Mothering › Forums › Parenting › How do you decide when they are 'too old'?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

How do you decide when they are 'too old'? - Page 2

post #21 of 40
I found myself telling my dd that she was too old for a toy the other day.....( she wanted an American girl doll and sheis 13)

BUt I thinhk it was about wanting more than a toy. She wants one because her sisters got one and she never did and she always wanted one. I doubt she would ever play with it. They are expensive. even if she did she would not get $100 worth of enjoyment out of it. So in this case too old meant its not worth the money for the short time it would appeal to you and I don't think I have ever seen you play with your sisters dolls what make syou think you would enjoy one of your own? etc etc..too old was what came out though.

Eight is a tough age. You don't neccesarily want to invest in a lot of toys that will be pushed aside in a year or two. I don't know that I would buy my 9 year old a doll house but I certainly don't think she is too old to enjoy one. Our doll house is one of the last toys standing in the playroom. but again it comes back to cost verses play value. I mean we got that doll house for Christmas 7 years ago and it is still going strong. BUT it was over $200 not including all the sets of stuff we have added to it over the years. Thats an investment. I didn;t mind paying $100 for a doll for my 4 year old. She has at least 6 or 7 years that she will be playing with it (and she only has one.) I would be less inclined to pay that much for a doll for a child who is already clearly outgrowing doll play. but I think the age is less significant than what you see in that specific child. Kids want things for different reasons. maybe they want it because other people do or because it was something they had and loved but lost. they want to replace it.

Only you can say of your dd is too old for a doll house or not. or if it is worth the money for the amount of enjoyment it will bring. Your in tough spot because of the fire. that really does change things. She had stuff, that she would clearly still be playing with if it were there....but now that it is not, is it worth replacing....What kind of doll house does she want? Would she like a more grown up one that involves building it, decorating, carpet, flooring etc. I think that would be a super fun project. kinda taking the whole doll house thing to another level?

as for your mom, she needs to knock it off. She is going to give the poor kid a complex.
post #22 of 40
I don't get the concept of being too old to play with something. I used to play at the playground in my early to mid 20s (still do, just not right now). I've known teenage girls (and teenage boys!) who still like stuffed animals. My brother (46) plays with Lego...never stopped. I can spend long periods of time blowing soap bubbles. Playing is just playing - the props (if any) don't have an age limit. I'd definitely tell my mom to button it if she were saying something like that to my child. My children's interests are their interests and I won't put up with family members belittling them.
post #23 of 40
I was older than 8 when I got my first dollhouse. I saved my money, got a kit, and built it myself. I also think it could be a way to work through how traumatizing the fire was.
post #24 of 40
i remember when i was 11 or 12, i built a dollhouse with my older sister.....who was 23 or 24 at the time. it was *her* dollhouse, though, i just helped. i loved playing with it, though.

so, no, i don't think 8 is too old for a dollhouse.
post #25 of 40
I'm 40, and still love dollhouses and I also collect dolls. imo, one is never too old. 8 years old is too old? Ridiculous!
post #26 of 40
It would be really hard for me to tell my daughter she's too old for something she enjoys. I can remember being 12 and still secretly really loving my dollhouse and dolls. I was one of the last girls in my class who was ready to give up toys and be boy crazy, I just wasn't ready. I also remember that when the too-old-for-that girls came over, we still ended up at least sitting around the doll house and brushing hair while we talked. There's such an extended period of not-quite-ready for girls, I think it's fine for them to take their own time getting through it.

Even with Santa, if she still enjoys it, why take that away? She'll know when she's ready to know. Just be ready with her "Santa job" so she has something else to keep the magic going. In my family, we start the kids helping with stockings or supervising letters to Santa with the younger cousins, or help them make donations to other families - that kind of thing. It's fun to PLAY Santa, too.

Can you just tell your mom that you're not interested in rushing her along and as long as your daughter doesn't feel "too old" then you're not going to push her? EIGHT is still LITTLE!

ETA - I was a very responsible kid. I helped with my younger brothers, took care of the dishes most days, and did a lot of the family laundry. I still liked dolls and toys and craft kits. If your mom's concern is maybe that at eight, she's old enough to contribute and help out, she may be right. There's no reason she can't start taking on some responsibility AND still enjoy being a little girl. It's not either/or.
post #27 of 40
Thread Starter 
I had a chat with my mom this morning, and she agreed to be more aware of what she's saying. We also decided that DD will (after the holidays as it's just way too busy right now) help her grandfather build a large wooden dollhouse for her to have- that will be kept in the livingroom so that her brothers will also be able to play with it as they grow into it. She's going to decorate the rooms with wallpaper scraps, carpet remnants etc. Her grandfather is going to help her design and build simple wooden furniture and people- he'll cut them out with a scroll saw for her and she can assemble things like tables. I think she'll enjoy the process of putting it together more than actually playing with it (though I don't rule that out) and it will stand up to two little brothers worth of toddlerhood/preschooler play as well.
post #28 of 40
I think that sounds great.

My oldest is 8 and asked for a baby doll from Santa this year. She was telling me that she was probably too old for it but really wanted Santa to bring one. I went and got one that day. Children are expected to be mini adults and I hate that. She does have her share of responsibilities like keep her room clean, put her own laundry away, or helping her 6 year old sister with the dishwasher but she is still a child.

