Want to find a natural mascara I love!

[saalmc]

I've tried a few with mixed results:


Larenim- not bad, just underwhelming. A bit more of the natural look than I hoped for. Did not emphasis or enhance at all.

Zuzu- I've read good reviews here and had really high hopes. Liked the way it looked on, but it smeared like *crazy*. Have not experienced this with other products, it was a very unpleasant surprise. I looked like a raccoon by the end of the day.

Recently purchased:

trial size of Earth's Beauty- clumpy. Not so great.

Real Purity: ok, best so far. Still not what I'm hoping for. Need to apply two coats to get coverage I'm looking for. Seems a bit thin and un-dramatic. I want a mascara that makes my lashes look better than they do on their own, not just darker.

So I'm hoping for some suggestions? Any others that you have tried and would recommend? Your thoughts are greatly appreciated!!

[Vancouver Mommy]

Have you tried Dr. Hauschka? I like it, but it isn't a really "dramatic" mascara.

[ssantos]

I am loving Jane Iredale PureLash Lengthening Mascara. I have used Clinique Natually Glossy Mascara for two decades, but I am trying to use products with fewer harsh chemicals - I check www.cosmeticsdatabase.org for almost everything.

I also love zuzu eyeshadows and lipsticks.