Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › Single dose vs. multi dose vaccines
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Single dose vs. multi dose vaccines

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
I'm confused about the difference between single and multi dose vaccines. I hear people say that the single dose ones are safer, but I can't seem to find any information that explains why. Our pediatrician only gives single dose vaccines and he says there is no aluminum in them, which I doubt. Can anyone enlighten me?

Thanks,
Sarah
post #2 of 8
from what i've read/been told, there are more perservitives in multi-dose vax. but i don't have any direct link right now, my computer crashed and i lost it all
post #3 of 8
Multi dose vaccines contain more junk than just one vaccine. Take for example, common things in vaccines:

*aluminum hydroxide

* aluminum phosphate

* ammonium sulfate

* amphotericin B

* animal tissues: pig blood, horse blood, rabbit brain,

* dog kidney, monkey kidney,

* chick embryo, chicken egg, duck egg

* calf (bovine) serum

* betapropiolactone

* fetal bovine serum

* formaldehyde

* formalin

* gelatin

* glycerol

* human diploid cells (originating from human aborted fetal tissue)

* hydrolized gelatin

* mercury thimerosol (thimerosal, Merthiolate(r))

* monosodium glutamate (MSG)

* neomycin

* neomycin sulfate

* phenol red indicator

* phenoxyethanol (antifreeze)

* potassium diphosphate

* potassium monophosphate

* polymyxin B

* polysorbate 20

* polysorbate 80

* porcine (pig) pancreatic hydrolysate of casein

* residual MRC5 proteins

* sorbitol

* tri(n)butylphosphate,

* VERO cells, a continuous line of monkey kidney cells, and

* washed sheep red blood

and multiply that.

And ask your doctor to see the product inserts, your doc is most likely wrong.
post #4 of 8
My biggest issue with the multi-dose ones are that if there is a reaction you will have no idea what it was to. I also think it masks to parents how much is actually being injected into their children. "Three needles" doesn't sound as bad as "seven vaccines" all at once.

Where I live DTaP-IPV-Hib is standard, and given along with Pneumoccocal and Meningalcoccal. Even if I were to vax, there is no way I would give all of that at one time, to a two-month-old infant, no less.


ETA: I have never actually done the math to see if the adjuvants/aluminum/preservatives/various other crap in multi-doses are actually greater than the sum of its parts. My research led me down the road to no-vax instead of selective vaxing, so it was never a decision I had to make. Something to carefully look into and consider though if you decide to vaccinate.
post #5 of 8
Quote:
Originally Posted by just_lily View Post
My biggest issue with the multi-dose ones are that if there is a reaction you will have no idea what it was to. I also think it masks to parents how much is actually being injected into their children. "Three needles" doesn't sound as bad as "seven vaccines" all at once.

Where I live DTaP-IPV-Hib is standard, and given along with Pneumoccocal and Meningalcoccal. Even if I were to vax, there is no way I would give all of that at one time, to a two-month-old infant, no less.


ETA: I have never actually done the math to see if the adjuvants/aluminum/preservatives/various other crap in multi-doses are actually greater than the sum of its parts. My research led me down the road to no-vax instead of selective vaxing, so it was never a decision I had to make. Something to carefully look into and consider though if you decide to vaccinate.
You are misunderstanding the original question.. I believe she is asking about single-dose VIALS compared to multi-dose VIALS ... a single vial (it is in a tiny glass container with a rubber top or something so the needle can poke through) contains a vaccine intended to be used in one injection into one person. It could contain one vaccine, like polio for example, or it could contain 3 vaccines like the DTaP for example (which contains diptheria, tetanus, and polio vaccines).

The multi-dose vials contain enough vaccines for 10 people each. So when they are done injecting you, they save the vial for the next person, inject a new needle into it etc... these vials should ALWAYS be shaken well before each use, to disperse contents equally.

YES there ARE more preservatives in the multi dose vials than in a single dose vial. There has to be because once a needle is poked into it, it is no longer a sterile environment, and the preservatives are needed to keep bacteria from growing in it for the next people. It does not mean the single dose vial is completely safe or does not have aluminum, but it is safe to say that they are the SAFER alternative of the two and in general have LESS preservatives than the multi dose vials.

The worry with a multi dose vial is if it is not shaken each time, the contents could settle. It is possible one person out of the 10 (or a few people) could get a much bigger percentage of preservatives (or other ingredients in the vaccine) than the other people. (the other people would end up getting less of course) - even if it was shaken perfectly all 10 times, one would end up getting more preservatives than if one had used vaccine from single dose vial.

As far as whether or not there is aluminum in the particular vaccine you will be using, you would need to ask for the manufacturers insert (ALWAYS ask for this in advance of your appt and read it well so you know about what will be injected into your child on your next appt) which states the brand name (Daptacel for example) and in addition to reading the insert you can research elsewhere to compare your brand to others to find the best choice (if you are firmly commited to vaxing) there are some brands that are higher than others in terms of aluminum.
post #6 of 8
Quote:
Originally Posted by Peachthief View Post
I'm confused about the difference between single and multi dose vaccines. I hear people say that the single dose ones are safer, but I can't seem to find any information that explains why. Our pediatrician only gives single dose vaccines and he says there is no aluminum in them, which I doubt. Can anyone enlighten me?

Thanks,
Sarah

Yes there is aluminum used in vaccines!! They are either lying or perhaps he MEANT to say "mercury" ... mercury supposedly is used only in TRACE quantities in vaccines today (but there is no law regulating or mandating this, it is completely voluntary from the companies) and the drs basically overlook the trace amounts (since they are much less than what they used to be) and say there is NONE.

There most definitely is aluminum although not in every single vaccine. Some particular vaccines do not use aluminum.

For example... and I'm a little rusty on this so someone correct me if I'm wrong but I believe HIB is not supposed to have any aluminum in it (no matter the brand) while DTaP for example always has aluminum, but the level could be "low" or "high" depending on which brand is used at your particular dr office)

There are certainly other questionable contents but I focus only on aluminum here because it was mentioned in the original question.
post #7 of 8
Thread Starter 
Yes, it's the single dose VIALS that I was referring to, thanks. I suspect he meant, or thought I was referring to, mercury, since that seems to be what most people are concerned about. I know that the aluminum is a necessary part of how the vaccine works, so I didn't see how there could be any difference.
post #8 of 8
Oops, sorry. My bad. Not much sleep happening around here lately.

The multi-dose vials definitely have a lot more crap in them. Go with single-dose for sure if you are going to vax.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Vaccinations
Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › Single dose vs. multi dose vaccines