Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Homebirth › Did anyone have an attended birth, but not with a midwife?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Did anyone have an attended birth, but not with a midwife? - Page 2

post #21 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Carson View Post
DH is an EMT and baby catching is a very minor part of his training. He also doesn't have any equipment at home. If we were not having a midwife in attendance, I would consider it a UC. If an emergency happens while we are birthing, we will have to call 911.
My DH is an EMT too, and has a "jump bag" full of the basics + an oxygen tank. He's still against HBing though, even though our last was a HB.
post #22 of 26
There is a doc around here that does a handful of homebirths has done 33 i believe. A friend of mine is using him. She had him with her last birth in hospital and likes that she will have the same care provider even if she needs to transfer. Her doc sounds totally awesome. She asked if she could have a homebirth and he surprised her by replying with, "absolutely, it's your baby!" I am actually thinking of using him as back up care as I might decide to have a UC my next pregnancy depending on the situation of paying for a midwife. There is also the Homefirst thing they have in I believe the Chicago area...
post #23 of 26
I had a homebirthing MD with my daughter. (She has since retired.)
My daughter was 16 days past her due date, and I was in labor for 38 hours. There's no way I would have gotten to birth naturally if it wasn't for her. Any hospital would have given me a c-section in a heartbeat, and most midwives won't attend home births past 42 weeks.

As far as being "black balled" by the medical community, that MD got fired from teaching at a university hospital because of her HB practice, and she also used to work in state-funded low-income clinics on the side, and got fired from that for the same reasons.
I recently heard a rumor about another doctor who fired by his medical group and lost his hospital privileges because he attended HBs for his wife. It might not have ended his career if it only happened once, but after 4 times, you can no longer pretend like it was unintentional..
post #24 of 26
My first birth was attended at home by our MD when we lived in northern Illinois - he's a family practice doc not an OB. He was great and the idea of homebirth never even crossed my mind until I started going to him and he suggested it! Needless to say, I am so incredibly grateful that we were guided to him! He has since stopped attending all births (even in the hospital) because the malpractice insurance was just too high
post #25 of 26

Dr.s who attend homebirths

There is also a MD on the NC/TN line (near Mtn. City) who attended his daughter's two homebirths around 15-18 yrs. ago. There is a MD/chiropractor/holistic MD (yes he is an allopathic MD only when it is Truly warranted) who caught his last 2 (of 4) children at home in Wilkesboro, NC. I used to have an office in his office, and he has offered to me to use an office suite, again, and his referal capabilites, now that I am back home.
Karen of BirthTender
& finally done with the MS in nursing/nurse-midwifery
post #26 of 26
I think that OBs attending homebirths used to be more common. My brother and I were born at home, an my mother had an OB and midwife at home. They all worked together in a homebirth practice. This was in the 70's and early 80's. Neither of them still practice homebirth, if they practice at all.
EMT's do NOT have skills to attend to labor and birthing. They are trained to handle an emergency hospital transport, and learn very little about how to handle the nuances of birthing. My brother is an EMT, and it was funny to hear about his "birth training". Most OB who are new on the scene or in the middle of their practice's life, often do not have the full skills to handle natural childbirth. Training is usaully concerned with observation, diagnosis and intervention. OBs are certainly trained to use technology. I think you can still find older OBs who are skilled at handling different presentation and a wide variety of birth scenarios where they are able to help the women remain on the path of a natural childbirth. I would love to hear otherwise, but this is my understanding. Additionally, docs in other fields I would not consider qualified to attend a birth based on their MD title.
Though, people certainly can learn...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Homebirth
Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Homebirth › Did anyone have an attended birth, but not with a midwife?