Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Frugality & Finances › If you were unexpectedly given $5K cash, WWYD?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

If you were unexpectedly given $5K cash, WWYD?

post #1 of 53
Thread Starter 
Long story.... short version is DH finally got paid for work he did a couple years ago. Due to extenuating circumstances, we weren't expecting him to ever get paid for this work. Well, the guy suddenly showed up and paid us in cash.

Yes, I asked a teller at a grocery store bank to verify some of the cash was real. I also deposited some into our credit union account. All is well on the authenticity front.

We need to use about half for a new furnace and ductwork. Neighbors have paid $2-3K and are happy with their decisions (installers and furnaces/ductwork/warranty/etc.). I need to call the companies and evaluate for myself. My dad is willing to help us do the install ourselves (and we'd help him install a new one in his place, as well). That would lower the cost below my estimate, but we may "splurge" and just pay someone to do the whole thing since we have the cash. Plus, we just did extensive repairs/upgrades ourselves over the spring/summer from a major flood. It is a catch-22 for me. I find I am happier with the quality of work (labor) when we do it ourselves, but it tends to take longer to get the job completely done. We usually opt for a higher quality product and free labor (ourselves), but we do contract out certain aspects of some projects. Our place was built in the 70s and certain things are best left to experts with appropriate equipment and expertise (potential asbestos, unusual mortar/tile removal, super high ceiling, etc). The furnace itself doesn't qualify for professional installers, in my opinion, but the ductwork might (fiberglass, I'm pretty sure).

Our only debt is our mortgage. DH's salary was cut back in January 2009. I called every company we pay and reduced our services to get our bills lowered. We're doing okay, but gave up eating out for the most part this year (for frugal reasons AND health reasons). We used some of the cash to get some restaurant gift cards (roughly $200 in GC for ~$65) for a treat in the new year and it turns out we'll be having a houseguest for a week soon. We haven't decided what to do with the rest.....

For fun (as in a fun discussion), what would you do with $5,000 cash you were not expecting, but earned back in 2007?
post #2 of 53
My practical answer is put it away for a down payment on a house. My totally fun and frivolous answer would be a trip to Paris. In the springtime.
post #3 of 53
Practical answer- pay off half our car loan, or fix the broken tub in our 2nd bath and some other miscellaneous home repairs that we've put off for years...

Fun answer- take a month off, and take the kids to go see my sister in New Mexico, camping the whole way there
post #4 of 53
I say use 75% to pay down debt, and 25% to splurge and have some fun

Congratulations!
post #5 of 53
I would pay of debt.... other wise a nice trip to see family for the Holidays Ours are in Alaska, so its a spendy trip.


Have fun.
post #6 of 53
Thread Starter 
I didn't think of it that way...practical and fun!

I guess the "practical" is taken care of with the furnace/ductwork, so now we can focus on the "fun".......

I don't know if I can allocate all the remaining amount (after furnace/ductwork) to "fun," though...... I was raised to be far more practical with money..... I'm having a hard time even considering paying professionals to install the furnace because we *can* install it ourselves. If the ductwork turns out to be a complicated issue (been warned previously by neighbors that it is/can be in our case), then I can come to terms with that portion being done professionally due to health concerns.

What percentage of $5K (most cash I've ever held in my hands at one time!) would you allocate to "practical" versus "fun"????
post #7 of 53
Practical - Pay off the IRS and some medical bills.

Fun - Take a Disney Cruise with my husband and the kids once DS was old enough. (Would $5K even be enough? )
post #8 of 53
Practical - pay off our CC card and put the rest against our car payment

Fun - pay off our CC and use the rest to go on vacation and get some new clothes
post #9 of 53
I'd put some aside for the self-employment tax, some towards debt and spend the rest on a shopping spree. Electronics, most likely. That's our thing, here.
post #10 of 53
I would use it to buy the crown molding for the kitchen and pay down debt. I wouldn't spend any on fun stuff right now, but that's because we spend enough on fun stuff at this time.
post #11 of 53
I know you asked just for fun, but I can't help but comment. Your words about the quality of labor are so familiar to me. We hardly ever hire anything out. When we do, it's just a disappointment - either in the quality or cost of labor. And sometimes it doesn't even take less time than it would take us to do it, though I know that's likely true in the case of a furnace and I can see the potential for the specialized skill.

But anyway, for fun... I would pay off the balance of DH's small loan on his truck, set $1k or so aside for us to take our weekly fitness classes, and use the rest to finish some of the projects we started. (what was that about less time? )
post #12 of 53
Personally, I would put back the amount I need to pay the taxes on the income. I would not ignore paying the taxes just because I was paid in cash. It's income. Then after that, I'd not really do anything with it. Just save it. I know, boring and not very fun, but we don't have anything that we would spend $5K on that we already can't now. We're big on saving and that is fun for me.

In your case, the taxes alone are probably going to be $1500 - $2000 and after that, you'll probably have just enough to do the furnace. Maybe have a nice meal out?
post #13 of 53
I would use it for practical reasons, but if I had to use it for fun reasons only, I would go shopping for new clothes for the whole family, take a short vacation (within driving distance of home) and get a few more Christmas presents for the kids.
post #14 of 53
Good for you! I'm happy that your DH got paid. My DH worked for a guy 5 years ago who owes him $600 and has never paid him, despite repeated attempts to collect.

If we had $5,000, I'd use it to 1) pay off our car and 2) move into a new rental. We just found out our rental house has mold. We've only lived here since September and can't afford to move again.

ETA: I forgot to say about the fun! Since the above things would only take about $2000, I'd also buy us a bunch of new clothes, blankets, and maybe a laptop computer. Anything left would go in savings.
post #15 of 53
I agree with velochic here. Having $2000 worth of fun isn't nearly worth the stress of knowing that you owe the IRS.

I'd probably get the new furnace (how exciting!! What a great upgrade for you guys!), save the tax money back, and I'd pick one fun thing to do.

For us, that'd be a nice dinner out. But, I could see justifying a day in the spring at an amusement park or a weekend camping or a new piece of electronics or getting $50 cash each or whatever floats your boat. That way, it feels like you got your reward, but you still met your obligations. ANd that feeling of security is really nice, too.
post #16 of 53
Pay off debt, then use the money I was going to pay it with over the next few months to build savings, then use money I would have put in savings to get furniture, tools, toys, a hammock, and for dh a trombone and a good sword.
post #17 of 53
Since you asked "for fun", I'd say take a family vacation.

Though the practical part of me says to pay down any debt or save it.
post #18 of 53
Well, we have a roof that needs to be replaced in about 4 years so I'd put the money in our roofing fund.

I imagine that's not a need of yours, though!

Any home improvement you've been thinking of doing other than the furnace thing?

How's your savings? Think about investing it?
post #19 of 53
I would pay our back mortgage, pay our 2008 state taxes, get our tags renewed on our van, put in new tub/tile in our bathroom before the new baby's birth. $5k would just cover all of it.
post #20 of 53
Pay off a couple of medical bills and then take a motorcycle safety class and buy my own motorcycle.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Frugality & Finances
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Frugality & Finances › If you were unexpectedly given $5K cash, WWYD?