Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Diapering › Is it just me or is this page full of misinfo about cloth diapers?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Is it just me or is this page full of misinfo about cloth diapers?

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
Virginia Tech. Dated Very recently.

Plastic covers?
Rinsing soiled diapers in the toilet?
7 diapers a day for disp users, but more () per day for cloth, not reducing until child toilet trains?
Wet pailing as the only storage option (else you'll need chlorine bleach)?
Diaper liners essential to "avoid problems" like wrong skin pH & rash?
Pre-wash?
White vinegar to prevent cloth causing rash?

Do you guys do all that / find it true description of how to do cloth properly??? Coz none of it is right, ime.

I don't have the energy to complain, but would love someone else to!
post #2 of 5
Well I was almost willing to say it wasn't that terrible its obvious its slant but not too over the top.. .but this comment
Quote:
There is little or no cost difference in laundering cloth diapers and buying disposable diapers.
HA HA really? HA! I think not we saw zitch zip zero cost diffrence in our water or our electricity bill in the 4.5 years we cloth diapered our first. Our flat rate bill would fluxuate around a $15 range just like it did prior to CD and has done in the years since it was not CD that caused any hike and that adjustment was for 6 months at a time. I large container of detergent before/After CD lasts us around 8-9 months with CD 6-7 it was hardly a huge added expense.
As for other details it depends... When I used or switched to disposables for whatever reason (vacations dealing with rashes ect) I used jsut as many sposies as cloth or at least a very close amount I don't think sposies or cloth are meant to jsut hold pee untill they give. So like my NB who was fully sposies got easily 15-20 diapers a day on average my toddler when we used sposies got the same 6-10ish a day as we used with cloth. And I used a LOT when potty training
I DO rinse cloth diapers in the toliet I can't stand for excess junk to go through my washer..
"plasic pants" is misleading waterproof/water ressistant would have been a better choice but truth is many cloth diaper choices do "need" a protectice cover
Its true there are super ecomimal cloth diapering choices *flats and dappi pants, middle ground (sized prefolds and velcro wraps or say one size pocket diapers and rather pricy stashes that would easily rivial the cost of sposies large custom wham diapers with lots of wool.. Even with resale CD stashes "can" be pricy but its not a guarentee... Sposies the cost keeps comming. And costs even for the store generic can add up pretty fast.. For example around my area I can get Target brand diapers for around $14 a package thats the cheepest.. at 7 diapers a day a package will last arounda week so 4 packs a month will run around $56 that not including wipes.. Thats over $600 for the first year alone just assuming 7 a day.
I can but 2 bummi diapering kits to CD from 8-30lbs for around $300 (less) I can add 2 dozen preemie/NB diapers and say 6 NB covers for another say $100 add say $10 worth of acessories (a few snappi pins a diaper sprayer wet bag and some wipes and some good doublers and I can have a good functioning CD stash for around $500 (I could do it for far less but trying to be somewhat real to an actual successful CD stash) that can go through PT and could potiently last through multiple kids...

Deanna
post #3 of 5
Geez.

We lived in an apartment with utilities included. Other than maybe an extra $2.50 a month in Bio-Kleen (a box of that stuff last forever!), laundering diapers was completely free.

This is my favorite:
Quote:
If you must use fabric softeners, use dryer sheets.
and a few paragraphs later:
Quote:
Don't use liquid fabric softener or dryer sheets.
This was obviously not proofread. I don't think they really care. They seem to assume already that you're going to use disposables, and they just want to make you feel better about that choice.
post #4 of 5
Looking at the authors, I see that there's a PhD and a graduate student. I can't help but think that the grad student isn't a parent yet and the PhD (plus all the "reviewers" at the bottom) never used "modern" cloth diapers. The "adults" probably have experience only with "pins and plastic pants" and disposables.

It's a shame that something so poorly researched is being passed off as "information from experts."
post #5 of 5
I couldn't help myself, but I very poiltely asked where the reviewers got the information that is posted. I'm curious to see what they say... will KIT. Personally, I think it's bolonga
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Diapering
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Diapering › Is it just me or is this page full of misinfo about cloth diapers?