Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › What Really Works? Read Books, but Nothing Is Working
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

What Really Works? Read Books, but Nothing Is Working

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
My daughter is 3.5 and is making things really hard on us as a family. She will have melt downs when she doesn't get what she wants, and lots of other issues. I feel at a loss for what to do. I have read "How to talk so your kids will listen and how to listen...", along with a few others and nothing seems to be working.
So what works, I am feeling overwhelmed.
Thanks
post #2 of 7
My DD is 4.5--we went through a rough patch at the end of the summer. I started really monitoring her sugar and protein intake. Too much sugar in her juice, yogurts, everything carby--and increasing her protein at snacks and meals. She seems mellower now, so I am sticking with it.
post #3 of 7
I'm getting ready to read "The Explosive Child". I found a support thread on here about it the other day and watched the videos on the website posted on the thread. Just watching those videos has helped me understand that my dd (also 3.5) probably doesn't have the skills to handle life's frustrations and needs to be taught those skills. I hope you find something that works for you guys. I know how hard it is to have the child who can tantrum for over and hour over something as simple as what plate you've served her sandwich on. Good luck!
post #4 of 7
Yeah, diet can make a big huge difference. My 3yo can't tolerate sugar at all and not very much dairy without it affecting his behavior a lot.

I also like Raising Our Kids Raising Ourselves and Hold On To Your Kids. Those were my favorites besides How To Talk.
post #5 of 7
Yes to the diet and the Explosive Child book. My challenging one seems to do best with firm but loving limits. The Positive Discipline series by Jane Nelsen is helpful.

For us one of the best things that ever happened was sending dd1 to preschool 2 days a week. She LOVED it there, heard other grown ups reinforce the same types of rules we did. She became much happier (adequate social and other stimulation) and as a result, so did we! Also she became more cooperative.

Remember that children sometimes save their hardest behaviour for their parents because they trust you and know you love them no matter what. Hang in there.
post #6 of 7
Time, consistency, and patience, I think, work better than anything you can find in a book. Even if you're doing everything "right," the years between 18 months and 4 years old can be extremely trying on the parents. If you're firm, calm, and consistent, they do learn more social, and less irritating and explosive, behaviors, but it doesn't happen quickly.

My DD1 is 5 1/2 now. She was IMPOSSIBLE as a three year old. The second half of that year was the worst. She'd fly into a rage at the drop of a hat, and whine and complain all day, and break down in the face of even the tiniest difficulty. She talked nonstop all day, and would throw a fit if asked to do ANYthing that wasn't her idea.

FWIW, she's grown into a reasonably civilized kid who's fun to be with. She's got her moments, of course, but on the whole she's a kid you'd like to hang out with.

That doesn't mean you don't keep searching for what works. But it does mean that you can't conclude that what you're doing isn't working, just because it hasn't worked yet. It's like teaching a baby not to hit-- you have to tell them a thousand times, and stop them from doing it a thousand times, and show them appropriate ways to touch, again a thousand times, and then finally one day, months or years later, all that accumulated repetition and consistency seems to "take."
post #7 of 7
aaaaaaaah the feeling of overwhelmed.

is it because you expect your child to comply? act in a certain manner?

yup that is high expectations. nope it really isnt going to happen.

3 and 4 is all about trying to figure out the world. what a parent tries to do is set the rules, and try to get the child to comply but not demand it.

the how to talk to books are for older kids. not 3.5.

if you expect your 3.5 year old to listen most of the time then you are expecting too much. maybe 20-30% of the time - now that is more reasonable.

the thing here is looking into your own life and wondering why you are having such a hard time.

with me i found whenever i was having a hard time - it was more about me rather than my dd.

and looking back the hard time was because i didnt want to be THAT mom with THAT child. social pressure.

i happened to be THAT mom with THAT child and i am so grateful that happened because my dd is a pretty independent freethinking 7 year old right now.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › What Really Works? Read Books, but Nothing Is Working