Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Diapering › yet another stinky dipe thread - prefolds
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

yet another stinky dipe thread - prefolds

post #1 of 16
Thread Starter 
16 mo ds' dipes reek of ammonia. the last time i changed his overnight prefold, i almost threw up, and i am not grossed out easily.

i am at my wits end and about to throw these diapers in the garbage! ds' had such a bad rash that i had to use disposables (7th gen). after a week it is almost all healed.

here is what i'm dealing with:

2 dozen prefolds (all cotton, no polyester insert)
1 dozen organic cotton fitteds
nylon covers (they don't stink)

front loader

well water

no detergent (when i use even a small amount of natural stuff the smell is waaaaaaaaaay worse)

wash every.single.day

small load (6-8 dipes)

1 1/2 hour cold wash no detergent extra rinse THEN
2 1/2 hour "sanitary" cycle no detergent extra rinse THEN
1 1/2 hour cold wash no detergent extra rinse

i usually don't use a cover so i can feel when he pees and change it right away

dry pail/wet pail, poop goes straight into the toilet

have boiled them several times for 1/2 hour at a time, 2 dipes at a time, helped a little

i've tried soaking them in vinegar and oxiclean (seperately and together), it helped a little

i've even tried a hydrogen peroxide soak, helped a little

i also dry in the sun every other wash

i won't use calgon or anything that has chemicals/fragrance in it

is there anything i haven't tried??? tia!
post #2 of 16
Um, detergent? Or something at least? Maybe baking soda? What detergent were you using that made a smell? You are against Calgon, but if you have hard well water, it will really help. Also if you have hard well water, you often need MORE detergent, not less, as the detergent goes to work attacking the minerals in the water and is not available to clean the diapers.
post #3 of 16
Thread Starter 
i've used lots of detergent and little detergent, and they both make the dipes stink more.

i use:

country save
trader joes
bac out
7th gen powder
post #4 of 16
Thread Starter 
i don't think we have hard water, as there are never any deposits on our bathtub/sinks/toilets. would there be any other way to tell, aside from buying a test kit? we live in the sierra nevada mountains, i don't know if that info helps.
post #5 of 16
I agree that you need to use some sort of detergent. You need something to lift the "stuff" off of the diapers. Here's a list of appropriate detergents, and almost at the very bottom, a recipe to make your own, if you like that idea.

There are numerous people on this thread who've tried all the natural detergent with no luck, and end up switching to regular ole Tide with great success. Most diaper companies don't recommend it, but there are plenty of people who have good sucess with it.

hope you find something that works!
post #6 of 16
Thread Starter 
thank you for the link!

i have used detergent and normally do, but my understanding was that it's detergent that causes the ammonia build-up, and stripping dipes is designed to get out that excess detergent.

i had read that many moms don't use detergent on dipes, and with great success where there was none before.

i guess i'm confused. i'll try some detergent again. how much should i use for a fl?
post #7 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by ScarletBegonias View Post
thank you for the link!

i have used detergent and normally do, but my understanding was that it's detergent that causes the ammonia build-up, and stripping dipes is designed to get out that excess detergent.

i had read that many moms don't use detergent on dipes, and with great success where there was none before.

i guess i'm confused. i'll try some detergent again. how much should i use for a fl?
If you are having ammonia problems, I recommend 1/2 cup white vinegar in every cold prewash.
post #8 of 16
Thread Starter 

even more confused!

argh!

so, i've not been using detergent because from ALL the threads i've read, build-up, stink, rashes etc.,. can pretty much almost 100% be attributed to detergent. using too much, not rinsing enough etc.,.

stripping dipes makes them squeaky clean. stripping dipes involves using NO detergent. right?

with my wash routine, i am basically stripping my diapers EVERY DAY. so WHY do they stink? i even rinse them before i throw them in the washer.

i wash my diapers for 5 1/2 hours every day, with boiling water and cold rinses.

i just don't understand!

i can't use chemicals at home, so calgon or tide isn't an option for us. i read that baking soda can be used instead of clagon. where in the wash cycle should i use it?
post #9 of 16
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Galatea View Post
If you are having ammonia problems, I recommend 1/2 cup white vinegar in every cold prewash.
thank you!

so i should only use it in the first cold wash cycle? not in the boiling wash or second cold wash?
post #10 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by ScarletBegonias View Post
thank you!

so i should only use it in the first cold wash cycle? not in the boiling wash or second cold wash?
Yes. I use it in the first cold prewash, then 1 tablespoon Mtn Green or Vaska plus one scoop generic oxiclean free in my hot wash, then a cold rinse, then a hot wash and cold rinse with nothing in them.
post #11 of 16
Scarlet,

I get why you are confused because so many problems can be caused by the detergent. In my opinion, stink problems can be caused by 3 things - too much detergent, not rinsing well enough, or not enough detergent. There may be other issues, but I think those are usually the big 3.

