Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › I can't believe he did this
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

I can't believe he did this

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
(xposted in childhood yrs)

DS, who will be four next month, did something extremely out of character yesterday at childcare. When I got there to pick him up, two teachers were intercepting him in a tussle with a little girl. They told me he had his hands on her neck.

This is absolutely out of character for him. I am speechless. We talked later about why he did such a thing. He really couldn't give a reason at all, and I doubt it was anything this little girl did/said. As it happens, many of his friends have just transferred schools (as we will do in a matter of weeks), and he did say he was lonely and angry yesterday--but that had nothing to do with this child.

We don't watch TV--we have been VERY careful about exposure to such things. Ordinarily, he is VERY good about talking about his feelings and saying if he is angry, frustrated, etc. I have no idea where he would get that impulse--except from some other kids at the school, which is a big part of why we are getting out of there. Still, that's no excuse.

Has anyone been shocked in this way by your own child's behavior? Can anyone shed any light on this? I am still mortified. We talked about why not to do such a thing to someone, and what to do if he feels unhappy at school, etc. What else should I do? He has NEVER done anything like this before, ever.
post #2 of 6
When my dd was three and a half she bit a child on the back. She hadn't bitten anyone since she turned two and she didn't hit or show any signs of aggression except that one time. Her teacher's were great about it and didn't make a big deal out of it. She hasn't done it again since then. She does periodically try out other things she sees kids doing that aren't really her thing and they end pretty quickly with only a little talking about the alternative things she can do when she is upset or wanting attention. I think that you shouldn't worry unless it happens a couple more times.
post #3 of 6
my 10 year old uncharacteristicly beat up a 10 year old girl when he was 7...he had been fenceing with her with plastic swords (they both fence) and she somehow made him feel that she was being unfair (she admitted that she was being very dominate with him) and he went ballistic all over her...I was SO embarressed.

He has never done anything like that since...he felt really sorry about hurting her (she was shakeing from the attack)and bought her flowers with his own money, and wrote an apology...they are still really close friends today. though she is a toung teen, and he is 10. All I can say is that children have some really primal instincts at times, and don't always have the cognitave ability to stop themselves from acting out what they feel. (a good reason to always supervise so that quick intervention in possible..)

Don't feel too upset...he obviously needs to understand why he MUST apologise...but it doesn't mean he is a "bad" kid...or that he is more violent than other kids...or that t.v. is the issue.

IF he continues to act out like this though, I would suggest a child therapist, simply because there may be something else that is hurting him inside that he doesn't want to express, or doesn't know HOW to express. Sometimes, kids need a little extra support, and that isn't a reflection on your parenting.

Take care...be gentle with yourself, and your boy.
post #4 of 6
I know- Its kind of a blow when all of our gentle stuff and limiting influences and our sweet little kids haul off and kick someone's butt . But, it happens. And, sometimes, there really isn't a "why" that makes sense to us. Gosh, I'll never forget when my "sweet and gentle little boy" went over and shoved a kid, took his toy and kicked him when he was down. He had NEVER been to daycare, never even with a babysitter. I was literally with this child 24 hours a day since he was born. We don't HAVE a TV. He had been in some toddler scuffles with others, but was usually not too upset, never really serious about things and "talked" about them pretty well. I was in shock. But it taught me an important lesson. If we like it or not, violence is part of the human animal. However, it is also part of the human animal to be able to learn how to control it.

At 3, he is still not fully aware of the consequences of his actions or fully developed empathy. Meaning, he was just in the moment with maybe a vague idea about "hurting her", but most likely not able to put specific actions to end results. And, to us "hands around the neck" is shocking. To him, it may have just been an easy place to hold/pull. In other words, an adult looking at the situation may not be at all what a child was "seeing" when he did it.

I think the most you can do it making a learning experience. Emphasize taking responsibility for his actions. Apologizing and trying to figure out what was the trigger and how to handle it better in the future. Then, let it go. Obsessing about it will only serve to torture you both. 3 is very young. They start looking like "kids", but they still are bordering on toddler. Learn, forgive, do better, try again.
post #5 of 6
Good post Emerging Butterfly ITA
post #6 of 6
Thread Starter 
Thank you all so VERY much for these thoughtful responses. I greatly appreciate these words. Thanks!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › I can't believe he did this