Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › Where the Wild Things Are - Movie!!!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Where the Wild Things Are - Movie!!!

post #1 of 19
Thread Starter 
(I posted this in an existing thread, but then realized that thread was in the "television" forum, so am re-posting in the more general media area)

Just saw this trailer when I went to see the new Harry Potter last night (first time we've gone out to a movie since DS was born a little over a year ago).

I am SO psyched! I think Spike Jonze and Dave Eggers are brilliant. The official website has a featurette with Maurice Sendak saying how there's been interest in making it into a movie for years, but he (Maurice) was not interested in any of the people who wanted to make the movie...until Spike Jonze came along. The trailer made me teary. I've since watched it a few more times on the web and I cry each time. (Probably the Arcade Fire song playing in the background of the trailer doesn't help...).

I've also seen articles discussing how scary or unscary this movie should be. There are claims that tests of an earlier version were too scary for young viewers at the test. But these claims have also been disputed. All I know is that I think it's a fun but dark book. I taught kg for 6 years and it was always a well-loved book, but even the book scared a couple extra-sensitive kids that I've had. I think the movie should be appropriately dark in order to capture the true feel of the book.
post #2 of 19
Moviemakers have to get their mitts on - and ruin - everything, don't they?

Sorry, I can't share the enthusiasm for seeing Hollywood put its stamp on this classic.
post #3 of 19
Thread Starter 
Hmmm...I do think that it's true that "Hollywood" has ruined many a fine book. But there are some folks out there making movies that feel less "Hollywood" and more "artist." Neither Spike Jonze nor David Eggers are mainstream Hollywood....I doubt this will be like The Polar Express (even though Tom Hanks is a producer) or Harry Potter or The Golden Compass.

But, I guess we'll have to wait and see...
post #4 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by zinemama View Post
Moviemakers have to get their mitts on - and ruin - everything, don't they?

Sorry, I can't share the enthusiasm for seeing Hollywood put its stamp on this classic.
This was my first thought too. I don't see how a movie will duplicate or improve on the magic in the book. I can see how a movie, even one with good intentions, can easily wreck the story.
post #5 of 19
My biggest reservation about the film based upon the trailers is that Max seems too old. In the book, he seems 4-6. I'd guess 10 based upon what I've seen for the movie.
post #6 of 19
I usually hate when my favorite books are made into movies (and this really is a favorite- my copy is signed by Maurice Sendek) and I was apprehensive when I heard about this but from the trailers, I feel like they "got it"

I actually think that maybe the movie will bring the true message of the book to more people. I think a lot of people miss it when they read it.
post #7 of 19
.....
post #8 of 19
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by tinyactsofcharity View Post
I actually think that maybe the movie will bring the true message of the book to more people. I think a lot of people miss it when they read it.

I was thinking along those lines, too.

Also, most books that are made into movies are chapter books. And then they get messed up by leaving things out that seem important or changing details. By making a picture book with very little text into a (feature-length) movie, the screenwriters and director have to put in things that are not in the book. It does seem from the trailer and from seeing the interview with Sendak, Jonze and Eggers, that the things added to this movie are the...explanations (for lack of a better word).

And, it looks like it promotes co-sleeping, too (Max saying to the wild things that when it's time for bed they'll all sleep in one big pile)
post #9 of 19
Thread Starter 

Spike Jonze WTWA blog

If anyone's interested, I came upon Spike Jonze's Where the Wild Things Are blog. Some stuff seems to be random and kinda unrelated, but there's also photos from shooting, excerpts from literary critiques of WTWA, snippets of Sendak interviews, photos of WTWA murals from all over...just a bunch of interesting stuff. Haven't gone through it all yet...

http://weloveyouso.com/category/wher...gsare/page/11/
post #10 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by not_telling View Post
By making a picture book with very little text into a (feature-length) movie, the screenwriters and director have to put in things that are not in the book. It does seem from the trailer and from seeing the interview with Sendak, Jonze and Eggers, that the things added to this movie are the...explanations (for lack of a better word).
This is exactly my problem with making it into a movie. They will load up the story with made-up stuff, thereby entirely changing it.

Could you clarify what you mean by "explanations"? I'm not sure what you mean. Like any book, WTWTA can be interpreted in different ways, by different people. Is any "official" explanation necessary? Or desired?
post #11 of 19
Thread Starter 
It does seem from the trailer and from seeing the interview with Sendak, Jonze and Eggers, that the things added to this movie are the...explanations (for lack of a better word).

Quote:
Originally Posted by zinemama View Post
This is exactly my problem with making it into a movie. They will load up the story with made-up stuff, thereby entirely changing it.