Think of trying to wash a greasy, like spagetti pan without dishsoap. It's the soap that attach to the dirt molecules and lift them away. So you'd get your pan clean eventually, but it would take a while. So now you've got diapers with lots of dirt, buried between 6 or 8 layers of fabric...in my opinion, you really need that agent to help lift away the grime.

5 1/2 hours of washing without getting clean would definately be frustrating! I would pick a detergent off that list, or try making your own. Try the vinegar. You'll have to play with it a bit to get it to work for you, as everyone's machine and water are different. But I really do think you'll find a solution that will work!

Let us know how it goes.
post #12 of 16
When you say that these various treatments "helped a little" -- does that mean they were clean and stink-free but only one time, and then the stink returned? Or do you mean that the stink was slightly less overpowering but still there?

The one factor that you have that I don't have experience with is the well water, so I don't know how that plays into everything. But my suggestion based on everything else you wrote is:

1) have you tried using more water? I don't know what cycle you're on... but FLs use so little water (at least mine does). I wash everything on delicate (but still hot wash) because that uses the highest water level.
2) have you tried wet-pailing? that helped me a lot because it takes out a lot of the pee and enables the wash part of the cycle to actually do some cleaning. otherwise it's rolling around in dirty water.
3) dittos to everyone else's comments re: detergent. I think Tide might solve a lot of your problems, but I know you said you can't use it so I'm no help there.
4) what FL washer do you have? I had to use a maytag neptune while on vacation and I think if I had to use that regularly, no amount of anything I did would have gotten my dipes clean. So I'm just raising the possibility that it's not your routine, it's your washer.

Well those are all the ideas I had. Hope you find something that works!
post #13 of 16
when i switched from a top-loading washing machine to a front-loading one, i had a couple of months worth of problems with ammonia until i made two crucial changes to my wash routine. i, too, use prefolds almost exclusively.

first, i "forced" my front loader to use more water per cycle in washing my diapers. in my machine, this means running a "soak" cycle between my "pre-rinse" cycle and my actual wash cycle that uses detergent. the soak cycle makes the diapers wringing wet without spinning the water out, and running the wash cycle directly after that keeps the extra water in the wash basin.

second, i ran an additional separate rinse cycle in addition to the extra rinses that i could tack on the my wash cycle. so, all together, my diapers are in the washing machine for 4 hours and 50 minutes, but they're problem-free when they come out. detergent is very, very important in getting diapers clean, but getting it all out of the diapers again is just as important. i use planet when i can afford it, but usually stick with all small&mighty.

christina
post #14 of 16
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Galatea View Post
Yes. I use it in the first cold prewash, then 1 tablespoon Mtn Green or Vaska plus one scoop generic oxiclean free in my hot wash, then a cold rinse, then a hot wash and cold rinse with nothing in them.
thank you! i looked at vaska and i like it

Quote:
Originally Posted by Michigan Mama View Post
Scarlet,

I get why you are confused because so many problems can be caused by the detergent. In my opinion, stink problems can be caused by 3 things - too much detergent, not rinsing well enough, or not enough detergent. There may be other issues, but I think those are usually the big 3.

Think of trying to wash a greasy, like spagetti pan without dishsoap. It's the soap that attach to the dirt molecules and lift them away. So you'd get your pan clean eventually, but it would take a while. So now you've got diapers with lots of dirt, buried between 6 or 8 layers of fabric...in my opinion, you really need that agent to help lift away the grime.

5 1/2 hours of washing without getting clean would definately be frustrating! I would pick a detergent off that list, or try making your own. Try the vinegar. You'll have to play with it a bit to get it to work for you, as everyone's machine and water are different. But I really do think you'll find a solution that will work!

Let us know how it goes.
thanks for the support!

Quote:
Originally Posted by poppan View Post
When you say that these various treatments "helped a little" -- does that mean they were clean and stink-free but only one time, and then the stink returned? Or do you mean that the stink was slightly less overpowering but still there?

