Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › How To Discipline With Make Believe
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

How To Discipline With Make Believe

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
To balance my whining post, I wanted to share something that I'm finding makes a HUGE difference in my 3yo's behavior and that we enjoy immensely. She has hit the play pretend years just lately and roleplays absolutely constantly. I grew up storytelling on the fly, roleplaying in college, and doing my share of make believe as a kid, so I stepped right in to participate without thinking twice. When she wanted two imaginary friends over, I'd supply that they'd brought a cake or flowers or a toy, and I'd prompt her on how to be a good hostess. We've used it to try out new ways of dealing with anger (do you have to hit the dragon, or can you be friends?), to create safe havens, to practice social skills, and so on. I've also shamelessly used it to reconnect when we've had a falling out. For her the thought really counts, a pretend present is as good as the real deal. (Downside: DH didn't get it and "took away" a "present" she tried to give him when he was initiating a serious discipline talk and she broke into tears. Recently I gave her a purple tea cake after a bad falling out, and she threw it against the wall. Later she seemed to have forgotten about throwing it against the wall, and went to pick it up from the cupboard, aka my computer, and when I misinterpreted her andn closed the computer, she bawled. At least there was no clean up.)

I just thought some people might try it out.
post #2 of 9
Cool beans. I bet as you work out some of the wrinkles you end up able to fix all problems. At least until the next phase, .
post #3 of 9
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by sapphire_chan View Post
At least until the next phase, .
Tell me about it! No sooner do we have peace and cooperation from the toddler this evening, than the two of them (newborn and toddler) spend two hours tag teaming us with who is awake and who is asleep. Argh.
post #4 of 9
Discipline with make believe? I never tried it, and it never came to my mind that it is going to be effective. My kids are smart, and they easily recognize it when things are fake or not.
post #5 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by mort20 View Post
Discipline with make believe? I never tried it, and it never came to my mind that it is going to be effective. My kids are smart, and they easily recognize it when things are fake or not.
Did you read the whole post or just the title?
post #6 of 9
You might really enjoy Playful Parenting by Larry Cohen. This is a major theme in the book.

If you view discipline as 'teaching', then it makes sense. Play is a highly effective way to teach a child. And precisely because it is make-believe, the children can try out roles, ideas and responses that would be too scary or difficult to try out in more high stakes situations.

I remember getting very frustrated with ds because he would never say 'thank you' or 'sorry', and he was at an age where it was becoming expected by people around him. And then one day, we started playing a game where he would come running toward me, bump into me (gently) and run away. Somehow, part of the game evolved into him saying 'sorry' when he bumped into me. He must have said it 100 times in that short game! And slowly after that, he began to use it situations where he had actually caused offense, or hurt.
post #7 of 9
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by mort20 View Post
Discipline with make believe? I never tried it, and it never came to my mind that it is going to be effective. My kids are smart, and they easily recognize it when things are fake or not.
Good for me that my children are so stupid they can play make believe, isn't it?
post #8 of 9
Thread Starter 
On a completely snark-free note, I hadn't noticed this was bumped because I haven't felt the need to visit the GD forums. I'm not saying this has been a panacea, but I find myself "disciplining" DH and myself as often as the 3yo. I mean, she's so much better lately! For days on end! I still watch for triggers, but she's much better at articulating whatever is ailing her now. I've had more time to observe her positively and figure her out, with less damage control. If nothing else, this was worth it for how much more polite she's been! As a PP indicated, this is great for teaching courtesy. I'll have to check out the playful parenting thread.
post #9 of 9
I think that sounds really great! I'm going to remember this! I love make believe! I hope my dd does, too! That's neat that you figured that out with your dd!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › How To Discipline With Make Believe