Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › Almost 4 yo will not stop touching 1 yo's head.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Almost 4 yo will not stop touching 1 yo's head.

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
It sounds ridiculous, but it is driving me to drink.

I have a 5 yo DD(new kindergartner), 3.75 yo DS, and a 13 month old DD. 3.75 yo DS seems ;fixated on DD2's head. They cannot be unsupervised for even a second, or he starts pulling at her head, twisting her face, sort of wrenching her neck, pulling on the back of her shirt. When we are physically together, if my eyeballs come off him, he is at her. Even if my eyeballs are on him, speaking to him directly, ignoring the baby, he is always almost unconsciously moving toward her to mess with her head. In the hallway picking up kindergartner DD, it is very nearly physically impossible to keep him from her. I have to hold him bodily away, and he is often flailing his arms at her while I do so. Extremely out of character. If I pick up DD2, he pulls on her legs. You get the picture. I don't think it *is* a compulsion, but it reads like compulsive behavior. He has no trouble listening to me about any other topic. Always has listened well in public, except about this. He displays no other sensory type behaviors. Not impulsive for his age, except about this. Wants to play with his sister, generally, gets upset that he can't when he hurts her (though this does not seem to deter him). Of course, she adores him, and would follow him around all day if she could, attempts to wring her neck notwithstanding.

I have tried extra 1 on 1 attention for him(lots and lots! Totally separate from the incidents!), separating them, trying to get him to empathize, giving him jobs about her, taking them all away so he didn't get resentful, etc. It has been going on for about 3 months, so I think I must just be missing the cause. I was thinking sibling rivalry, looking for attention. That's not it. She just started walking 2 weeks ago, and had been crawling for months when it started, so it's not mobility. What else could it be? My only other guess is jealousy about all the attention his older sister is getting for being a kindergartner, but what could I do about that? He is already getting hours of 1 on 1 time a day, and that's not really it (plus not sustainable as it means I have no downtime, and am running out of steam). He's not displaying any other troublesome behaviors, and nothing changes at all. I think his "cup"' is full. He's just doing this.

Anybody else with a compulsive head futzer? What did you do?
post #2 of 6
"You are hurting your sister. You need to take a seat. When you can play without hurting her, you may get up."
"That hurts your sister. Have a seat. Come and play when you can do it without hurting her."

Over and over and over.
post #3 of 6
Thread Starter 
I have been doing that, for about 3 months, with no effect. Really, none, and I am 100% consistent, and it is the same sentence I use with other behaviors to good effect. It seems compulsive, which is why I am posting. He does not have this problem with any other behaviors, and his older sister has never had this kind of trouble with any behavior. I would say, apart from this, that they are exceptionally good listeners, and we have exceptionally good communication together about what is an isn't acceptable behavior in our family. This is different.
post #4 of 6
Ask your pediatrician or health care provider to recommend a child psychologist. My son developed an odd behavior around age four. Two sessions with a child psychologist and it was gone.

Best of luck to you.
post #5 of 6
I have no suggestions, but can totally empathize. I have an almost 4 y.o. and an 8 m.o., and while the "attention" isn't constant, it's troubling to me. I have noticed that the 4 y.o. does it in kind of a manic way. When I tell him to stop and that the baby doesn't like it, he does it more forcefully, rolls his eyes away from me, gets a big weird smile on his face, and shakes his head. It drives me batty, too! I really, truly think it has something to do with the life changes the baby brought to the household and the shifting dynamic, especially with me, mama. I keep telling myself that I know he'll grow out of it, but sometimes it seems impossible to protect the little one and be a gentle guide to the bigger one at the same time!
post #6 of 6
Sometimes good moms are very quiet with their kids. You might try responding very loudly and quickly when he does it and give your attention to the baby. When he does something that looks extra bad like going for her face, rush over and push him away and start talking to the baby about if she is ok. Make him out to be the bad guy.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › Almost 4 yo will not stop touching 1 yo's head.