Help me choose what to knit!

[adoremybabe]

Please help me decide what scarf to knit for my mother!

Right now it is between these two:

http://www.mistialpaca.com/downloads...n_2001_WEB.pdf

http://www.mistialpaca.com/downloads/Asphodel.pdf

I am favoring the second one more because on Ravelry there are pics of one knit in cashmere that is perfect and gorgeous! She repurposed a scarf. I was thinking about knitting it with this http://www.knitpicks.com/yarns/Shimm..._D5420112.html

Here is a link to the scarf knit in cashmere. http://www.ravelry.com/projects/morf...del-lace-scarf

This would be my first blocked project.

I'm soooo nervous!

[flapjack]

The second.

[DeerMother]

Originally Posted by flapjack

The second.

that's my vote too. I need to fave it!

[iowaorganic]

I love the second one! I might be knitting that as well- and I do have quite a bit of stashed lace weight....

[Juvysen]

Wow, that first one really looked crocheted to me. I had to actually look and make sure it was actually knit! HAHA... and I do both!

Anyway, I like the first one better. Your last link leads to knitpicks yarn, not to ravelry

[adoremybabe]

Yes, the last link is supposed to lead to knitpicks to show you what yarn I'd use istead of the cashmere. I'll post a link to the cashmere scarf in ravelry.

[Juvysen]

Originally Posted by adoremybabe

Yes, the last link is supposed to lead to knitpicks to show you what yarn I'd use istead of the cashmere. I'll post a link to the cashmere scarf in ravelry.

Ah, gotcha I love that yarn, fwiw...

[mum21andtwins]

I love the second one thanks for posting this I've faved it

[weliveintheforest]

I love the asphodel one

[Runningmommy]

ooohh, the second one. What color are you doing? How long does something like that take to knit up?

[caiesmommy]

i say second one> I've faved it for my M-I-L! Thanks

[adoremybabe]

I think that I will go with the second one. It caught my eye first.

I'm not sure what color to knit it in yet. ...see my post about choosing color.