And yes she still believes in Santa. She goes to school and knows plenty of kids who do not believe. I ask her what she believes and she still wants to so we keep it up. I know that in the next year or two it will be gone so I am going to cherish the time that she believed in magic.
post #29 of 40
I keep thinking about this thread b/c I bought DD a dollhouse for christmas. She's 8, and while she is mature in that she is a fan of Miley, Jonas bros., loves her ipod more than any other belonging, and enjoys other tween stuff -- she still likes to play and imagine, just like most kids.
post #30 of 40
I don't think its ever anything anyone else can decide tbh. I feel its the same for socially gender specific toys. I would never tell my son he can't play with something because 'thats a girls toy'...I would never tell him he can't play with something because he was 'too old' for it either. Its his choice. I actually got him a dolls house because I still do enjoy playing with them - I figured it would be a nice toy that we could both play with together as its something we would both enjoy!

Your mum does sound a bit 'mean'...but perhaps its her own childhood upsets she is re-living? Maybe her parents told her she was too old for a dollhouse and it still hurts her?
post #31 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by confustication View Post
I had a chat with my mom this morning, and she agreed to be more aware of what she's saying. We also decided that DD will (after the holidays as it's just way too busy right now) help her grandfather build a large wooden dollhouse for her to have- that will be kept in the livingroom so that her brothers will also be able to play with it as they grow into it. She's going to decorate the rooms with wallpaper scraps, carpet remnants etc. Her grandfather is going to help her design and build simple wooden furniture and people- he'll cut them out with a scroll saw for her and she can assemble things like tables. I think she'll enjoy the process of putting it together more than actually playing with it (though I don't rule that out) and it will stand up to two little brothers worth of toddlerhood/preschooler play as well.
Thats a terrific idea!
post #32 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by LoMaH View Post
confustication
Why don't you show your mom the following link to dollhouses where the age range states from 3-11 yrs. old?
ETA- the Laurel House states it's for 3- 14! (even better)

http://www.toysrus.com/search/index....ter|8-11+Years

Personally, I wouldn't worry if my dd wanted to keep playing with her dollhouse after 11...... but at least for now, you can keep the peace with your mom and continue to allow your daughter to play with her dollhouse.
my 9yr dd still plays with dolls, mostly pollypockets

funny, we got dd ones of the doll houses in the link when dd was 7-8, but she prefers the fisher-price barn (got when dd was1yr) over the doll house since the pollypockets fit better!
post #33 of 40
One of my good friends still had her doll house set up through college.

I hate the phrase "Too old". If a kid wants to play with it, let them play! My kids always let me know when they've lost interest in things. Who are we to dictate play? I'm excited for my dd to get her doll house this year, because *I* want to play with it too.
post #34 of 40
I'd be very upset if my mother was telling my daughter she was too old for anything. I love doll houses and I am 29. If I wanted one bad enough, I'd buy myself one and decorate it and *gasp* even sit down and play with it!

Don't let your mom ruin the fun for your daughter, it is just not right.
post #35 of 40
Ack! No one should ever be "too old" for anything fun! I remember playing an impromptu game of hide n seek when I was ahem, 21 with a bunch of same aged friends . Oh heck it was a blast and all of the older folk on the block were laughing with us.

The thought of an 8 year old being too old for a dollhouse just baffles me.
post #36 of 40
There's no "too old" for play, especially in a world that continually forces teendom on kids earlier and earlier. Heck my 11 year old still loves her dollhouse! Her bff, who is not yet 11 but is already all about the fashion and makeup and texting asked for a tea set this Christmas...the little porcelain play kind that comes in a tiny basket...they've taken to having weekly tea parties.

Quote:
The thought of an 8 year old being too old for a dollhouse just baffles me.
post #37 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by confustication View Post
I had a chat with my mom this morning, and she agreed to be more aware of what she's saying. We also decided that DD will (after the holidays as it's just way too busy right now) help her grandfather build a large wooden dollhouse for her to have- that will be kept in the livingroom so that her brothers will also be able to play with it as they grow into it. She's going to decorate the rooms with wallpaper scraps, carpet remnants etc. Her grandfather is going to help her design and build simple wooden furniture and people- he'll cut them out with a scroll saw for her and she can assemble things like tables. I think she'll enjoy the process of putting it together more than actually playing with it (though I don't rule that out) and it will stand up to two little brothers worth of toddlerhood/preschooler play as well.
That's awesome, what a great project. It will have even more meaning too.
post #38 of 40
I, too, was 8 when I got my first ever doll house. I think there is a lot of "play" left at that age, particularly if she is at all into crafts. My mom and I made most of the furniture from kits, so it wasn't just a pretend play thing, kwim? Sounds like you have a good plan to give her what she wants.
post #39 of 40
My Mom is 60, and I am 40, and we just spent some time this weekend decorating my sister's old dollhouse from childhood for Christmas. (Little tree! Little wreath! Tiny presents!) My mom keeps it on a table in the den and redecorates it periodically. I think dollhouses are kind of ageless. And so are a lot of other toys.

OP, your daughter sounds sweet!
post #40 of 40
Oh my. Your mom wouldn't like me and my DH very much. We're in our 30s/40s, and we LOVE toys!!!! We have a 200+ Pez dispenser collection, RC cars, and a studio with walls covered in action figures.... But we don't just "collect" but also play with our mighty toys. All this happened long *before* DD was born.

Now, my FIL is hinting at making DD a Victorian dollhouse when DD's older, and we can't wait!

So to answer your question...No, I don't think 8 years is too old to have a dollhouse. When my FIL makes it, DD's dollhouse (and many of her other toys) will always be a permanent addition at our home until she decides to take it with her when she moves out.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › How do you decide when they are 'too old'?