Could you clarify what you mean by "explanations"? I'm not sure what you mean. Like any book, WTWTA can be interpreted in different ways, by different people. Is any "official" explanation necessary? Or desired?
Yeah, I knew "explanation" wasn't quite the word I meant...

It's true that anything can be interpreted in different ways by different people. What I was trying to get at was that the screenwriter and director for WTWTA - from what I've gleaned from various sources - are taking the story we all know, and are using their personal responses to the story to zoom the lens in and zoom the lens out. What does the bigger picture look like of a young boy who is "acting out," who feels angry toward people he loves and who love him? What kinds of things (I'm assuming normal everyday things) cause a child, or any of us, to have dark feelings? And, then, zooming in, what does it feel like to be the child (or adult...I know I still have moments of wanting to act completely wild, waving my claws and gnashing my teeth) who just wants to act wild? What is it like to feel those more hurt or hurtful feelings towards people you love? How does seeking solace in fantasy help? What does that inner fantasy world look like?

I know I've seen and been annoyed by movies that add all this silly made-up stuff to a story that was perfectly fine, or just downright better, without it. And, since I haven't seen this film yet, I can't say for sure that my hopes will be fulfilled. (I tried not to get my hopes too far up for The Golden Compass, but I was totally crushed anyway)

But, you never know. I love the movie "Clueless"...talk about interpretation!
I don't think a movie version need be an "official" explanation, though I know some people might take it as such.
post #12 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by not_telling View Post
I know I've seen and been annoyed by movies that add all this silly made-up stuff to a story that was perfectly fine, or just downright better, without it. And, since I haven't seen this film yet, I can't say for sure that my hopes will be fulfilled. (I tried not to get my hopes too far up for The Golden Compass, but I was totally crushed anyway)

But, you never know. I love the movie "Clueless"...talk about interpretation!
I don't think a movie version need be an "official" explanation, though I know some people might take it as such.
ITA (especially about the Golden Compass! : And Clueless! ) But that didn't stop me from cheering with the rest of the audience at Harry Potter when this trailer came on - I can't WAIT to see it! I'm always hopeful that the film translations will be true to the spirit of the books; they can never be 100% true to the book, the media are just too different in my opinion.
post #13 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by zinemama View Post
This is exactly my problem with making it into a movie. They will load up the story with made-up stuff, thereby entirely changing it.

Could you clarify what you mean by "explanations"? I'm not sure what you mean. Like any book, WTWTA can be interpreted in different ways, by different people. Is any "official" explanation necessary? Or desired?
Well, Maurice Sendak has explained the book, as he wrote it, in many speeches and contexts. He's working on the movie as well. I guess if the author himself wasn't working on the movie, I might have more of a problem using the word "explanation" but since he is, I don't see the issue.
post #14 of 19
Even if the "explanation" is officially sanctioned by the author, I still kind of have a problem with it. I'm a children's librarian. I've spent a lot of time with this book.

I think that one of the beautiful things about the story is that Max is just "wild". He just IS, and there's no reason for it. Is it a bad mood? A personality flaw? We have no idea -- we see the barest of snapshots of his life.

It's that LACK of explanation that makes all of us relate to the story (well, those of us who do). Even those of us who were "good girls" could potentially have an evening where we'd like to put on our wolf suits and make mischief of one sort or another.

It looks like the movie had to thresh out Max's backstory, and while it probably doesn't ruin the story as a story, it does tend to diminish the universality of it. So Max is troubled because his mom has a boyfriend? He gets bullied at school? Relatable, but not quite as universal.
post #15 of 19
I can't wait to see it. It looks like it is going to be an amazing movie
post #16 of 19
I was a little unsure about them making this book into a feature film, but after seeing the featurette, the trailer, and reading all about it (it got great reception at Comic-Con)...I'm more excited now! The trailer especially amazing - it's one of my most anticipated fall movies.
post #17 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by bayberry*moon View Post
(it got great reception at Comic-Con)
If Comic-Con liked it, that says a lot! I think I'm excited, though it seems a bit scary!
post #18 of 19
I just saw the preview when we went to see Ponyo. Ick. The Wild Thing costumes were good, but everything else...they took a simple, mysteriously story and put all this music and emotion and cliched "message" into it. Not for me.
post #19 of 19
Wish he still had the larger photo up, this one is hard to see, but just had to share the take on it some of my classmates had.
http://academic.evergreen.edu/m/murl...k%20goood2.htm
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Books, Music and Other Media
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › Where the Wild Things Are - Movie!!!