Of course I thought about this post last night and most of today, and thinking about what else I wanted to bring to it. I really appreciate this thread in general....
Anyway, while I'm thinking about it, what keeps popping into my mind is the secretary for my department. She and I had babies at the same time. I was on baby #2, she was on baby #1. I don't remember ever being rude or offensive, but I was still very rigid in my beliefs about birth...having had a csection with baby #1, I was of course determined not to have that happen the second time around. She couldn't have cared less outwardly how it all went. She seemed to give it all minimal thought actually. I found that disturbing and irresponsible. And I'm sure I made several, well meaning and pointed remarks with the intent of "educating" her. I had another cbirth and she had a completely unmedicated vaginal birth. So much for me and my angst.
: (you're not alone here Kim, I just don't always mention how my kids were born, it seems to decrease my credibility...and others--honestly ask yourself, did your opinion of my previous opinion drop just a little now that you know? I bet for some of you it did. That's okay, I'm just pointing out that we're all biased)
Since then I've relaxed a lot of my rigidity. I pumped for and breastfed my kids--I personally take credit for the pumping room installed in my district office following my unrelenting pursuit of a suitable place to pump that did not include a toilet--the secretary pumped for awhile then quit. I never said a word. I learned that we all have different lives and experiences and my reality is not hers. Recently she and I have begun processing our early relationship (i.e., when we were pregnant) and several times she began the conversation by saying something about how our pregnancy hormones didn't work together well. Finally she spit out what she really thinks. She said, "You made me feel like I was doing everything wrong." That sounds about right. I never once said that. I never once told her she made a poor choice or whatever. But I thought it. A lot. I completely disapproved of so many things, and in my effort to "educate" her, I just made her averse to me. I thought I was being enlightening. I was just obnoxious. I find she listens to my opinions far more now that I treat her as if her opinions and life experiences matter too. Because they do. Now we share our individual thoughts, it's not just me teaching her about her rights and abilities...
Honestly, I don't see birth anymore as much different than any other right to choose any other thing. If the consequences of an action are known, the risks involved weighed, why can't a woman elect to cbirth, or birth vaginally or any other of the choices? If we're talking about empowerment, and making people aware, then we have to respect that sometimes their decisions will not be ours. And by the same token, not everybody processes their grief, their trauma, their pain at the same rate in the same way. To me, that's AP--recognizing the individuality of lives, and that's what's truly not mainstream--being open to the ideas and actions of those that don't agree with our own.
Leah
Anyway, while I'm thinking about it, what keeps popping into my mind is the secretary for my department. She and I had babies at the same time. I was on baby #2, she was on baby #1. I don't remember ever being rude or offensive, but I was still very rigid in my beliefs about birth...having had a csection with baby #1, I was of course determined not to have that happen the second time around. She couldn't have cared less outwardly how it all went. She seemed to give it all minimal thought actually. I found that disturbing and irresponsible. And I'm sure I made several, well meaning and pointed remarks with the intent of "educating" her. I had another cbirth and she had a completely unmedicated vaginal birth. So much for me and my angst.
: (you're not alone here Kim, I just don't always mention how my kids were born, it seems to decrease my credibility...and others--honestly ask yourself, did your opinion of my previous opinion drop just a little now that you know? I bet for some of you it did. That's okay, I'm just pointing out that we're all biased)Since then I've relaxed a lot of my rigidity. I pumped for and breastfed my kids--I personally take credit for the pumping room installed in my district office following my unrelenting pursuit of a suitable place to pump that did not include a toilet--the secretary pumped for awhile then quit. I never said a word. I learned that we all have different lives and experiences and my reality is not hers. Recently she and I have begun processing our early relationship (i.e., when we were pregnant) and several times she began the conversation by saying something about how our pregnancy hormones didn't work together well. Finally she spit out what she really thinks. She said, "You made me feel like I was doing everything wrong." That sounds about right. I never once said that. I never once told her she made a poor choice or whatever. But I thought it. A lot. I completely disapproved of so many things, and in my effort to "educate" her, I just made her averse to me. I thought I was being enlightening. I was just obnoxious. I find she listens to my opinions far more now that I treat her as if her opinions and life experiences matter too. Because they do. Now we share our individual thoughts, it's not just me teaching her about her rights and abilities...
Honestly, I don't see birth anymore as much different than any other right to choose any other thing. If the consequences of an action are known, the risks involved weighed, why can't a woman elect to cbirth, or birth vaginally or any other of the choices? If we're talking about empowerment, and making people aware, then we have to respect that sometimes their decisions will not be ours. And by the same token, not everybody processes their grief, their trauma, their pain at the same rate in the same way. To me, that's AP--recognizing the individuality of lives, and that's what's truly not mainstream--being open to the ideas and actions of those that don't agree with our own.

Leah





) If a mom tells me she tried to have a natural birth but then goes into how small her pelvis is and how she hadn't made any progress for 4 hours and then guess what, of course I want her to know that it was all crap and she probably could have done what she wanted if she had been able to go at her own pace. But it could be she will intrepret that as me judging her.
:
Follow Mothering