Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Surprising conversation I had today.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Surprising conversation I had today.

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
So, I'm finally getting back into working as a home health aide, and I've got this new patient who is an elderly lady, and her daughter and 12 year old grandaughter live in the house with her. The daughter is staying home with her for the week, as she's recently back from the hospital.

So, at the end of my shift, after I had had the mom back in bed resting, I asked if they wanted to see pictures of my babies, which they very much did. So we got into talking about baby stuff, and I talked a little bit about their having been in NICU, and something about pain in infants came up.

At that point she suddenly brought up how when she was pregnant she had been hoping she would have a boy, so I kind of knew something about circ was probably coming up, and I was expecting to hear something very conventional. She talked quite a bit about having wanted the baby to be a boy, and then she got into the circ talk, and said "and if it had been a boy, there was absolutely no WAY that I was getting him circumcised."

Then she went into a bunch of reasons, including "and there's protection of his partner, I mean, if I can't teach him to clean himself there..."

Of course, I quickly let her know that I hadn't circed my little guys, and I felt really strongly about it too. I was also able to educate her on the non-retractability of babies, and the fact that many medical people are ignorant about that. She said that she and her husband actually do want to have another child, though I don't know if it will happen or not, as she's in her late 30's. After this talk though, I really hope that they do, and that it turns out to be a boy.

She also said that everybody else in her family had been really forceful in telling her that it HAD to be done.

So after we exchanged all this I told her that it was really nice to meet someone who felt the same way I did, and then she turned towards her mother and said "There, see Mom?!", like she had finally trumped her mom in an argument from 13 years in the past.

Anyway, it's kind of nice to be reminded that there really are other people around who feel the same way we do.
post #2 of 8
Yes, it is VERY nice to meet people who feel the same way! I hope that lady has a boy in the future.
post #3 of 8
Isn't that such a nice surprise!
post #4 of 8
I agree it is a wonderful surprise, b/c circ usually isn't a matter of conversation with people you don't know well.
post #5 of 8
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by mommyminer View Post
I agree it is a wonderful surprise, b/c circ usually isn't a matter of conversation with people you don't know well.
Actually, that's not really been my experience. I never bring it up myself, and never really participated in other people's conversations about it before having my own kids, but I can remember a number of times that it's come up in casual conversation with people talking in very intimate detail about their experiences.

I once was standing in line at a store to buy concert tickets, and there was a lady next to me with about a year old baby that she was trying to really hard to cheer up. Then she turned to me out of the blue and said, "That's the first time he's smiled all day. He got circumcised yesterday, so he's sore and it hurts." Like I really wanted to know that. I just sort of smiled and nodded and went on with my ticket purchase.
post #6 of 8
I want a home health nurse like you! The topic came up with the last nurse and she went on and ON about the elderly patients she'd taken care of and their "problems". I told her that their "problems" were caused by improper care. She didn't know what to say to that. It amazes me how many nurses don't know what to DO with a foreskin!
post #7 of 8
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by bandgeek View Post
I want a home health nurse like you! The topic came up with the last nurse and she went on and ON about the elderly patients she'd taken care of and their "problems". I told her that their "problems" were caused by improper care. She didn't know what to say to that. It amazes me how many nurses don't know what to DO with a foreskin!
I'm not a nurse, just an aide, though I am hoping to get an RN degree at some point.

I have seen some frightful situations, including a couple of nurses or aide's (can't remember) standing over a clearly intact old man and loudy discussing his status which they were unable to figure out. And then a third nurse piping in about how old men often end up needing to be circed. And this poor old guy could hear everything and they were talking as if he weren't even there.

I'd guess that the elderly are almost as much victims of medical ignorance as the very young.
post #8 of 8
Quote:
Originally Posted by Crunchy Frog View Post
I'm not a nurse, just an aide, though I am hoping to get an RN degree at some point.
Meh, close enough. I've known many aides who knew more than the RN's. We've had one RN (normally they send out LPNs) and she was just....unbelievably incapable. I would rather leave my DD with a 19 year old nursing student or an aide than someone like that again. Sheesh.

You know more in that department than every nurse I've ever met. So you are already on my "I want this in a nurse" list.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Surprising conversation I had today.