I'm still figuring myself out spiritually. It's a "trendy" thing to do in my age group according to my mother. But I'm not nearly as eloquent as others.
I als grew up Methodist. My parents were both Midwestern Methodists. I come from a very long line of very good people. But the church just didn't move me. I was a gymnast. Many of my friends through gymnastics were Catholic and I would go to church with them. Catholic church felt like....God.
My parent's church was trying really hard to be "cool" and "relevant" to younger people. Electric guitars, and gettin' real with Jesus. To me, it just seemed silly. I had no spiritual connection to my Sunday "worship"
During that time, I was about 12, we took a family trip to New Mexico and visited all the missons. I found myself surreptitiously reading catechism books. Collecting any and all Catholic info I could, and hiding it!!! I have no idea why. My mom decided to buy a Catechism book for us (my parents are very open minded people) so that my sister and I could learn about Catholicism. I was so excited! I stole it and read it every chance I got.
Years later, I'd drifted away from the Methodist church. Our family took a Christmas trip to Italy. We spent Christmas is Florence. The next day we went to Assisi.
Assisi is the birthplace of St.Francis and St. Claire. It is serenely beautiful. Overlooking the Tuscan hills. I walked into one of the small chapels there and was greeted by a white dove. The place that held St. Francis' hairshirt emitted an eerie almost beckoning sound. It was the most profoundly, viscerally, spiritual place I've ever been. It brings me to tears thinking about it.
I "came out" as a Catholic to my mom in Assisi. She bought me a rosary before we left.
After I came home, and this was when I was in college, I did the RCIA program at our University parish.
I later married into a very devout Catholic family.
I still have a lot of questions since I didn't grow up in the Church. I'm also not sure that I agree entirely with church teachings. I struggle with church dogma, but I feel safe in the Church. Spiritually, I am completely at home. I can't really explain it any further than that. It's confusing to me too

I do have some issues now because I'm divorced. That's another thread entirely.