Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › is there a wrong way to nurse?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

is there a wrong way to nurse?

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
I mean, position-wise? like, I nurse dd in bed while lying down and we do both breasts while lying on one side, does that make sense? I just shift my body weight. and then other times if we are just lying around I'll nurse her in whatever position I happen to be in. I'll be lying down with her propped up in a sitting pos. and just pull her close to my breast.

Is this ok? Is there a reason people recomend just three basic positions? Thanks!
post #2 of 12
If it works, she gets milk, doesn't hurt you and doesn't give you plugged ducts- go for it

-Angela
post #3 of 12
There's no wrong way to nurse unless you're nursing the same way all the time. You don't want the baby to always be looking at you with the same eye because that can lead to lazy eye problems -- so if you do all your nursing lying down with you on your right side, that wouldn't be good. But if you switch sides say, every other night, but all the feedings that night were from teh same side, that would be fine. No need to be technical about it either, counting feedings -- just shouldn't ALL be the same way.
post #4 of 12
If it works for you, that's fine. My son's orthoptist is absolutely insistent that we did not cause his squint and could not have done anything to prevent it, it's how his eyes developed inside me. There are plenty of women who have successfully fed using a single breast, even- either post-mastectomy, because they have a single arm or are tandem feeding twins or close-in-age siblings and have a designated breast for each baby.
If being unable to nurse in three positions meant failing at breastfeeding, then the majority of new mums are failures. It's pretty common for newborns to be better at latching on lying down, or in the cradle hold.
post #5 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by alegna View Post
If it works, she gets milk, doesn't hurt you and doesn't give you plugged ducts- go for it

-Angela
Yes yes yes.

Interesting question as to why some people recommend just three basic positions. I would guess it's because they can help in cases where mum isn't sure where to start, or if mum and babe are having problems with inefficient latch or milk transfer.

Suzanne Colson's Biological Nurturing approach moves away from the "traditional" holds, and is mother- (and baby-) centred and far less prescriptive. See here for details, and here for an overview with lovely pics ).
post #6 of 12
I think there are some basics to keep in mind. belly to belly so baby's not turning head or craning neck, baby's body pretty lined up from head to bum not smushed or arched. And good comfy posture for you, not to strain your back, neck, shoulders, etc.
side lying nursing from top or bottom breast is fine, unless it is uncomfortable to squish the bottom breast.
sadly, i think more people are familiar with baby bottle positioning. so it is different points about positions for breastfeeding.
post #7 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by alegna View Post
If it works, she gets milk, doesn't hurt you and doesn't give you plugged ducts- go for it

-Angela
:

I nursed that way all the time to keep from putting the kids between me and dh. I never tried the football hold at all it was either belly to belly sitting up or lying side by side in the bed. I wasnt much for trying new things since the ones I used worked just fine.
post #8 of 12
I don't agree with the comment about lazy eye. Yes, it certainly is optimal for eye development if you switch sides. That much is clear to me. But to say that not switching sides is going to cause an eye problem that is almost always caused by genetic factors is not helpful and just not true.

There are legions of bottlefed babies out there who were fed being held on only one arm, and they see just fine. And what about twins? My kiddos were assigned a side permanently from the time they were a few months old-- DS on the right, DD2 on the left. They have not been harmed. Yes, I'm sure switching sides is the ideal. But that's not the same as claiming that a child who doesn't switch positions is going to be harmed.
post #9 of 12
Check out the "mama sutra" for alternative nursing positions
(It's a series of cartoons from Kate Evans's book The Food of Love.)
http://www.thefoodoflove.org/mama-sutra.htm
post #10 of 12
I think the three basic positions are recommended is in the beginning when both mother and baby are learning, and getting a good latch is important, and giving options for good positioning and latch with those positions is laying a good foundation. But once you've both got the hang of it, there is a lot of variation, and I think each nursing couple figures out what works for them.

Breastfeeding my first child, I tended to get a little hung up on the fact that I wasn't doing it "right"--I was leaning over, I was hunched, my hands were falling asleep, etc. But I think examining some of the problems with the position were what made me find more things to aid me, like trying out different chairs, using a footstool, different pillows, a rolled up blanket, etc. I actually felt a little put out by it all, sometimes, thinking I must not be doing things right to have to use all these things, but once I got over that, and once I realized that breastfeeding could be easy and comfortable, it was a whole new ball game. At that point I could nurse in all sorts of positions and it was just amusing to me the contortions that arose. If things changed a little, like with teething or illness or what have you, and I started to have breast and nipple pain, coming back to the basics was the first step in fixing things.
post #11 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by femalephish View Post
I mean, position-wise? like, I nurse dd in bed while lying down and we do both breasts while lying on one side, does that make sense? I just shift my body weight. and then other times if we are just lying around I'll nurse her in whatever position I happen to be in. I'll be lying down with her propped up in a sitting pos. and just pull her close to my breast.

Is this ok? Is there a reason people recomend just three basic positions? Thanks!
i also nurse on one side while in bed, it's just plain easier! i am large breasted so can easily lean a little more and nurse away. i actually feel more comfortable that way! i think too much emphasis is put on correct positioning. of course, latching, etc. must be correct but if you are comfy, baby is latched and seems comfy then i think that's all that matters. my babe will grab his foot and swing his leg all around, he is still chowing down and i am totally comfy. i used to look up pics and watch videos and think "i don't feel like i look like that." my mom would say "he looks totally comfy, leave him alone!"
post #12 of 12
What she said. My midwife always told me, "If mom is comfy, baby is comfy"
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Breastfeeding
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › is there a wrong way to nurse?