I used Bradley with my first and Hypnobabies with my second birth. I enjoyed Bradley while I was taking it. I thought they provided a lot of very useful information and good ways to cope with the pain. But, I had a very difficult labor (back labor, 28 hours, 3 1/2 hours of pushing) and I felt that it didn't provide any information on how to handle back labor. Also, because of the back labor, I had a very different progression of labor (long contractions, no breaks in between), which differed a great deal from what we were taught during Bradley about how contractions would be and what to expect from them. Also, it relies a great deal on a partner (hence the name, husband-coached childbirthing) and, while dh was supportive during the pregnancy, he had no idea how to help me during the labor because of how much pain I was in, and pretty much froze and did nothing. I felt very alone during labor.
With my second, I wanted an approach that I could do myself but could also include dh if he wanted (and was able). I looked into Hypnobabies and saw such rave reviews that I decided to give it a shot. I listened to the tapes during the pregnancy and felt that they really helped me have a relaxing, enjoyable pregnancy. I also was more comfortable physically - much less back pain and other common discomforts of pregnancy. I also slept MUCH better - I always fell asleep to the tapes and I actually used them to help me fall asleep. The birth itself was wonderful. From start to finish it was 3 hours, 20 minutes. I woke up to what I thought were Braxton Hicks at 1:40 in the morning and went and got some water (thinking I was just not hydrated enough, switched a load of laundry, and then decided I should maybe time these "pressure waves" just to make sure they werne't coming regularly. Well, they were regular - 2 minutes apart! I still didn't really believe it since I was still so comfortable so I waited until about 2:40 to wake up my dh. He went to call our doulas and mw (which I objected too. I said, "this probably isn't it. And even if it is, I have HOURS to go. I'm completely comfortable. Don't wake them up."). He called anyway and we left for the birth center at 3:15. We arrived at 4:20 (it was an hour and 15 minutes away but in the middle of the night we got there slightly faster). The pressures waves were regular but just felt like tightness -the same feeling you get when you have your blood pressure taken. The only time they hurt was when we pulled into the birth center. There's a bump there, which dh didn't realize, and he pulled into the parking lot kind of quickly. It kind of threw me off center a bit, which required me to move out of my deeply relaxed, limp state. That contracton HURT, and lasted about 1 1/2 -2 minutes, compared to all the others, which never lasted more than 45 seconds. We got inside, they checked me, and I was 6 cm! They told me I could get into the tub so I got in at around 4:30. Around 4:40 my doulas arrived. I was laughing and cheering the fact that I was 6 cm, posing for pictures with my fancy drinks with the umbrella straws in my nice cozy jacuzzi tub, and just having a great time. About 10 minutes later, at 4:50, I started getting more "serious." I kept saying, "I'm feeling the pressure low" and needed to be reminded to relax my shoulders. At 4:55, I said, "I have to poop," got on all 4s to stand up and just started pushing (still not realizing that I was pushing a baby out, rather than just pooping!). My doulas called the midwife in saying, "she's pushing" and I thought, "I am?" and 4 minutes later, my daughter was born. It was amazing. It was fast and easy and peaceful. Pushing was intense, especially because I didn't realize I was pushing. But honestly, I can tell you that 1 contraction was painful (the one pulling into the parking lot), 2 were intense/uncomfortable (during the 5 minutes of transition), and pushing was just a little overwhelming, but other than that, it was painfree, relaxing, and wonderful. I seriously can't wait to give birth again. I had such a wonderful experience and rave about Hypnobabies to everyone I see. I can't imagine giving birth without it now that I've done it!