt her, so it's not embedded in her to want to learn which leaves to avoid. But teaching is definitely a positive! Less pain on child is best on both child and parents!
post #19 of 26
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by RunnerDuck View Post
Anyway outdoor stuff I find complex. I don't know if I would bother being specific with a child. I don't know if you always CAN...
The outdoor stuff IS tricky! The way it originally came up was that the previous owners of our house had planted some "decorative" weeds that I and my son are highly allergic to, and I was outside with a mask digging the little buggers up. DS had asked what I was doing and I explained that those particular plants were ones that made our allergies much worse. He then asked if there were any other grasses/weeds in the yard that did that and we showed him the ones that can cause us problems. No doubt this was not an inclusive list and didn't account for the combinations, but the ones we showed him do cause a rash as well as respiratory issues for him. He evidentally remembered this on our visit! My in-laws just couldn't grasp why we would teach him such things and proceeded to mock us and make fun of us, warning that ds would use that as an excuse to get out of everything. Needless to say that wasn't the only issue during the visit and the visit was cut short!
post #20 of 26
I think it would be odd not to. Here in england, we are surrounded by nettle!...It STINGS - and for a long time too after one comes into contact with it. No one wants to touch it and if you are wearing shorts for example, it can get you unawares! lol...So yeah, I have pointed it out to DS and by two he knew exactly what it was and to avoid it! It would be silly not to really.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Do you identify to your child things that they're sensitive to?