Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Are microwaves bad?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Are microwaves bad?

post #1 of 21
Thread Starter 
I've decided to open a dedicated thread for microwaves in hope that someone could help me with links. While I'd be willing to get rid of the microwave (because my gut does tell me that it's not good to microwave food), my husband uses it all the time. I know microwave is not safe due to EFM, but I wonder if microwaving food also affects the food's nutritious qualities or automatically makes the food bad for your body. Does anyone have any reliable links about the matter?

Thanks in advance,
Yulia
post #2 of 21
I would be far more concerned about cell phones: got to youtube and search cell phones and popcorn. I've always been wary of the microwave but I have never found reliable info on the matter.
post #3 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by jeliphish View Post
I would be far more concerned about cell phones: got to youtube and search cell phones and popcorn. I've always been wary of the microwave but I have never found reliable info on the matter.
That was admitted to be a hoax. Although I don't like cell phones either.
post #4 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fujiko View Post
That was admitted to be a hoax. Although I don't like cell phones either.
Same here. I saw the video, but evidently it was a fake. But I don't like cell phones in general and don't believe for a second that they are safe. We use cell phone only in the car (we keep it in the car) for very brief emergency calls only.

I am aware about EFM coming from the microwave, even when it's off, so we started unplugging it when it's not used. But I was wondering if microwaving food has a negative affect on food qualities, making it automatically bad for you.
post #5 of 21
Well, microwaves destroy enzymes in breast milk, so I'd have to assume that they're doing something to the food.

Personally, I own one, but I use it rarely because I'm not convinced it's safe for food. In fact, I think I use it more often to heat up my "hot bag" to put on my stiff neck or back!

And of course, it should go without saying that microwaving in plastic is bad bad bad.
post #6 of 21
My dh was leary of getting rid of ours, but he couldnt give me a good reason to keep it, other than convenience. So I donated, got a toaster oven thingy and we love it! Even if nutrients arent ruined in a microwave, not having it has made me realize how much it destroyed taste!
post #7 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by poiyt View Post
Even if nutrients arent ruined in a microwave, not having it has made me realize how much it destroyed taste!
You're so right on that one, Lindsay! My MIL cooks all her veggies and some of her meats and grains in the microwave. Blech!
post #8 of 21
Someone had posted about an experiment where they took two identical plants and microwaved all the water (and let it cool) that one plant received and gave the other plant regular tap water. Supposedly the plant that was fed the microwaved water died within two weeks, even though both plants had otherwise identical conditions.

I never verified that, but it would make sense to me. True or not, I quit using the microwave except to sterilize my kitchen sponges. DH may or may not care, but he has greatly lessened the amount of microwaving he does, especially if it's something for me or the kids.

Poiyt, you are right about it ruining the taste of food. I've found really good ways of reheating foods on the stove or toaster oven that make the food taste "just made" instead of like leftovers.

I did not know about EFM's even when the microwave wasn't on, so we will be unplugging when not in use, from now on.
post #9 of 21
We sold our microwave two years ago. It took a few weeks to get used to simply not popping something in and having it ready in a few minutes, but after that no problem. We've never once regretted it. One of the things that convinced us to toss it was reading how microwaving food rearranges molecules in the food or something like that (it's been a few years since I've researched that stuff ). Plus, as someone mentioned above....microwaved food doesn't exactly taste all that great. If that's what it does to the taste than what is it doing to the food?

Here are some articles (some of them repeat a bit of each other, but all of them contain different info):

http://www.mercola.com/article/microwave/hazards2.htm

http://www.**********/general2/dangers.htm

http://www.relfe.com/microwave.html
post #10 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bri'sgirl View Post
Someone had posted about an experiment where they took two identical plants and microwaved all the water (and let it cool) that one plant received and gave the other plant regular tap water. Supposedly the plant that was fed the microwaved water died within two weeks, even though both plants had otherwise identical conditions.

I never verified that, but it would make sense to me. True or not, I quit using the microwave except to sterilize my kitchen sponges. DH may or may not care, but he has greatly lessened the amount of microwaving he does, especially if it's something for me or the kids.

Poiyt, you are right about it ruining the taste of food. I've found really good ways of reheating foods on the stove or toaster oven that make the food taste "just made" instead of like leftovers.

I did not know about EFM's even when the microwave wasn't on, so we will be unplugging when not in use, from now on.
I don’t see that experiment as a complete one. In order for it to be complete, it needs to have three plants, not two, that were given: 1. tap water; 2. boiled cooled water; 3. microwaved cooled water. I’m pretty sure that #2 and 3 will have the same poor outcome – death of the plant. So, if this experiment was trying to prove that raw water/food is more nutritious than the cooked one, then they did a good job, but honestly, this fact has been very well known for a long time. That is why raw diet is considered to be the healthiest. But assuming we cook food (and any cooking makes food less nutritious), I wonder if microwaving causes some additional damage to the food (beyond the damage done by conventional methods of cooking).

