Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Diapering › Considering buying Pull Ups - WWYD
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Considering buying Pull Ups - WWYD

post #1 of 10
Thread Starter 
My 3 year old DD has NEVER worn a disposable diaper, but I'm considering buying her pull ups I think she's pretty close to potty learning, but of course I'm not sure. She goes through phases of using the potty often, but then she'll go a week or more without using it at all. I have a 4 week old, and we've had a difficult summer dealing with DD's behavior. I didn't want to let using the potty be one of the power struggles and an added stressor in my life or DD's life, so I haven't pushed it. A few times she's asked for panties, which I happily put on her, but generally she pees in them (or worse yet poops in them) within an hour or two of putting them on. I don't mean she doesn't quite make it to the toilet, I mean she just goes in them.

She's just done a HUGE growth spurt, and now her pocket diapers just don't fit her well. I can still snap them on her without hurting her, but they're really too small and leak quite often. We have some fitted and wool that fit better, but it's WAY too bulky to wear under pants, so it just works under skirts and dresses. She has lots of trouble getting the wool covers down or back up over the bulky fitted diaper too.

We're pretty tight on money right now. I've considered buying larger pocket diapers, or cloth trainers, but I fear that would cost lots of money that we really don't have, and I'm doubting the cloth trainers would solve the leaking issues.

We spent LOTS of time outside of the house, and it just doesn't work for her diapers to leak regularly. She's also in several 3-4 year old activities and seems to be the only child in diapers in those classes (and likely the youngest by several months). One is a gymnastics class that she really needs to wear pants for. I absolutely don't want to risk the possibility of a leaky diaper in the middle of one of these classes, mostly for her sake.

So, I'm considering buying pull ups to use when we're out of the house. I would continue to use fitteds with wool at night, and would likely aim for lots of bare bottom time at home during the day.

Anyone have a better idea? I really hate to be doing disposables, but I'm thinking in the end it might be the best decision here.
post #2 of 10
2 things come to mind:

1) pull ups are not a replacement for a diaper. If she has a full on 3 y/o pee (lots!) it will still leak. A sposie diaper may help that though. Cloth trainers are the same way, they only hold a little accident, not a full on pee'ing.

2) Fuzzy bunz one size really does work up to that large a kid. Given, I am not sure how big your DD is, but they fit my almost 3 y/o with room still. Then when she is done with them, they can immediately be used on the other baby. This has been our solution for now.

All that said, I have bought a few packs of sposie pull-ups for night time, but DD has been mostly PT'ed for almost a year now. If she has a full accident, they do leak. If I would have known she would still need them at night, I would have gone with more FB OS's instead. Right now we only have 2 designated for her, the other 4 are for my son.
post #3 of 10
I'd just go with regular sposies for out and about. They are cheaper and you won't use very many.
post #4 of 10
Honestly? I think pull ups are a gimmick ($$$). My daughter went straight from dipes to panties and I never saw the need for them. It took one weekend of lots of juice and hourly potty sitting for her to remember to sit on the potty. I think that switching back and forth only prolongs potty learning.

I'd just go for the cheap dipes or only panties.
post #5 of 10
My dd wears Toddler-ease with Dappi nylon pants at night, and they never leak. Plus she can pull them down and up herself. The only problem is bulk, which I don't care about since it's only at night, but I guess it might be more of a problem when out and about.
post #6 of 10
My dd is weird but pull ups actually helped her pottytrain. For some reason while she wanted to be successful with pottying she jsut couldn't seem to make the big connection and a wet cloth diaper or peeing all over her naked self meant nothing other than it embarressed her . there was something about how the pull up would kinda clump as the gel beads got wet and expanded that was her clue opps better get to the bathroom and with in a few weeks she was finiAlly able to put the before feeling together and prevent all accidents. I say finially cause she was 4.5 years before we had even a small breakthrough. Weird I know. We used store brand type pull ups and snap EZ trainers (those she pretty much treated like a diaper) the pull ups help everything just fine as long as we changed often eventually we just used one at night and did the goodnights or the huggies neight weight ones with success. DD was at that time into a size of CDs that were hard to find without custom ordering and we couldn't do pockets or any poly fabrics. I did have a few special CDs make but it was expensive very expensive so pullups won.

Deanna
post #7 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by ShwarmaQueen View Post
Honestly? I think pull ups are a gimmick ($$$). My daughter went straight from dipes to panties and I never saw the need for them. It took one weekend of lots of juice and hourly potty sitting for her to remember to sit on the potty. I think that switching back and forth only prolongs potty learning.

I'd just go for the cheap dipes or only panties.
I have to overall agree with this. If your DD is showing real signs I would try taking a week or so and jsut really focusing and seeing how it goes. If shes not ready maybe its time to go back to diapers for a while. Our situation was diffrent because mine has sensory processing delays that played a big role into how her body responded but for most I'd deffiently give it a good go.

Deanna
post #8 of 10
Personally I would NOT recommend pull ups. We had a girl (same age as my son) in his daycare. She did pull ups, he did cloth pull ups (mother-ease training pant - AWESOME). He learned in one weekend (with accidents in the following month - that is normal), she went back to diapers b/c honestly with pull ups you don't feel wet! We did undies during the day, yes there will be accidents, we just explained that "when you feel that tingle before you pee - tell us". He got it really quickly. He was ready though. At night we used the mother-ease training pants and he was night trained in a week. that's my two cents. You might have to adjust your weekend/week to focus on this, it is hard but worth it.
post #9 of 10
I vote for potty-training her. My kids were never serious about going on the potty and would always pee and poop in their pull-ups. Then I just finally said, "No more diapers!" and the first two days were no fun (I put them on the potty every hour) but by the 3rd day they were potty-trained.
post #10 of 10
What we do at night works well and is cheap... we use a cloth training pant ( gerber from walmart) and put a prefold diaper inside for extra absorption and use a bumkins pull on cover( if you buy these spend the extra $1.00 for the PRINTED ones...they are thicker and hold up much better than the white ones). I refuse to waste money on pull ups. Good luck to you!!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Diapering
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Diapering › Considering buying Pull Ups - WWYD