Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › 4yo DS - Tantrums and hitting sister
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

4yo DS - Tantrums and hitting sister

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
My DS is 4. We have a 2 yo DD. DS has always been a kind, gentle child but he is also very sensitive and has quite a few tantrums throughout the day. He's been going through this since he was about 2.5. He goes into these modes where he's crying and angry, which makes him hit. I tell him hitting is not ok, and that he can't be with us when he hits. I offer comfort, but it usually results in more hitting. At that point, I tell him he should take his anger out in a quiet place, like his room, but he refuses to go. I'm not really sure what to do at that point. Short of pinning him down (which no, I'm not doing), I can't get him to stay in his room. Once it got so bad, I had to close my own door, with DD and I in there. He still cried hysterical for a while and started screaming he was scared. I opened the door, and he sobbed for a bit but did not hit anymore. I feel at a loss these days. He is usually a very sweet, considerate boy but when he gets into this mode, it's hard to be around him.
He cries a lot more when his sis is around, and I try my best to meet the needs of both children. But my DD is quite demanding as well, and has started to nurse like a newborn again (actually she didn't nurse remotely this much when she was an infant). We even have special times where my son gets one on one attention either from myself, my DH or my mother.
He loves his sister very much, and loves the idea of taking care of her... but I think it's hard for both of them because they cannot communicate yet. He wants her to play a game or something, and DD doesn't do it the "right" way so he starts to get angry and try to force her sometimes. He also cannot stand her touching anything of his. If she takes something of his, I ask him to let me help, by offering something else. I usually ask him to do it. But by the time, I turn my back to get something he's already tackled her on the floor and snatched it from her hands. She is usually in hysterics by this time. Also, when he thinks I'm not looking, he sometimes pushes her or hits her and tells me she fell, and that's why she's crying.
Any help regarding any of the above would be much appreciated...
post #2 of 4
Thread Starter 
post #3 of 4
For the toys perhaps let him choose say 3-4 things that his sister absolutely cannot touch and let him "hide" them where she cannot reach. It may make him a little more open to letting his sister handle something of his. my son frequently resorted to hitting at 4 but I can tell you it does get better. making sure he's sleeping enough and getting snacks/meals regularly can cut down on the meanness. Stick close to the kids playing to intervene before he gets to hitting. You may feel like you do nothing but play with them all day but eventually it will get better
post #4 of 4
:

My dd1 is 4 and when she goes off on her tantrums or hitting, here too it just seems to escalate if I focus on it, try to talk about it, try to get her to leave the room or try to put her in her room. So, in our house, I have noticed that the best thing to do is just walk away from her, or remove her little sister from her so she can't continue. She calms down when left alone. Of course I will say something short and sweet like, "Boy you're angry! When you're ready for a hug or to try playing again, we'll be in the kitchen." That seems to help.

I too find that I'm intervening right now as their age difference makes it hard for them to play together. Sometimes it works for them, sometimes it doesn't. If dd2 tries to take dd1's stuff (e.g., colouring book, markers, paint), and dd1 wants to focus on her project and work by herself, I try to help older dd get set up out of little dd's reach. Or I try to set them both up with the same kind of stuff side by side, or across the table from each other.

When dd1 wants to build towers with blocks and doesn't want dd1 to knock them over, I start building "decoy" towers and noisily protest in mock outrage as dd1 knocks mine over. I keep her interest in my towers so she doesn't go after dd1's towers.

I also try to explain, short and sweet to dd1, that dd2 just wants to be like her. "See? She loves being with you. She just wants to be with you. She wants to do what you're doing. You're amazing to her. She loves you." This gives dd1 pause and makes her more tolerant of the frustrations. At times.

Sometimes I leave them to work it out themselves but I try to give dd1 tools for dealing with dd2, like getting her to lure dd2 away from her toy by offering something else... or if dd2 hits, telling her, "I don't like that! I want you to stop!" That often makes dd1 pause.

Good luck. It's a stage. It will pass.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › 4yo DS - Tantrums and hitting sister