Just for the record, we do not cook anything in the microwave, but my husband does use it all the time in order to warm food up.
post #11 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Grylliade View Post
We sold our microwave two years ago. It took a few weeks to get used to simply not popping something in and having it ready in a few minutes, but after that no problem. We've never once regretted it. One of the things that convinced us to toss it was reading how microwaving food rearranges molecules in the food or something like that (it's been a few years since I've researched that stuff ). Plus, as someone mentioned above....microwaved food doesn't exactly taste all that great. If that's what it does to the taste than what is it doing to the food?

Here are some articles (some of them repeat a bit of each other, but all of them contain different info):

http://www.mercola.com/article/microwave/hazards2.htm

http://www.**********/general2/dangers.htm

http://www.relfe.com/microwave.html
Thanks for the links!
post #12 of 21
IDK, I've read a dozen or so articles ont he safety (or lack there-of) of microwaving food, and I'm not sold that its totally awful, nor that its super great. So, I try to avoid using it as much as possible, but we do still have one (though its hidden away in our basement, and thus a slight PITA to use and thus gets used minimally), and use it occasionally. Mostly to heat up leftovers for lunches a couple times a week. I'd love to get a nice toaster oven and just get rid of it totally, but I honestly don't know where I'd put a toaster oven, and we don't have the money. So... yeah
post #13 of 21
Yulia, I'm not really sure of the details of the experiment. I just remember someone posting about it a while back. You are right, there does need to be more evidence along with more controls for it to be a complete experiment. I personally do not feel microwaves are that safe, but that is more of a gut feeling.

Safe or not, food does not taste that great after being microwaved. Sometimes, it's down-right nasty!
post #14 of 21
I'm not about to throw mine out. I actually posted about this here not too long ago. I never use it to cook anything, but I do use it to thaw meat out if I just got home at 5 pm and have no idea what to cook, and to make tea (I am the only tea drinker in the house). The kids use it for things like melting cheese on nachos and stuff too.
post #15 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bri'sgirl View Post
Someone had posted about an experiment where they took two identical plants and microwaved all the water (and let it cool) that one plant received and gave the other plant regular tap water. Supposedly the plant that was fed the microwaved water died within two weeks, even though both plants had otherwise identical conditions.
I remember reading (maybe on MDC in the homeschooling forum?) about a family who tried to duplicate that experiment. They needed to use a neighbor's microwave since they didn't own one. Anyway, they watered the plants with the microwaved (then cooled) water and found no difference between those plants and the ones watered with tap water. They theorized that maybe the experiment didn't work because they microwaved the water in their own glass containers (as they also didn't own any plastic). The original experiment never mentioned what kind of container they used for the water.
post #16 of 21
I stopped using the microwave about 5 years ago. I think that it harms and damages food, so I think that it damages my health too when I eat microwaved food. Instead, I use either my small convection oven, toaster oven, or stove top to warm up food.
post #17 of 21
I think the experiment was boiled cooled and microwaved cooled, but I have never duplicated it myself. After the human blood fiasco and the breastmilk denaturing, I had to believe they couldn't be good. And what they do to food is weird, anyway!
post #18 of 21
i just don't like them. i think they can (not necessarily do) promote laziness...lazy cooking...microwave dinners...instant food, etc. and that for me, is something i avoid. i think that preparation is a large part of the eating experience and is something that i prioritize and make time for.

and they are ugly and i hate "appliances" sitting around wasting kitchen space.

and they are unnecessary.

and other reasons which pp have mentioned...
post #19 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ruthla View Post
I remember reading (maybe on MDC in the homeschooling forum?) about a family who tried to duplicate that experiment. They needed to use a neighbor's microwave since they didn't own one. Anyway, they watered the plants with the microwaved (then cooled) water and found no difference between those plants and the ones watered with tap water. They theorized that maybe the experiment didn't work because they microwaved the water in their own glass containers (as they also didn't own any plastic). The original experiment never mentioned what kind of container they used for the water.

How interesting!
post #20 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by katiesk View Post
i hate "appliances" sitting around wasting kitchen space...
I SO wish I could use this argument with dh in order to get rid of our microwave it would have been a perfect one because our kitchen is tiny, but unfortunately we both are tall (I’m 5-11 and dh is 6 feet), so our microwave is on the top of the fridge and therefore, doesn’t waste any space.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Nutrition and Good Eating
Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Are microwaves bad?