Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy › Is this normal / healthy behavior?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Is this normal / healthy behavior?

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
Hoping this is the right forum and that it is safe to discuss this here, as I believe it is.

I weaned my ds, just 4, at 3.5…not really his decision, more so mine. I started night weaning him (he was still nursing every 2 hours or so at night…) and then I had surgery and became paranoid that I wouldn’t be able to pump and dump all the junk I had in my system from the surgery (when I pumped nothing came out) and so decided to wean. He loved nursing, and we talked a lot not having “milky” anymore and that if he felt like that’s what he needed, he could have a hug, or some snuggle time…he did fairly well…although I know it is missed. It was a big comfort for him, as he is somewhat spirited and I often called nursing my “reset” button for him. He was understanding, but misses it.

Here’s my current issue, since weaning, he continually puts his hand in my shirt, on "his" "milkly”. When we are in public, I gently move his hand out of my shirt as I do sometimes at home. It is a real habit for him. When he wakes up in the night, he’ll scoot over and instinctively place his hand there, as he does when he is hurt, or upset.

The other day, I was helping him through a tantrum when finally he came to me and laid down on my lap. I was wearing a v-neck and he snuggled up. The next thing he said, excitedly, was, “Mommy! You have milk in there again.” I said, “No honey, there’s no more milk.” He said, “But I can smell the milk. It smells so nice” I explained that he was remembering what it was like when he used to nurse…

Anyway, when is enough, enough? My main concern is that he grows up and remembers doing that and is disgusted or weirded out by it. And, I would rather he not do it, but don’t want to traumatize him, as it seems to be a great source of comfort.

Anyone have any thoughts or suggestions? When should I just not allow it? How do I not allow it? Is this behavior ok? Normal?

Thank you for your thoughts.
post #2 of 7
I think it is normal. He associates comfort with the breast. Many children do the same for years after weaning. And as you said, he probably wouldn't be self weaned yet (no judgment, I weaned my ds too, just a thought). My ds does the same thing or asks to lay on my tummy. And at this point my tummy is just like a big breast to him I think. Smooshy, warm, part of mama. As for when you are out you can tell him wait until we get home. He is old enough to understand that - but you will need to follow through and let him have a snuggle when you get home.
post #3 of 7
have you thought about maybe trying other forms of comfort? that helped SO much when my dd and I were going thru the weaning process. Another wise mothering mom gave me the idea to explain the concept of "comfort" to dd-I explained to her that nursing was her biggest comforting thing I could do, but that now, as she was getting older, we had new comforting things we could do together. she loved that explanation, and she very quickly accepted foot rubs and back scratching as her new comforts. (still does, today, at 7 )
post #4 of 7
Ohhh, I think thats so sweet ... I dont think there is anything at all unusual or abnormal about him wanting to touch/cuddle with Mama's breasts, as pp said, its obviously a huge source of comfort for him, and has been for pretty much his whole life!

Its hard, I am sure when in public, but I would also gently redirect, and explain that cuddling the breasts is for at home/during the night/whatever you're comfortable with.

I think its fabulous that he will associate such comfort and security from you and you milky's Now its just about setting some boundaries that he will understand. I wouldnt make him just "stop" touching, because it does sound like that would be a little traumatic. But reserve touching for private/at home time, maybe.
post #5 of 7
As other posters said, I think this is normal. One of my daughters used to twirl my hair while nursing and she still liked me to lay down with her so she could twirl my hair while falling asleep until she was about 9 or 10. My son used to rub a mole on my stomach and he continued to be attached to that until age 7.
post #6 of 7
My third did this. When he was upset his older sibs would ask if wanted boobie and he would say yes and stick his hand down my top for a cuddle.
Did it till he was in kindergarten. I never told him not too, even in public and he kinda "weaned" himself when he was ready. He still remembers and is not at all bothered by it.
post #7 of 7
His comments about smelling the milk made me cry (as do all weaning stories I read). PP's all had good advice and as long as you are both comfortable I think it is healthy and normal to continue talking about it and touching as well. You obviously have a very sweet and sensitive little bot who loves his Mama and her comfort!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy › Is this normal / healthy behavior?