Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Pets › Pet Ethics Question
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Pet Ethics Question

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
Our cat is 16 years old, possibly ill, and I could use some help deciding what the best course of action would be.

A little history: She was my ex's cat. We each brought a cat to the relationship, and by the time we divorced (9 years ago) we didn't feel OK about separating them. I took both cats since he traveled and worked extensively. My cat passed away almost 4 years ago, so we (I'm now remarried with a 4 year old son) have only had the one cat since then, and we don't plan on having any more after this one.

I have known this cat since my ex got her when she was just a kitten, and she has ALWAYS been a handful. Peeing/pooping outside the litter box has been a major issue throughout her life. We have had her checked for health problems more times than I can count, (the vet always says, "I wish I was so healthy!) and have always bent over backwards to accommodate her preferences/behaviors/whathaveyou. Just a couple of examples: when we bought our house, we specifically looked for one with no carpet anywhere (which was not easy to find in our price range), because she would have peed on it and ruined it. I cannot even begin to tell you how much money I have spent on cleaning, lost apartment security deposits, vet bills, and discarded rugs & things. We have tried every possible litterbox configuration and finally settled on old towels folded up in the box instead of litter, because it is the only way she will go in the box (sometimes.) So I am basically cloth-diapering my cat - triple-washing a load of revoltingly stinky pee towels every week, in addition to anything else she may have seen fit to pee on that week.

Needless to say I have been at the end of my patience with this cat for...well...ever.

Yesterday I found a spot of blood on the towel in her litter box. I checked her paws and they are fine, so I'm thinking she must have a UTI or something. This morning, she squatted right in front of me and peed & pooped on the dog's bed (which she also lays on during the day.) Clearly it's not outside the realm of possibility that she would go on ANYTHING, but usually she sleeps there most of the day, and usually she's pretty stealthy about going on stuff.

Obviously, I have been committed for years to caring for this cat for better or for worse. I don't want her to suffer, but honestly, I am done. I am not interested in spending a lot of money on testing, medications, or prescription food. I am not interested in having her ruin any more of our stuff, and if she really is sick, it's only a matter of time before she starts going on furniture and beds and we just cannot afford to replace those things. I have always been horrified by the idea of euthanizing an animal for convenience, but at her age and with likely health problems, I also don't see that re-homing her is an option. I would be worried about her ending up in a shelter, and if it's her time, I would so much rather have her at home, surrounded by her family.

What would you do in this situation?
post #2 of 8
Quote:
Originally Posted by chamomeleon View Post
Obviously, I have been committed for years to caring for this cat for better or for worse. I don't want her to suffer, but honestly, I am done. I am not interested in spending a lot of money on testing, medications, or prescription food. I am not interested in having her ruin any more of our stuff, and if she really is sick, it's only a matter of time before she starts going on furniture and beds and we just cannot afford to replace those things. I have always been horrified by the idea of euthanizing an animal for convenience, but at her age and with likely health problems, I also don't see that re-homing her is an option. I would be worried about her ending up in a shelter, and if it's her time, I would so much rather have her at home, surrounded by her family.

What would you do in this situation?
OK, if the question is ethical I will say that it is MORE ethical to humanely and painlessly euthanize an animal rather than to not treat it and allow it to suffer. Since it sounds as if you have no interest in treating her, nor an interest in the expense and yes nobody is going to want a sick or geriatric cat, then it would likely be more humane to euthanize.
post #3 of 8
If you're not going to treat her, and she's suffering - euthanizing the cat is the more humane option. You're not the only person to choose to euthanize over treating health problems. For a lot of people, euthanizing is the more affordable option ... versus expensive treatments.

It's hard for me to say what I would do as my only pet right now is my dog ... and I'd sell one of my kidneys to treat him! I know that must sound crazy to some ... but, he's seriously the best dog.

So, I can't relate to your situation in that I've never had an animal who caused such problems or with whom I wasn't bonded.

Bottom line: it's not unethical to choose to euthanize over treatment.
post #4 of 8
have you asked your ex husband if he will take her back, now since you no longer have the other cat?
post #5 of 8
I just wanted to offer hugs of understanding. I have a similar situation with a cat, only she has been my cat since she was a kitten, and her problems only developed once my husband and I moved in with one another (when she was about a year old). In the beginning, she'd only pee on his laundry (which he LOVED). As you can imagine, he does not feel bonded to her at all.

She did better for awhile, but once our boys were born, she added their things to her list of favorite places to go. Then she just started going on the carpet wherever she wanted. About 3 years ago, my husband finally said that it was either him or the cat, and since that time she has lived in our unfinished basement. She goes outside daily when the weather is nice, and hangs out with the family upstairs only when we are able to supervise her. I feel horrible about the situation, but am at a loss for a better solution.

Our cat is 14 now, and I know we'll soon be having to make decisions for her like you are for yours now. I wish you all the best with your decision!
post #6 of 8
Thread Starter 
Thank you all for your replies!

I just want to make clear that we wouldn't NOT treat her and just allow her to suffer. Reading back over my first post, I can see why it sounded like I may have been saying that, but that is not the case - if we decide not to euthanize, we will certainly treat her.

I actually did contact my ex a few months after our other cat died to ask him if he would be willing to take her back. Unfortunately he was traveling in India for several months at the time - this is typical for him, so it really wasn't possible.

I called my vet's office yesterday to find out what the course of treatment would be (if it is a UTI) and what it might cost. I made an appointment to go in and talk to the vet tomorrow about our options. As of now, the cat seems fine - I haven't seen any more blood on the litterbox towels, and I haven't (YET) found anything else she's gone on. It's hard to tell by her behavior if she's feeling bad - she's old and she sleeps ALL the time anyway. She comes downstairs about twice a day for 20 minutes to eat, drink, and go to the bathroom.

I will always love (other people's) cats, but no more cats for me! Whatever the outcome of this situation, and however far in the future this may be...I am looking forward to being able to have rugs in my house.
post #7 of 8
I can relate. We are about to enter the same type of situation. We have a 15 year old cat with diabetes.

Between the vet visits, tests, meds, emergency vet stays, consultations with a Cornell specialist and special food, we are approaching four figures this year alone.

Then there is the litter box trouble. She goes outside the box 90% of the time, close to the box almost like she can't get there in time. After all the tests, the vet concluded that she is just old and sickly. (The cats have dedicated room for their boxes away from the household activity and we clean every day so it isn't an environment thing.)

I don't know how much longer this can continue. She is stable and happy right now so nothing needs to be decided now but when she takes a turn for the worse again, what do we do?

(I LOVE this cat. She and her brother were our first babies.)

My husband won't even discuss it. I have tried to gently bring up the subject of her quality of life without bringing money and effort into the conversation but in the back of my mind I wonder when is enough enough?

At what point does all the money and energy taken away from the human family outweigh the responsibility to an aging pet?

I can now see why some people don't get another pet after one dies.
post #8 of 8
Glad to hear that she's headed to the vet so that you have all the info in place to make a decision. You may want to consider asking for a written prescription that you can use in a human side pharmacy. Many of the big box stores have free antibiotics for certain drugs, which is something vet hospitals can't even begin to compete with. Just keep in mind that sometimes the right med won't be available, but most vets will try to make it work.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Pets
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Pets › Pet Ethics Question