Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › 3 yr dd hits and kicks us when she is angry or frustrated....baffled.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

3 yr dd hits and kicks us when she is angry or frustrated....baffled.

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
I have an almost 4 year old (OCT bday). She is the most creative and sweet little thing a good majority of the time . However, when she is frustrated, angry or just mad because things don't go her way, she kicks or hits us. If she is laying in bed or lying down anywhere she will thrust her legs up and onto the bed or onto us. I don't understand why she is doing this. We are absolutely lost as to how to guide and discipline when it comes to this behavior. We of course have always encouraged her to use her words and express her feelings, but that only goes so far when she is angry and isn't going to get her way with something. I have tried holding her in the past or using phrases such as "Mommy loves you and wants to be close to you and play, but I cannot do that until you are able to settle down and be kind to me". Sometimes I think she has no idea how to do that. I try to help her by suggesting to take slow deep breaths or try to talk about something else to get her mind of of the anger inducing problem. Once she settles down eventually, she is able to talk things out. So many times though, she will make noises when frustrated such as "EH, EH, EH!" while kicking or hitting. I don't know why she does this and it makes me so sad that she does do it.

Example: Lunch time today was the last time: She was eating lunch and took a few bites and told me she was done and ready to eat a piece of chocolate. I explained that she needed to put some yummy healthy food in her body first before she eats any chocolate. She then insisted that she ate enough and that she was done and wanted a piece of chocolate. Of course my answer was going to be no....but I left it open ended, I told her that if she ate her lunch then she may have a piece of chocolate afterward. I told her that I was sorry that she was frustrated but Mommy knows what is good for her body and that she needed to eat lunch. This resulted in her hitting me. I explained that hitting hurts and that we may not hit each other, that she needed to use her words. She disappeared and came back with a small ball and threw it at me. I then took her to her room and closed the gate at the top of the stairs and told her, "I am not going to allow you to hit me, hitting hurts my body. When you can be calm and kind to me, then we can be together". All the while I am not far from her. She did settle. But, when I went up to talk with her she would just make frustrated noises (EH, EH, EH). If I tried to talk to her she would ignore me. I am really not sure what the best route is.

Please tell me this is normal. Has anyone else experienced this and come up with a good solution to guide this behavior in a better direction?

J.
post #2 of 6
It is normal. I think kids that age esp get frustrated when you say what you said about knowing what is good for her body and she needed to eat lunch. Trying to deal with kids when they are hungry(which I would assume she was) or tired makes everything worse too. Try turning things into games instead of power struggles and continue to gently remind that hitting hurts and show her deep breathing or a safe place to calm down. Eventually it will get better.
post #3 of 6
It is totally normal. My 4 y.o. used to do the same thing and still does at times. I really think you are handling it just fine by guiding her with words AND actions. It is important that she learn that you will not accept being hurt and hit. In our house too it sometimes takes quite awhile of dd1 being on her own before she cools down enough.
post #4 of 6
I have twins one month older than your dd and one of them is doing exactly what you describe. The other is usually a few months behind in social/emotional development type stuff, so I'm expecting it to kick in for her any day. I don't have any advice, but I've finally come to accept that all of the behaviors I find frustrating and am afraid of -- as in afraid it means I'm raising a fill-in-the-blank (in this case disrespectful I guess) child -- do go away with time, especially if I think I'm being consistent and reasonable, as it sounds you are, and this makes it easier to live with. FWIW, in the power struggle thing at this phase I try really hard to avoid any situation where it's you-can't-have-this-until-you-do-this. I try to let them know what will and won't happen in the near future as far as treats, activities, routine, and have that not be contingent on behavior. If there was chocolate with lunch they would know before we started lunch and it would have been a small enough piece that I wouldn't care if they ate it without eating much lunch. Not saying that's what you should do, just trying to give an example. I have lots of the behavior that you describe because I've said no to things but I think I feel better about it when the no is "no, that was not the plan," rather than "no because you didn't do xyz."

As far as dealing with the behavior, I'm doing the same as you. Though lots of times I don't remain as calm as I should/would like to.
post #5 of 6
I'd also classify it as normal behavior. It sounds like your DD needs more space/time to cool off afterwards, though. So I'd put the ball in her court--"When you're ready for a hug/to talk/to finish your lunch/to be nice, let me know." Then leave her alone until she tells you she's ready to interact positively with you. Talking to a brick wall just frustrates everyone involved.

I've got a 4yo DS who eats a somewhat limited diet, so I understand wanting to get healthy food into little bodies. But I really want my DS to listen to his body's signals. So just b/c I think he should be hungry, if I offer food and he doesn't want it, I trust that when he is finally hungry, he'll let me know. I'd just let my DS eat the small portion of non-healthy food, and when he was ready to eat more healthy food, give it to him. I really try to avoid power struggles over food. However, some mamas here have success with the "eat 3 more bites of x, then you can have y" technique. Remember, you've got to take the long view--over the course of a week, overall, has there been mostly healthy food consumed? If so, a little junk doesn't matter that much.
post #6 of 6
My almost 4 y.o. (Sept) does this whenever he gets frustrated. It gets old really fast.

We are dealing w/it in a similar way. He can sit away from us until he calms down and is ready to touch us nicely. I think I need more help w/this issue bc it doesn't seem like it's working that well w/him.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › 3 yr dd hits and kicks us when she is angry or frustrated....baffled.