The one factor that you have that I don't have experience with is the well water, so I don't know how that plays into everything. But my suggestion based on everything else you wrote is:

1) have you tried using more water? I don't know what cycle you're on... but FLs use so little water (at least mine does). I wash everything on delicate (but still hot wash) because that uses the highest water level.
2) have you tried wet-pailing? that helped me a lot because it takes out a lot of the pee and enables the wash part of the cycle to actually do some cleaning. otherwise it's rolling around in dirty water.
3) dittos to everyone else's comments re: detergent. I think Tide might solve a lot of your problems, but I know you said you can't use it so I'm no help there.
4) what FL washer do you have? I had to use a maytag neptune while on vacation and I think if I had to use that regularly, no amount of anything I did would have gotten my dipes clean. So I'm just raising the possibility that it's not your routine, it's your washer.

Well those are all the ideas I had. Hope you find something that works!
well, some of the treatments worked and then were back after a couple washes. some just cut the smell a little.

1: i didn't know about the delicate cycle using more water. i'll read my manual and see if i can find any help there.

2: i've done wet-pailing and it makes the stink worse. i actually rinse my diapers really, really well before throwing them in the washer. the morning diaper gets rinsed for about 20 minutes while we take our morning bath.

3: it sounds like i need to try more detergent again ?

4: you may have something there. i have an LG tromm. it is 3 years old. unfortunately, i will not be getting a new washer until this one bites the dust. i spent $3000 on my w/d, and dh would laugh if suggested a new one.

but, it may very well be my washer. i've been checking threads on this board for 3 years and tried every wash routine i've seen and some of my own. i have been battling ammonia since dd, but i was always able to combat it quickly and easily. this time has me stumped!

Quote:
Originally Posted by lafemmedesfemmes View Post
when i switched from a top-loading washing machine to a front-loading one, i had a couple of months worth of problems with ammonia until i made two crucial changes to my wash routine. i, too, use prefolds almost exclusively.

first, i "forced" my front loader to use more water per cycle in washing my diapers. in my machine, this means running a "soak" cycle between my "pre-rinse" cycle and my actual wash cycle that uses detergent. the soak cycle makes the diapers wringing wet without spinning the water out, and running the wash cycle directly after that keeps the extra water in the wash basin.

second, i ran an additional separate rinse cycle in addition to the extra rinses that i could tack on the my wash cycle. so, all together, my diapers are in the washing machine for 4 hours and 50 minutes, but they're problem-free when they come out. detergent is very, very important in getting diapers clean, but getting it all out of the diapers again is just as important. i use planet when i can afford it, but usually stick with all small&mighty.

christina
interesting. i don't have a soak cycle on my washer. i do have extra rinse though. and i use it every time.

here's what my washer does:

1. cold, long cycle with prewash and extra rinse on cotton/towels cycle.

2. boiling water "sanitary" wash with prewash, extra rinse and stain cycle.

3. same as 1 again.

that is what i've figured so far gives the most wash/rinses/longest cycle times. i'm going to look at my manual again and see if i'm missing anythiung that would help.

oh, also i add a bucket of h2o to the first wash.

i'm going to try the vinegar rinses and add detergent to the 2nd cycle and see if that helps.
post #15 of 16
Try adding several drops of TTO or GSE to a load as a disinfectant to see if it helps.
post #16 of 16
Thread Starter 

Update

i read my washer manual and there is no soak cycle, nor any info related to how much water each cycle uses. argh!

so i started my diapers soaking in a the following combination:

1/2 gallon white vinegar
1 liter hydrogen peroxide
1 cup borax
3 cups baking soda
boiling water in the bath to cover

i stirred by hand and soaked for a few hours. when i drained the bathtub, the water color was brown!

i rinsed them , then filled up the bath again with almost boiling water. i let them soak overnight. when i got up this morning the water was slightly discolored. i'm soaking them in more hot as i type.

my next move is to wash them on cold with a vinegar rinse. then on sanitary with detergent, then another cold wash. i'll dry one diaper to test on ds tonight, and leave the others soaking in cold water.

if it's a success, i'll wash them one more time on cold then dry. if not, well, i'll go from there.

thank you for all your help and feedback mamas!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Diapering
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Diapering › yet another stinky dipe thread - prefolds