We tried again last night because I have some nipple trauma on my right side and I want to pump for a few days on that side to give it a break (pumping doesn't hurt as bad, I'm bleeding when I nurse, but not when I pump) Anyway, Gavin took it! He drank about an ounce and a half, but I had just nursed him 30 minutes before on my left side, so I know he wasn't really hungry. It was his evening cluster feeding.
I did nurse him on my right side less than an hour later, and it didn't hurt as bad. Maybe because the pump had relieved some of the pressure and he could latch easier, or maybe because he wasn't as hungry so he wasn't sucking as hard, I don't know. But I'm going to mostly pump that side for at least another day to give myself a chance to heal some more. OUCH.